Pictorial cigarette pack warnings: a meta-analysis of experimental studies.
Noar SM, Hall MG, Francis DB, Ribisl KM, Pepper JK, Brewer NT. · 2016
Read Pictorial cigarette pack warnings: a meta-analysis of experimental studies. by Noar SM, Hall MG, Francis DB, Ribisl KM, Pepper JK, Brewer NT. (2016) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4636492.txt.
Introduction
Seth M. Noar and colleagues published a 2016 meta-analysis of experiments on pictorial cigarette pack warnings. Many countries were weighing picture warnings against text-only ones. The team searched seven databases for controlled experiments that reported both formats. The work appeared in Tobacco Control.
Thirty-seven studies with 33,613 participants qualified. Picture warnings beat text on twelve of seventeen effectiveness measures. They held attention longer, stirred stronger thoughts and feelings, and soured attitudes toward packs and smoking. Intentions to avoid starting and to quit both rose. Participants also judged picture warnings as more effective on every perceived-effectiveness measure. The authors note that actual smoking behaviour was rarely measured, a gap for future studies.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Noar SM, Hall MG, Francis DB, Ribisl KM, Pepper JK, Brewer NT. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2016 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Pictorial cigarette pack warnings: a meta-analysis of experimental studies By Seth M Noar, Marissa G Hall, Diane B Francis, Kurt M Ribisl, Jessica K Pepper, Noel T Brewer Published in: Tobacco Control DOI: 10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2014-051978 ABSTRACT Objective To inform international research and policy, we conducted a meta-analysis of the experimental literature on pictorial cigarette pack warnings. Data sources We systematically searched 7 computerised databases in April 2013 using several search terms. We also searched reference lists of relevant articles. Study selection We included studies that used an experimental protocol to test cigarette pack warnings and reported data on both pictorial and text-only conditions. 37 studies with data on 48 independent samples (N=33 613) met criteria. Data extraction and synthesis Two independent coders coded all study characteristics. Effect sizes were computed from data extracted from study reports and were combined using random effects meta-analytic procedures. Results Pictorial warnings were more effective than text-only warnings for 12 of 17 effectiveness outcomes (all p<0.05). Relative to text-only warnings, pictorial warnings (1) attracted and held attention better; (2) garnered stronger cognitive and emotional reactions; (3) elicited more negative pack attitudes and negative smoking attitudes and (4) more effectively increased intentions to not start smoking and to quit smoking. Participants also perceived pictorial warnings as being more effective than text-only warnings across all 8 perceived effectiveness outcomes. Conclusions The evidence from this international body of literature supports pictorial cigarette pack warnings as more effective than text-only warnings. Gaps in the literature include a lack of assessment of smoking behaviour and a dearth of theory-based research on how warnings exert their effects. INTRODUCTION Tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable death and disease in the world, causing nearly six million deaths each year.1 While tobacco product packaging is a key part of marketing efforts to make tobacco use appealing,2 3 regulators can use that same packaging to communicate the health risks of tobacco products to consumers.4 A pack-a-day smoker potentially sees a cigarette pack an estimated 7300 times per year (20 views/day×365 days/year). Messages on these packs would generate exposure far outweighing exposure from other antitobacco communications, such as mass media campaigns.5 The combination of high exposure, nearly universal reach, and very low cost has made pictorial warnings on cigarette packs a core tobacco control strategy globally. The WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) calls for the implementation of large warnings on tobacco products.6 The treaty's Article 11 specifies that health warnings may include pictures, and subsequent guidelines for implementation state that pictorial warnings are ‘far more effective’ than text-only messages.6 By 2015, implementation of pictorial warning policies had occurred in 77 countries and jurisdictions that are home to nearly 50% of the world's population.7 As pictorial cigarette pack warnings have proliferated globally, so has research on their impact.8 9 Observational studies suggest increased cessation behaviour after the introduction of pictorial warnings,10 11 and such studies typically have high external validity. However, isolating the effects of pictorial warnings on smoking behaviour in such studies has proven difficult because governments often introduce the warnings alongside other tobacco control policies.8 12 By contrast, experiments can offer strong evidence of the causal impact of pictorial warnings, isolating the effects of warnings on key outcomes. For this reason, experiments are an important tool for studying the effects of pictorial warnings. Previous research on pictorial cigarette pack warnings A large and growing empirical literature has documented the effects of pictorial cigarette pack warnings. Some evidence suggests that pictures and imagery may be more effective than text-only messages at communicating health risks.13 14 Compared with text-only warnings, pictorial warnings have been associated with stronger beliefs about the harms of smoking and higher motivation to quit smoking.10 15–21 However, while some studies find that smokers and non-smokers rate pictorial warnings as more effective than text-only warnings,22–26 other studies have reported conflicting findings.27–29 For instance, studies have found that graphic, pictorial warnings result in poorer recall than less graphic or non-graphic warnings,28 do not increase youth's expectations to be non-smokers a year later,29 have no effect on beliefs about cancer or addiction among non-smoking adolescent boys,26 and are effective in lowering smoking intentions for Canadians but not for Americans.27 Reviews of the literature on pictorial cigarette pack warnings have taken a variety of approaches. A narrative review by Hammond8 suggested that cigarette pack warnings can be effective in promoting smoking cessation, especially when warnings are large, full-colour, and use graphic images. While useful and an important contribution for understanding pictorial warnings, this review did not provide a systematic, quantitative synthesis of pictorial warning effects. A systematic review by Monarrez-Espino et al30 examined 21 mostly observational studies of the impact of pictorial warnings on reduced smoking, quit attempts and smoking cessation. Monarrez-Espino et al found that most of these studies were of poor methodological quality; for this reason, their findings on the impact of pictorial warnings on smoking behaviour were inconclusive. Importantly, this review did not examine many factors that are likely pre-requisites to changes in behaviour, such as attention to warnings, cognitive and emotional reactions to warnings, and changes in beliefs about smoking. While these recent reviews have summarised portions of the cigarette pack warnings literature,8 9 30 no meta-analysis has synthesised the experimental literature on pictorial cigarette pack warnings. To inform international research and public policy, we conducted a meta-analysis of experiments examining the impact of pictorial cigarette pack warnings. Our research question was: across the body of experimental studies, what are the effects of pictorial cigarette pack warnings compared with text warnings? METHOD Search strategy We used a comprehensive search strategy to locate studies relevant to this meta-analysis. The search strategy involved three steps. First, we searched PsycINFO, PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science, Communication & Mass Media Complete, Business Source Complete, and CINAHL computerised databases in April 2013. We used the following Boolean terms: (cigarette* OR tobacco) AND (warning* OR label* OR pictorial OR graphic OR messag* OR text*). Second, we examined the reference sections of five narrative reviews of cigarette pack warnings.8 9 31–33 Third, we examined the reference lists of the final set of articles included in our review. We included all reports that came up in our searches—peer-reviewed journal articles, book chapters, and grey literature (eg, dissertations, publicly available reports)—as long as the full text was available. To be included, a study had to use an experimental protocol that tested warnings intended for cigarette packs. Studies had to report data on both a pictorial warning condition and a text-only condition. The experimental design could be between subjects (individuals were randomised to different warning label manipulation conditions—eg, text vs pictorial) or within subjects (individuals viewed multiple warning label manipulations). We excluded studies of non-cigarette tobacco products, public service announcements or multicomponent interventions, and warnings embedded in cigarette advertising. We excluded observational studies that asked individuals to report on warnings that they had seen on their own prior to the study. Finally, articles reporting the studies had to be available in English. Figure 1 depicts the search process. The initial database search yielded 14 139 total references, and searching through the other methods yielded 424 references. After removing duplicates, there were 8486 references. Two reviewers independently examined all study titles