Multivariable Mendelian randomization: the use of pleiotropic genetic variants to estimate causal effects.

Burgess S, Thompson SG. · 2015

Read Multivariable Mendelian randomization: the use of pleiotropic genetic variants to estimate causal effects. by Burgess S, Thompson SG. (2015) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4325677.txt.

Introduction

Stephen Burgess and Simon G Thompson extend Mendelian randomization, a method that uses genes as natural experiments to judge cause and effect. Their paper appeared in the American Journal of Epidemiology in 2015. The classic method needs a gene variant tied to one risk factor only, but many variants touch several related factors at once, a property called pleiotropy.

Blood fats are the running example: variants that move triglycerides usually move other lipids too. The multivariable method uses several variants across several measured risk factors to estimate each factor's causal effect at the same time. The paper sets out the assumptions and the math. It widens causal inference to risk factors that could never be separated before.

Catalog record

CREATORBurgess S, Thompson SG.
YEAR2015
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4325677

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multivariable Mendelian Randomization: The Use of Pleiotropic Genetic Variants to Estimate Causal Effects By Stephen Burgess, Simon G Thompson Published in: American Journal of Epidemiology DOI: 10.1093/aje/kwu283 ABSTRACT Abstract A conventional Mendelian randomization analysis assesses the causal effect of a risk factor on an outcome by using genetic variants that are solely associated with the risk factor of interest as instrumental variables. However, in some cases, such as the case of triglyceride level as a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, it may be difficult to find a relevant genetic variant that is not also associated with related risk factors, such as other lipid fractions. Such a variant is known as pleiotropic. In this paper, we propose an extension of Mendelian randomization that uses multiple genetic variants associated with several measured risk factors to simultaneously estimate the causal effect of each of the risk factors on the outcome. This “multivariable Mendelian randomization” approach is similar to the simultaneous assessment of several treatments in a factorial randomized trial. In this paper, methods for estimating the causal effects are presented and compared using real and simulated data, and the assumptions necessary for a valid multivariable Mendelian randomization analysis are discussed. Subject to these assumptions, we demonstrate that triglyceride-related pathways have a causal effect on the risk of coronary heart disease independent of the effects of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol. Keywords: causal inference, epidemiologic methods, instrumental variables, lipid fractions, Mendelian randomization, pleiotropy Mendelian randomization employs genetic variants as instrumental variables to estimate the causal effect of a risk factor on an outcome using observational data, even in the presence of unmeasured confounding (1, 2). A genetic variable is a valid instrumental variable if - the variant is associated with the risk factor of interest, - the variant is not associated with any confounder of the risk factor–outcome association, and - the variant is conditionally independent of the outcome given the risk factor and confounders (3, 4). These assumptions can be illustrated using a causal directed acyclic graph, displaying a causal effect of one variable on another by an arrow and the absence of a direct causal effect by the lack of an arrow (Figure 1) (5). Although a genetic variant need not be causally associated with the risk factor to be a valid instrumental variable, we assume that there exists a causal variant for which the measured variant is a proxy (6). [Figure: Mendelian randomization assumptions for variant G with risk factor X in a confounded association with outcome Y. Confounders represented by U are assumed to be unknown.] In order to avoid violations of the second and third instrumental-variable assumptions, Mendelian randomization experiments have generally relied on genetic variants which are associated with a single risk factor. In practice, however, many variants are pleiotropic—that is, associated with multiple risk factors. Indeed, in some cases, there may be no variants which are solely associated with the risk factor of interest, and a Mendelian randomization analysis cannot be performed without considering pleiotropic variants. In any case, it may desirable to include information on pleiotropic variants in order to provide a more powerful analysis, provided that this does not prejudice its validity. It may also be that multiple quantitative traits relating to the same risk factor are of interest; for example, in cardiovascular disease, the concentration of lipoprotein(a) and the size of lipoprotein(a) particles (7). In this case, the relative proportions of risk reduction associated with interventions separately targeting lipoprotein(a) concentrations and the size of lipoprotein(a) particles may be of interest, and the traits may be regarded as independent risk factors, even if the same genetic variants influence both traits. The possibility of including multiple risk factors in an instrumental-variable analysis is discussed in many econometric textbooks (8), and applied instrumental-variable analyses involving multiple risk factors have been performed (9, 10), but we are unaware of any application of the approach in genetic epidemiology. The context of this paper is that there are measurements on multiple genetic variants and several associated risk factors, the causal effect of at least 1 of which on the outcome is of interest. We assume that the genetic variants do not influence the outcome via any pathway except those fully mediated by one of the measured risk factors or by some combination of the measured risk factors. Questions about variants with potentially unmeasured or unknown pleiotropic associations are reserved for the Discussion section. We initially discuss how pleiotropic associations may arise and the methods and assumptions necessary for estimating causal effects with several risk factors. We demonstrate the use of these methods in an applied example and then construct a simulation study with parameters chosen to be similar to those in the example to investigate how the methods perform. Finally, we discuss the application of the methods in epidemiologic practice and the interpretation of the applied example. METHODS Mechanisms for association with multiple risk factors There are several causal mechanisms by which a genetic variant may be associated with multiple risk factors (11). We divide the possible mechanisms into 2 cases (Figure 2): 1) vertical pleiotropy, where a variant is associated with multiple risk factors due to the causal effect of the primary risk factor on a secondary trait, and 2) functional pleiotropy, where the genetic variant is associated with multiple pathways. These 2 cases are not mutually exclusive; it is possible for both of them to exist for the same variant. [Figure: Causal directed acyclic graph illustrating vertical (A) and functional (B) pleiotropy in associations between variant G, risk factors X1 and X2, and outcome Y.] In the case of vertical pleiotropy, genetic variants associated with the primary risk factor would be expected to show consistent associations with the secondary trait. For example, genetic variants associated with higher body mass index (weight (kg)/height (m)2) would be expected to show a consistent association with higher blood pressure. In this case, the causal effect of body mass index on the outcome would include an indirect effect, mediated through blood pressure, as well as a direct effect comprising all other pathways from body mass index to the outcome that are not operating via blood pressure. If it is assumed that the only pathway by which the genetic variants are associated with the secondary trait is via the primary risk factor, then a simple Mendelian randomization analysis would consistently estimate the causal effect of the primary risk factor on the outcome in spite of the apparent pleiotropic association. In the case of functional pleiotropy, we suppose there are multiple genetic variants (at least as many variants as there are risk factors) which have different magnitudes of effect on the risk factors. These genetic variants can be used to estimate the causal effects of each risk factor even if none of the variants are specifically associated with any 1 particular risk factor. Since Mendelian randomization is analogous to a randomized trial (12), the use of genetic variants to assess the causal effects of multiple risk factors in a single study is analogous to a factorial randomized trial (see Web Figure 1, available at http://aje.oxfordjournals.org/), where multiple randomized interventions are simultaneously assessed (13). We refer to such an analysis as “multivariable Mendelian randomization.”

Read the complete text