Evaluation of the lung cancer risks at which to screen ever- and never-smokers: screening rules applied to the PLCO and NLST cohorts.

Tammemägi MC, Church TR, Hocking WG, Silvestri GA, Kvale PA, Riley TL, Commins J, Berg CD. · 2014

Read Evaluation of the lung cancer risks at which to screen ever- and never-smokers: screening rules applied to the PLCO and NLST cohorts. by Tammemägi MC, Church TR, Hocking WG, Silvestri GA, Kvale PA, Riley TL, Commins J, Berg CD. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4251899.txt.

Introduction

Martin C. Tammemägi, Christine D. Berg, and seven co-authors worked out who should get lung cancer screening in PLoS Medicine in 2014. CT screening cuts lung cancer deaths in heavy smokers, but programs picked candidates by simple age and smoking cut-offs, or by broader task force rules. A risk model might choose better, if a fair threshold could be set.

Applying the PLCOm2012 risk model to two large trial cohorts, the team found benefit was consistent above a six-year risk of about 1.5 percent. That rule screened 8.8 percent fewer people than the task force criteria yet caught 12.4 percent more cancers, with fewer false alarms. For never-smokers, no one in the large cohort crossed the threshold, so the authors advise against screening them for now.

Catalog record

CREATORTammemägi MC, Church TR, Hocking WG, Silvestri GA, Kvale PA, Riley TL, Commins J, Berg CD.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4251899

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evaluation of the Lung Cancer Risks at Which to Screen Ever- and Never-Smokers: Screening Rules Applied to the PLCO and NLST Cohorts By Martin C Tammemägi, Timothy R Church, William G Hocking, Gerard A Silvestri, Paul A Kvale, Thomas L Riley, John Commins, Christine D Berg, Malek Massad Published in: PLoS Medicine DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001764 ABSTRACT Martin Tammemägi and colleagues evaluate which risk groups of individuals, including nonsmokers and high-risk individuals from 65 to 80 years of age, should be screened for lung cancer using computed tomography. Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary INTRODUCTION The National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) demonstrated that annual low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) screening reduces lung cancer mortality by 20% when applied to high-risk smokers (age 55–74 y, ≥30 pack-years, and <15 y of quit time [for former smokers, time since ceasing smoking]) [1]. Consequently, several institutions have recommended LDCT lung cancer screening of high-risk populations [2]–[7], and many health-care institutions have started or are planning LDCT screening programs. Most recommendations and programs rely on NLST risk criteria or variants of these criteria for selecting individuals for screening [8]. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends annual screening of high-risk individuals, i.e., those who are 55–80 y, have smoked ≥30 pack-years, and have <15 y of smoking quit time [9]. Some of these criteria, which are similar to the NLST criteria, were based on microsimulation models developed by the Cancer Intervention and Surveillance Modeling Network (CISNET) lung group [10]. However, it has been shown that selecting individuals for screening based on accurate lung cancer risk prediction models is significantly more sensitive in detecting individuals who will be diagnosed with lung cancer and would save more lives than using the NLST criteria [11],[12]. Important issues regarding selection of individuals for lung cancer screening remain. It is unclear at what risk individuals should be screened, how efficient the USPSTF criteria are compared to model-based risk criteria, and into what risk threshold USPSTF recommendations translate. Never-smokers have been excluded from lung cancer screening trials and programs, but this has not been based on quantitative evidence. Lung cancer in never-smokers is a major public health problem, accounting for approximately 10%–15% of lung cancers, and if considered separately, would rank seventh as a cause of cancer death [13],[14]. Although a survey found that a sizeable proportion of never-smokers would consider computed tomography (CT) screening [15], it has not been demonstrated that never-smokers can be at high enough risk to warrant screening. In the United States on April 30, 2014, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services convened the Medicare Evidence Development & Coverage Advisory Committee (MEDCAC) to evaluate the use of LDCT lung cancer screening in the Medicare population, primarily aged 65 y and older [16]. The MEDCAC panel gave low confidence scores for screening, and if its recommendation is followed, Medicare will not reimburse the cost of lung cancer screening in those 65 y and older. In contrast, because the USPSTF gave LDCT lung cancer screening a “B recommendation” in favor of screening high-risk individuals, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act will lead to reimbursement for screening of high-risk individuals aged 55–64 y. The impact of these discordant strategies is unclear. In the current study, we extend evaluation and application of our PLCOm2012 model [11]. It is a logistic regression lung cancer risk prediction model based on 6-y incidence of lung cancer occurring in smokers in the control arm of the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial (PLCO). The model consists of four smoking variables (smoking intensity, smoking duration, quit time in former smokers, and current smoking status [current versus former]) and seven non-smoking variables (age, race/ethnicity, socioeconomic circumstance estimated by education level, body mass index, personal history of cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, family history of lung cancer). The PLCOm2012 model demonstrated high predictive performance, both discrimination and calibration, in external validation in PLCO intervention arm smokers. This study further analyzes data from two major screening trials, the NLST and PLCO. Our study aims are as follows: (1) identify a risk threshold for selecting lung cancer screenees based on the PLCOm2012 [11] risk at which mortality rates in the NLST CT screening arm are consistently lower than those in the chest X-ray (CXR) screening arm; (2) compare performance of USPSTF versus PLCOm2012 risk criteria for selecting screenees, based on lung cancer incidence and mortality; (3) as an alternate PLCOm2012 risk threshold, estimate the PLCOm2012 risk that selects a proportion of smokers equal to that selected by USPSTF criteria; (4) determine whether high-risk never-smokers exceed screening risk thresholds and thus might be considered for screening; and (5) compare the PLCOm2012 risks and lung cancer rates in high-risk PLCO smokers aged 54–64 y versus ≥65–80 y. METHODS Design Overview, Setting, and Participants PLCO and NLST study designs and results have been described previously [1],[17]–[21]. For both trials, institutional review board approvals were obtained at all study centers, and written informed consent was obtained from all participants. In this study we use PLCO (control arm n = 77,455, CXR arm n = 77,445) and NLST (CXR arm n = 26,730, CT arm n = 26,722) data. This study included histologically confirmed lung cancers and lung cancer deaths, which were identified from medical record reviews, death certificates, and National Death Index retrieval, and a death review committee classified causes of death. Predictor variable data were collected through epidemiological questionnaires administered at baseline. Statistical Analysis We determined two different thresholds for using PLCOm2012 risk to identify screening candidates. For the first, we determined the PLCOm2012 risk threshold above which lung cancer mortality rates in the NLST CT arm appear to be consistently lower than those in the NLST CXR arm (named TPLCOm2012). This yields a threshold above which there is reliable evidence of mortality benefit. As an alternative threshold, we applied the USPSTF criteria to the PLCO intervention (CXR) arm smokers and estimated the proportion of the cohort that would be selected for screening. We then found the PLCOm2012 risk threshold that identified a proportion of smokers equivalent to that of the USPSTF criteria (named TUSPSTF). If one planned to screen the same proportion of the population as recommended by the USPSTF but using PLCOm2012 risk to select screenees, then it seems reasonable to use TUSPSTF. For TPLCOm2012 and TUSPSTF, we estimated the sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive values (PPVs) for lung cancer incident cases and deaths using PLCO intervention arm participants, and compared them to those observed for the USPSTF criteria. Because the PLCOm2012 model was developed in the PLCO control arm smokers, using the PLCO intervention arm smokers for comparisons with USPSTF criteria made for fairer comparisons. Although the PLCO age criteria for enrollment were similar to those in the NLST (ages 55 to 74 y inclusive), 14,678 of 40,447 (36.3%) of PLCO intervention arm smokers with exit time data contributed follow-up times for age range 75–80 y (USPSTF age criteria difference from NLST criteria), and these data were included in this analysis, making possible some evaluation of the USPSTF criteria. The PLCOm2012 model was developed using lung cancer incidence occurring in 6 y of follow-up so as to make it applicable to NLST participants,

Read the complete text