Methods for sample size determination in cluster randomized trials.

Rutterford C, Copas A, Eldridge S. · 2015

Read Methods for sample size determination in cluster randomized trials. by Rutterford C, Copas A, Eldridge S. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4521133.txt.

Introduction

Clare Rutterford, Andrew Copas, and Sandra Eldridge explain how to size a certain kind of trial in the International Journal of Epidemiology in 2015. In cluster randomized trials, whole groups, such as clinics or villages, are assigned by chance rather than single people. Such trials are growing more common and more varied, which makes planning their size harder.

The basic fix is to size the trial as if people were assigned singly, then inflate the number by a design effect to cover the grouping. That shortcut rests on assumptions that often fail. The paper gives formulas and guidance for richer cases: uneven group sizes, dropouts, people not following their assignment, starting measures, and repeated measures. It serves both newcomers and seasoned planners.

Catalog record

CREATORRutterford C, Copas A, Eldridge S.
YEAR2015
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4521133

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Methods for sample size determination in cluster randomized trials By Clare Rutterford, Andrew Copas, Sandra Eldridge Published in: International Journal of Epidemiology DOI: 10.1093/ije/dyv113 ABSTRACT Abstract Background: The use of cluster randomized trials (CRTs) is increasing, along with the variety in their design and analysis. The simplest approach for their sample size calculation is to calculate the sample size assuming individual randomization and inflate this by a design effect to account for randomization by cluster. The assumptions of a simple design effect may not always be met; alternative or more complicated approaches are required. Methods: We summarise a wide range of sample size methods available for cluster randomized trials. For those familiar with sample size calculations for individually randomized trials but with less experience in the clustered case, this manuscript provides formulae for a wide range of scenarios with associated explanation and recommendations. For those with more experience, comprehensive summaries are provided that allow quick identification of methods for a given design, outcome and analysis method. Results: We present first those methods applicable to the simplest two-arm, parallel group, completely randomized design followed by methods that incorporate deviations from this design such as: variability in cluster sizes; attrition; non-compliance; or the inclusion of baseline covariates or repeated measures. The paper concludes with methods for alternative designs. Conclusions: There is a large amount of methodology available for sample size calculations in CRTs. This paper gives the most comprehensive description of published methodology for sample size calculation and provides an important resource for those designing these trials. Keywords: Sample size, cluster randomization, design effect Key MessagesThere is a large body of literature on sample size calculations for cluster randomized trials.There are relatively simple and accessible methods to allow for design complexities such as variable cluster sizes; time-to-event outcomes; incorporation of baseline values and cross-over, stepped-wedge and matched designs.This is the most comprehensive resource to date for sample size methods for cluster randomized trials.There is scope for further methodological development. INTRODUCTION Cluster randomized trials In a cluster randomized trial, groups or clusters, rather than individuals, are randomly allocated to intervention groups. This approach may be deemed necessary; if randomization at individual level is impractical, to avoid contamination between treatment groups, i.e. individuals in the control arm being exposed to the intervention; or for administrative or cost advantages. The rationale for cluster randomized trials has been described in detail elsewhere.1–10 The responses from individuals within a cluster are likely to be more similar than those from different clusters. This is because individuals within a cluster may share similar characteristics or be exposed to the same external factors associated with membership to a particular cluster. This lack of independence introduces complexity to the design and analysis. The degree of similarity, or clustering, is commonly quantified by the intracluster correlation coefficient (ICC) denoted in this article as ρ. Obtaining a good sample size estimate is particularly important in cluster randomized trials due to the large cost that can be associated with recruiting an additional cluster as compared with recruiting an additional subject in an individually randomized trial. Equally important are the ethical implications of over- or under-recruitment where the addition or loss of one cluster may equate to a large number of individuals potentially being exposed to the risk of treatment, or lost. A simple approach to sample size calculation A consequence of clustering is that the information gained is less than that in an individually randomized trial of the same size, making randomization by cluster less efficient. This inefficiency was identified in the seminal paper by Cornfield that sparked the development of methodology for the design and analysis of cluster randomized trials.11 It has been proposed by Donner, Birkett and Buck that a sample size calculated assuming individual randomization can be inflated by a Design Effect (DE) to reach the required level of statistical power under cluster randomization:12 [formula: (1)DE=1+(n−1)ρ] where n is the number of individuals per cluster and ρ the ICC. Therefore for a comparison of means, in a two-arm trial with equal allocation the required the number of individuals per group, m, is calculated as: [formula: (2)m=(Z1−α/2+Z1−β)2 2σ2Δ2(1+(n−1)ρ)] where Zx is the x’th percentage point of the standard normal distribution, Δ the clinically important difference in treatment means and σ2 the variance in the outcome. Analyses may be conducted at either the cluster or individual level (see Eldridge and Kerry for a full discussion of analysis methods1) In cluster-level analyses, a cluster-level summary is calculated for each cluster, effectively reducing the data to one observation per cluster. The observations can then be treated as independent, and standard statistical analysis methods applied. The main advantages of cluster-level analyses are their simplicity and applicability to different types of outcomes. Disadvantages of this approach are that individual-level covariates cannot be included and the number of observations per group may be small. However, the two-sample t-test has been shown to be quite robust to deviations from normality and a small number of clusters per treatment group.13 Methods that use individual-level data but adjust for clustering can be used for analysis, such as the adjusted chi-square method for binary data, the adjusted two-sample t-test2 or the non-parametric clustered Wilcoxon test for continuous data.14 In this article, these are referred to as adjusted tests. The main drawback to these methods is that they do not allow for the inclusion of covariates. Commonly individual-level analyses are conducted using a regression model that accounts for the clustered nature of the data and may include either cluster or individual level covariates. Mixed effects regression models are a cluster-specific method (henceforth referred to as mixed models) and Generalised Estimating Equations (GEE), a type of population-averaged or marginal method. Both approaches require a sufficient number of clusters for optimal performance; when the number of clusters is small, the mixed model is less biased than the GEE. The difference between these two approaches lies in the interpretation of the estimated treatment effect.1 In general, sample size requirements depend upon the proposed analysis method. In this paper we describe each sample size method alongside the analysis method for which it was designed. However, alternative analysis approaches may also be suitable. For example, with continuous outcomes a cluster-level analysis is equivalent to an individual-level analysis if all the clusters are the same size. When cluster size is variable, the assumptions underlying the cluster-level t-test are not met and a weighted t-test must be used to achieve adequate power and precision. Individual-level analyses naturally incorporate this weighting and so are more efficient than cluster-level analyses weighted by cluster size.4 For continuous outcomes and equal-sized clusters, the cluster-specific and population-averaged methods for individual-level analyses are mathematically equivalent. For binary outcomes, due to the transformation of the data onto the logistic scale, the treatment effects calculated under the cluster-specific and population-averaged methods are different. For binary outcomes, Austin et al.15 compared the performance of three cluster-level methods: the t-test, the Wilcoxon rank-sum test and the permutation test, and three individual-level methods: the adjusted chi-square test, the mixed effects model and the GEE model. In the scenarios investigated, which included variable cluster sizes, the difference in power between these methods was negligible. Measuring variability between clusters A key parameter common

Read the complete text