The contribution of interindividual factors to variability of response in transcranial direct current stimulation studies.

Li LM, Uehara K, Hanakawa T. · 2015

Read The contribution of interindividual factors to variability of response in transcranial direct current stimulation studies. by Li LM, Uehara K, Hanakawa T. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4428123.txt.

Introduction

Lucia Li, Kazumasa Uehara, and Takashi Hanakawa reviewed in Frontiers in Cellular Neuroscience in 2015 why brain stimulation results vary so much between people. The method they discuss, transcranial direct current stimulation, passes a weak current through the scalp. Reports claim gains from stroke recovery to memory, yet effect sizes swing widely and some studies contradict each other.

Person-level factors may explain much of that spread. The starting state of brain cells, head and brain anatomy, age, and the damage left by injury all shape the response, the authors argue. Variability also enters through the magnetic pulse tests used to measure motor effects. Their review urges researchers to plan for these differences rather than treat mixed results as simple failure or success.

Catalog record

CREATORLi LM, Uehara K, Hanakawa T.
YEAR2015
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4428123

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The contribution of interindividual factors to variability of response in transcranial direct current stimulation studies By Lucia M. Li, Kazumasa Uehara, Takashi Hanakawa Published in: Frontiers in Cellular Neuroscience DOI: 10.3389/fncel.2015.00181 ABSTRACT There has been an explosion of research using transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) for investigating and modulating human cognitive and motor function in healthy populations. It has also been used in many studies seeking to improve deficits in disease populations. With the slew of studies reporting “promising results” for everything from motor recovery after stroke to boosting memory function, one could be easily seduced by the idea of tDCS being the next panacea for all neurological ills. However, huge variability exists in the reported effects of tDCS, with great variability in the effect sizes and even contradictory results reported. In this review, we consider the interindividual factors that may contribute to this variability. In particular, we discuss the importance of baseline neuronal state and features, anatomy, age and the inherent variability in the injured brain. We additionally consider how interindividual variability affects the results of motor-evoked potential (MEP) testing with transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), which, in turn, can lead to apparent variability in response to tDCS in motor studies. INTRODUCTION Non-invasive brain stimulation (NIBS) techniques, in particular transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), have become increasingly popular methods for temporary modulation of behavior. However, there is increasing recognition of the high variability in the reported effects of tDCS, even when using the same stimulation parameters, making the effect of tDCS on behavior and cognition anything but predictable (Jacobson et al., 2012; Horvath et al., 2014a, 2015; López-Alonso et al., 2014; Wiethoff et al., 2014; Strube et al., 2015a). The observed effect of tDCS is dependent on the electrical dose administered, the biological response to that dose, and the way that response is assessed. Electrical dose is defined by “what is externally applied (and therefore fully controlled) rather than by any physiologic or behavioral response to stimulation” (Peterchev et al., 2012). There is lack of standardization in the electrical dose administered across studies, particularly in the cognitive field but even in the motor field where recommended protocols exist (Nitsche and Paulus, 2000, 2001). This significantly affects reproducibility of study results. Recent papers have also highlighted several other issues with tDCS research, which can confound outcomes, such as blinding techniques, task (outcome assessment) selection and absence of proper control conditions (Jacobson et al., 2012; Horvath et al., 2014a; de Aguiar et al., 2015). However, the factors affecting biological response to electrical current, and causing interindividual variability in response to tDCS, are highly important yet under-appreciated. Understanding the biological response to tDCS is both crucial for developing tDCS for wider use and for providing insights into neurophysiological function. Early animal studies have demonstrated that anodal stimulation increases neuronal excitability whilst cathodal stimulation decreases neuronal excitability (e.g., Purpura and McMurtry, 1965), and later Nitsche and colleagues confirmed this effect in the human primary motor cortex (M1) (Nitsche and Paulus, 2000; Stagg and Nitsche, 2011). The majority of subsequent tDCS protocols have been based on this premise – anodal stimulation causing neuronal, and therefore behavioral, facilitation, with cathodal stimulation causing the opposite. However, a recent meta-analysis of tDCS studies found that the probability of achieving the classical “anodal-facilitatory/cathodal-inhibitory” effect on motor outcomes was only 0.67, and for cognitive outcomes only 0.16 (Jacobson et al., 2012). It is becoming increasingly clear that this classical view of a dichotomous tDCS effect is far too simplistic. The pitfalls of an excessively simplistic view have been seen with other brain stimulation techniques, such as transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS). For example, we now recognize that repetitive or patterned TMS protocols aimed at inducing neuroplasticity does not always have the “classical effect” in all participants (Müller-Dahlhaus et al., 2008; Ridding and Ziemann, 2010; Hamada et al., 2013; Hinder et al., 2014; López-Alonso et al., 2014). Studies specifically setting out to address the underlying physiological reasons for this variation have found numerous factors, including age, genetic polymorphisms, and variability in inhibitory circuitry (Cheeran et al., 2008; Ridding and Ziemann, 2010; Hamada et al., 2013). The variability in reported results is therefore likely to arise from variability in stimulation protocols, interindividual variability and the interaction of the two. Understanding the contribution of protocol variability to the observed results in the tDCS literature is also crucial for deciphering the impact of interindividual variability to tDCS response. This topic is worthy of extensive review and investigation in itself and is outside the scope of this review. In this review, we focus on interindividual biological differences that can confound tDCS studies, that is, factors which would cause variability in behavioral responses even under identical electrical doses. In particular, we discuss neurophysiological state and features, anatomy, genetics, age, the injured brain and also the variability introduced by TMS assessment techniques. We will primarily consider the evidence from healthy subjects in both motor and cognitive tDCS studies, and also discuss the special case of the injured brain. We make suggestions for how studies can address interindividual variability and how future research can investigate this important issue. LITERATURE SEARCH STRATEGY There are extremely few published studies specifically addressing interindividual variability in tDCS so a specific literature search was not possible. Instead, we searched PubMed with “transcranial direct current stimulation” as a MeSH® term and also as a string, as well as performing searches with the following strings: “tDCS anatomy,” “tDCS genetics,” “tDCS task,” “tDCS age,” “tDCS GABA,” “tDCS dopamine,” “tDCS injury,” “tDCS stroke.” Relevant papers were identified by all authors, and reference lists were examined for any other relevant studies. ANATOMY Interindividual differences in cranial and brain anatomy can influence the impact of tDCS by creating variability in the actual current received by the brain, even when the same electrical dose is administered. The distribution and extent of current density is the most common measure for assessing this current received by the brain, and computer simulations based on anatomical data have provided useful insights into how the factors which modulate current density. A comprehensive discussion of the development of such simulations is outside the scope of this paper and is reviewed in detail elsewhere (Bikson et al., 2012, 2013; Wagner et al., 2014). Simulation studies modeling factors derived from individual neuroimaging have demonstrated that gross anatomical features and microarchitectural features influence current distribution (Bikson et al., 2012; Datta et al., 2012a). These factors include: skull thickness (Opitz et al., 2015), cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) thickness (Opitz et al., 2015), subcutaneous fat (Truong et al., 2013), gyral pattern (Datta et al., 2012a; Halko et al., 2012; Opitz et al., 2015), local tissue heterogeneities (Shahid et al., 2012; Russell et al., 2013), and orientation of neurons (Arlotti et al., 2012). Moreover, a recent study modeled the current density induced by an electrode over the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (dlPFC), and found that the improvement in a working memory task correlated with the simulated current density, suggesting that the work from simulations has real functional relevance (Kim et al., 2014a). Cortical anatomy shows high variability in gyrus and sulcus patterns between individuals (Ono et al., 1990), and is likely to produce high interindividual variability in tDCS response (Rademacher et al., 1993). This

Read the complete text