Multiple imputation of covariates by fully conditional specification: Accommodating the substantive model.
Bartlett JW, Seaman SR, White IR, Carpenter JR, Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative*. · 2015
Read Multiple imputation of covariates by fully conditional specification: Accommodating the substantive model. by Bartlett JW, Seaman SR, White IR, Carpenter JR, Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative*. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4513015.txt.
Introduction
Jonathan W. Bartlett, Shaun R. Seaman, Ian R. White, and James R. Carpenter wrote a 2015 statistics paper on filling gaps in medical data. Studies often lose some values, and multiple imputation fills each gap several times to gauge the doubt. Trouble starts when the final model bends, with squared terms or crossed effects, while the filling models stay straight and clash with it.
The group adjusted a popular filling method, fully conditional specification, so each filled value comes from a model that fits the final analysis model. Computer trials with fake data showed the fix gives steady estimates for common models, as long as data are missing at random and the filling models are right. Free Stata software carrying the method comes with the paper.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bartlett JW, Seaman SR, White IR, Carpenter JR, Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative*. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2015 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multiple imputation of covariates by fully conditional specification: Accommodating the substantive model By Jonathan W Bartlett, Shaun R Seaman, Ian R White, James R Carpenter, Michael G Kenward Published in: Statistical Methods in Medical Research DOI: 10.1177/0962280214521348 ABSTRACT Missing covariate data commonly occur in epidemiological and clinical research, and are often dealt with using multiple imputation. Imputation of partially observed covariates is complicated if the substantive model is non-linear (e.g. Cox proportional hazards model), or contains non-linear (e.g. squared) or interaction terms, and standard software implementations of multiple imputation may impute covariates from models that are incompatible with such substantive models. We show how imputation by fully conditional specification, a popular approach for performing multiple imputation, can be modified so that covariates are imputed from models which are compatible with the substantive model. We investigate through simulation the performance of this proposal, and compare it with existing approaches. Simulation results suggest our proposal gives consistent estimates for a range of common substantive models, including models which contain non-linear covariate effects or interactions, provided data are missing at random and the assumed imputation models are correctly specified and mutually compatible. Stata software implementing the approach is freely available. 1 INTRODUCTION Missing data are a pervasive problem in both experimental and observational medical research, causing a loss of information and potentially biasing inferences. In this article, we focus on settings in which interest lies in fitting a substantive model relating an outcome to a number of covariates, one or more of which have missing values. The method of multiple imputation (MI) has become an extremely popular approach for accommodating missing data in statistical analyses, both generally1 and in the specific context of partially observed covariates.2 MI involves ‘filling in’ each missing value with draws from an appropriate distribution, leading to a number M of completed datasets. The substantive model can then be fitted to each of the M completed datasets, and the results combined across the M datasets using Rubin’s rules,3 which account for the uncertainty due to the fact data have been imputed. MI is most often applied under the missing at random (MAR) assumption, which stipulates that the probability that data are missing are independent of the missing values, conditional on the observed data, although MI can also be used when data are missing not at random.3 Parametric MI as originally proposed is based on a joint imputation model for the partially observed variables (conditional on any fully observed variables), which we refer to as ‘joint model MI’. A popular alternative to joint model MI is the fully conditional specification (FCS) approach.4,5 FCS MI involves specifying a series of univariate models for the conditional distribution of each partially observed variable given the other variables. This permits a great deal of flexibility, since an appropriate regression model can be selected for each variable (e.g. linear regression for continuous variables, logistic regression for binary variables). Consequently, FCS MI is particularly appealing in settings in which a number of variables have missing data, some of which are continuous and some of which are discrete. One of the strengths of MI is that it divides the process of dealing with missingness (the imputation stage) from the analysis of the completed data (the analysis stage). As has been previously discussed in detail, this division presents both opportunities and threats.6–9. For example, we may be able to include so-called auxiliary variables in the imputation model which are not used in the analysis stage. This offers the potential for increased efficiency and may also improve the plausibility of the MAR assumption holding, by conditioning on auxiliary variables which are predictive of missingness. Sometimes the imputer and analyst will be different people. If the imputer has additional knowledge which enables him to impose (correct) additional assumptions in the imputation model, the analyst will gain efficiency. The division may however sometimes lead to problems. In the context of imputing partially observed covariates, imputations might be generated from a model which is incompatible with the substantive model, which may lead to (asymptotically) biased estimates of parameters in the latter. Two conditional models are said to be incompatible if there exists no joint model for which the conditionals (for the relevant variables) equal these conditional models. This is a particular issue when the substantive model contains non-linear covariate effects or interactions, with which default imputation model choices may be incompatible. For example, suppose the substantive model is the linear regression of Y on a continuous covariate X and X2, and we wish to impute missing values in X. The default choice for the imputation model for X|Y in software for MI is a normal linear model, with conditional mean equal to a linear function of Y, which is incompatible with the quadratic substantive model. Following imputation of X, X2 is then passively imputed by squaring the imputed X values. In this case, estimates of the parameters of the substantive model from multiply imputed datasets will be biased (unless the quadratic coefficient is in truth zero), because within the subset of data where X has been imputed the association between X and Y is linear as a consequence of assuming linearity in the imputation model.10 Incompatibility between the imputation and substantive models can be avoided by specifying a joint model for outcome and covariates for which the conditional distribution of outcome given covariates matches the substantive model and then using the imputation model implied by this joint model. However, specification of a joint model is challenging when there are a number of partially observed covariates, particularly when some are continuous and some are discrete. In this setting, the FCS method is an attractive option. However, the default univariate imputation models used in FCS may be incompatible with the substantive model. In this article, we therefore propose a modification of the popular FCS approach to MI which ensures that each of the univariate imputation models is compatible with the assumed substantive model. We begin in Section 2 by introducing a motivating example from the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI). In Section 3, we formally define compatibility between an imputation model for partially observed covariates and a substantive model, explain when incompatibility implies imputation model mis-specification and give examples of when this occurs. We then outline how imputation models can be specified which are compatible with a given substantive model within the joint modelling approach to MI, which motivates our modification of the FCS MI approach. In Section 4, we briefly review the standard FCS framework for MI in the setting of partially observed covariates. In Section 5, we describe our modification of the FCS MI approach which ensures that each univariate imputation model is compatible with the substantive model. In Section 6 we give details for how this can be done when the model of interest is (i) normal linear regression, (ii) a model for a discrete outcome (e.g. logistic and Poisson regression) or (iii) a proportional hazards model. We report the results of a simulation study to investigate the performance of our proposed approach in Section 7. In Section 8, we apply our proposed approach to the motivating example. In Section 9, we discuss how our proposed approach can be used when,