Choosing and using diversity indices: insights for ecological applications from the German Biodiversity Exploratories.
Morris EK, Caruso T, Buscot F, Fischer M, Hancock C, Maier TS, Meiners T, Müller C, Obermaier E, Prati D, Socher SA, Sonnemann I, Wäschke N, Wubet T, Wurst S, Rillig MC. · 2014
Read Choosing and using diversity indices: insights for ecological applications from the German Biodiversity Exploratories. by Morris EK, Caruso T, Buscot F, Fischer M, Hancock C, Maier TS, Meiners T, Müller C, Obermaier E, Prati D, Socher SA, Sonnemann I, Wäschke N, Wubet T, Wurst S, Rillig MC. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4224527.txt.
Introduction
E. Kathryn Morris, Markus Fischer, and ten co-authors compared biodiversity measures in Ecology and Evolution in 2014. Ecologists compress species counts into diversity indices, but there is no agreement on which index suits which job. The team used a German grassland research program to test the favourites side by side.
Around stands of the plant Plantago lanceolata on 60 grassland plots, they computed richness, Shannon, Simpson, and dominance indices. The indices covered plants, fungi, above-ground arthropods, soil larvae, and the plant's own molecular and chemical variety. In path models, compound indices caught more links between the diversity of different groups than plain counts did. Trait-based diversity behaved much like species diversity. The paper gives practical guidance on picking an index to match the question asked.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Morris EK, Caruso T, Buscot F, Fischer M, Hancock C, Maier TS, Meiners T, Müller C, Obermaier E, Prati D, Socher SA, Sonnemann I, Wäschke N, Wubet T, Wurst S, Rillig MC. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2014 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Choosing and using diversity indices: insights for ecological applications from the German Biodiversity Exploratories By E Kathryn Morris, Tancredi Caruso, François Buscot, Markus Fischer, Christine Hancock, Tanja S Maier, Torsten Meiners, Caroline Müller, Elisabeth Obermaier, Daniel Prati, Stephanie A Socher, Ilja Sonnemann Published in: Ecology and Evolution DOI: 10.1002/ece3.1155 ABSTRACT Abstract Biodiversity, a multidimensional property of natural systems, is difficult to quantify partly because of the multitude of indices proposed for this purpose. Indices aim to describe general properties of communities that allow us to compare different regions, taxa, and trophic levels. Therefore, they are of fundamental importance for environmental monitoring and conservation, although there is no consensus about which indices are more appropriate and informative. We tested several common diversity indices in a range of simple to complex statistical analyses in order to determine whether some were better suited for certain analyses than others. We used data collected around the focal plant Plantago lanceolata on 60 temperate grassland plots embedded in an agricultural landscape to explore relationships between the common diversity indices of species richness (S), Shannon’s diversity (H’), Simpson’s diversity (D1), Simpson’s dominance (D2), Simpson’s evenness (E), and Berger–Parker dominance (BP). We calculated each of these indices for herbaceous plants, arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, aboveground arthropods, belowground insect larvae, and P. lanceolata molecular and chemical diversity. Including these trait-based measures of diversity allowed us to test whether or not they behaved similarly to the better studied species diversity. We used path analysis to determine whether compound indices detected more relationships between diversities of different organisms and traits than more basic indices. In the path models, more paths were significant when using H’, even though all models except that with E were equally reliable. This demonstrates that while common diversity indices may appear interchangeable in simple analyses, when considering complex interactions, the choice of index can profoundly alter the interpretation of results. Data mining in order to identify the index producing the most significant results should be avoided, but simultaneously considering analyses using multiple indices can provide greater insight into the interactions in a system. Keywords: Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, arthropods, Berger–Parker, chemical diversity, Hill’s powers, molecular diversity, plant diversity, Plantago lanceolata, Shannon index, Simpson’s index INTRODUCTION Biodiversity represents the variety and heterogeneity of organisms or traits at all levels of the hierarchy of life, from molecules to ecosystems. Typically, the focus is on species diversity, but other forms of diversity, such as genetic and chemical diversity, are also important and informative. Even after deciding which form of diversity to measure, quantifying biodiversity remains problematic because there is no single index that adequately summarizes the concept (Hurlbert 1971; Purvis and Hector 2000). Richness (S), or the number of species or attributes present, is the simplest metric used to represent diversity (Whittaker 1972), and it remains the most commonly applied (Magurran 2004). Intuitively, species or trait abundance is also important for diversity, and the proportional abundance of species can be incorporated into indices representing diversity. The simplest of these indices was proposed by Berger and Parker, has an analytical relationship with the geometric series of the species abundance model (May 1975; Caruso et al. 2007), and reports the proportional abundance of only the most abundant species in the population (BP, Table 1, Berger and Parker 1970). [Table: Formulas used to calculate diversity measures analyzed] There have been numerous attempts to create compound indices that combine measures of richness and abundance. Foremost among these are the Shannon’s diversity (H’) and Simpson’s diversity (D1) indices (Table 1), which differ in their theoretical foundation and interpretation (Magurran 2004). H’ has its foundations in information theory and represents the uncertainty about the identity of an unknown individual. In a highly diverse (and evenly distributed) system, an unknown individual could belong to any species, leading to a high uncertainty in predictions of its identity. In a less diverse system dominated by one or a few species, it is easier to predict the identity of unknown individuals and there is less uncertainty in the system (Shannon 1948). This metric is common in the ecological literature, despite its abstract conceptualization (Magurran 2004). D1 is the complement of Simpson’s original index and represents the probability that two randomly chosen individuals belong to different species (McCune and Grace 2002). D2 is closely related to D1, being the inverse of Simpson’s original index (Simpson 1949). Both of these transformations serve to make the index increase as diversity intuitively increases, and although both are used, D2 is more common (Magurran 2004). Finally, evenness represents the degree to which individuals are split among species with low values indicating that one or a few species dominate, and high values indicating that relatively equal numbers of individuals belong to each species. Evenness is not calculated independently, but rather is derived from compound diversity measures such as H’, D1, and D2, as they inherently contain richness and evenness components. However, evenness as calculated from H’ (J’) is of only limited use predictively because it mathematically correlates with H’ (DeBenedictis 1973). E, calculated from D2 (Table 1), is mathematically independent of D1 (Smith and Wilson 1996) and therefore a more useful measure of evenness in many contexts. Strong correlations between diversity measures should not be surprising as they represent aspects of the same phenomenon. In fact, most of the measures analyzed here can be derived from the same basic generalized entropy formula Na = (∑ = 1 P)1/(1−a), where Na is the effective species number, S is total species number, Pia is the proportional abundance of species i, and a is the power (Table 1; Hill 1973). H’ is equally sensitive to rare and abundant species; sensitivity to rare species increases as a decreases from 1, and sensitivity to abundant species increases as a increases from 1 (Fig. 1; Jost 2007). Therefore, S is sensitive to rare species, D1 and D2 are sensitive to abundant species, and BP is sensitive to only the most abundant species. As all the Na’s have species as the unit, the range of values can be interpreted as a continuum from effective number of the most rare species to effective number of the most abundant species. [Figure: Herbaceous plant diversity in sites with representative high and low land use intensity (LUI). The low LUI site (AEG07) was an unfertilized sheep pasture, while the high LUI site (AEG02) was a fertilized meadow that was mown three times a year. The effective species number decreases in both sites as Hill’s power increases and increasingly abundant species are excluded.] Despite the strong relationships between these diversity measures, they are not interchangeable and there has been much debate over which is appropriate in various contexts. For purposes where ranking sites by their level of diversity is the primary goal, such as in conservation planning when selecting sites to be protected, compound indices are often preferred over species richness (Magurran and Dornelas 2010). This was true for macroinvertebrate diversity in riverine sites and for plant diversity in temperate grasslands, where H’ and D2 were calculated, respectively, and found to discriminate sites more effectively than S (Wilsey et al. 2005; Heino et al. 2008). In contrast, Magurran and Dornelas (2010) argue against using compound indices when the objective is