Metal preferences and metallation.
Foster AW, Osman D, Robinson NJ. · 2014
Read Metal preferences and metallation. by Foster AW, Osman D, Robinson NJ. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4192464.txt.
Introduction
Andrew W. Foster, Deenah Osman, and Nigel J. Robinson explained how proteins end up holding the right metal in the Journal of Biological Chemistry in 2014. About a third of enzymes need a metal atom to work, yet most proteins grab metals by a fixed pecking order that does not match what they need. Left alone, many would seize the wrong metal and fail.
Cells solve the puzzle in layers. Delivery proteins hand metals to about 30 percent of these enzymes, and a quarter get ready-made metal clusters. The rest compete from pools the cell keeps carefully rationed, holding scarce metals at far lower free levels than common ones. Zinc, for instance, is kept at least a million-fold below magnesium. Sensors and buffers tune the pools so each protein's odds favour the metal it truly needs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Foster AW, Osman D, Robinson NJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2014 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Metal Preferences and Metallation* By Andrew W Foster, Deenah Osman, Nigel J Robinson Published in: The Journal of Biological Chemistry DOI: 10.1074/jbc.R114.588145 ABSTRACT Abstract The metal binding preferences of most metalloproteins do not match their metal requirements. Thus, metallation of an estimated 30% of metalloenzymes is aided by metal delivery systems, with ∼25% acquiring preassembled metal cofactors. The remaining ∼70% are presumed to compete for metals from buffered metal pools. Metallation is further aided by maintaining the relative concentrations of these pools as an inverse function of the stabilities of the respective metal complexes. For example, magnesium enzymes always prefer to bind zinc, and these metals dominate the metalloenzymes without metal delivery systems. Therefore, the buffered concentration of zinc is held at least a million-fold below magnesium inside most cells. Keywords: Copper, Iron, Manganese, Nickel, Zinc, Irving-Williams Series, Metal Sensors, Metallochaperone, Metalloenzymes, Polydisperse Buffer INTRODUCTION This narrative sets out, with examples, how cells assist metallation. Such assistance is vital because the physical and chemical properties of proteins tend to select essential divalent metal ions with a ranked order of preference that follows the Irving-Williams series (1). Competitive metals must be kept out of binding sites for the weaker binding ions. Cupric ions are at the top of the series, although their order with respect to zinc can flip (2). In the reducing conditions of the cytoplasm, cuprous (Cu+) rather than cupric (Cu2+) ions are expected to predominate, but these ions can also form tight complexes, especially with sites that contain sulfur ligands (3). In the periplasm of bacterial cells, ferric (Fe3+) rather than ferrous (Fe2+) ions often dominate (4). Ferric ions are retained in solution in organic complexes that can be exceptionally tight and include binding proteins such as the ferric-binding protein (Fbp) in the bacterial periplasm (5). Because proteins are not rigid, the scope for steric selection of metal cofactors is imperfect. Mismetallation can exploit a subset of ligands and/or distort the native binding geometry. Typically, a protein becomes inactive if one or more residues of an active metal site are recruited to an alternative site, perhaps with alternative geometry, by a more competitive metal. For example, glyoxalase of Clostridium acetobutylicum (GlxI) is activated by nickel or cobalt, both of which assume octahedral geometries, whereas zinc binds tightly in trigonal bipyramidal geometry and inactivates this isoform of the enzyme (6). Correct metallation in vivo is favored because the cytoplasm is a metal-controlled environment. For example, two periplasmic cupins (manganese MncA and cupric CucA) from a model cyanobacterium bind metal via analogous ligand sets within analogous folds (Fig. 1), yet in vivo they acquire different metals. MncA and CucA both show in vitro metal preferences that match the Irving-Williams series, which is especially problematic for MncA. A 10,000× and 100,000× excess of manganese is required at MncA folding in order for manganese to outcompete cupric or zinc ions, respectively (7). Cuprous ions can also outcompete manganese. Manganese MncA has oxalate decarboxylase activity, whereas neither the zinc nor the copper forms are active (7). CucA is a Sec substrate that folds in the periplasm on secretion, whereas MncA is a Tat substrate. The Tat system translocates prefolded proteins, and hence MncA folds within the cytoplasm before export (7, 8). In this way, MncA entraps manganese before exposure to copper and zinc in the periplasm. In the cytoplasm, at the site of MncA folding, copper and zinc must be at least 10,000 and 100,000× less available than manganese. This must reflect the relative buffered concentrations of these three metals plus, hypothetically, a manganese delivery system for MncA. [Figure: Metallation is governed by metal availability for MncA and CucA. a, Mn(II)-MncA global fold. b, Cu(II)-CucA global fold. Both proteins adopt a cupin architecture, with MncA composed of two cupin domains. c, MncA N-terminal Mn(II)-binding site. d, CucA Cu(II)-binding site. Both proteins coordinate their metals with identical ligand sets, with a water molecule in the open coordination position (this position is occupied by acetate in the C-terminal Mn(II)-binding site of MncA). MncA and CucA both prefer to bind copper rather than manganese in vitro, but MncA folds and traps manganese in the metal-regulated environment of the cytoplasm. Protein Data Bank (PDB) codes: 2VQA and 2XL7.] WHEN METALS COMPETE WITH OTHER METALS FOR PROTEINS Metal availability within cells is restricted such that proteins compete with other molecules, including other proteins, for limited pools of the most competitive metals. Dudev and Lim (9) have assessed the physical and chemical properties of metals and proteins that influence metal preferences. These include valence, ionic radius, coordination geometry, ligand number, second-shell ligands, effects of the protein matrix, and ligand characteristics (net charge, dipole moment and polarizability, charge-donating/-accepting ability, and denticity) (9). Despite these opportunities to tune metal preferences, in vitro metallation is typically aberrant when essential metals simply compete with each other for proteins (7). Zinc and magnesium are the most commonly utilized metal cofactors (∼16 and ∼9% of all enzymes, respectively) (10), and they dominate the subset of metalloenzymes lacking a defined delivery system, representing ∼78% of this group (Table 1). Empirically, zinc is known to replace magnesium to inactivate enzymes including β-galactosidase (11), tyrosine kinases (12), and magnesium alkaline phosphatase (13, 14). The calculated free energies for replacing magnesium with zinc in rigid or flexible sites implies that zinc will always be favored over magnesium in mono- and binuclear binding pockets, with ΔG for replacement in flexible, neutral sites ranging from −10 to −29 kcal mol−1 (15). The incorporation of magnesium into chlorophyll to metallate chlorophyll-binding proteins is a special case that exploits delivery systems and is therefore considered separately in a later section of this minireview. [Table: Types of metal sites and metal delivery pathways in Metal MACiE] Iron and manganese are the next most common cofactors estimated to be exploited by ∼8 and ∼6% of enzymes (10). These ions account for most (∼18%) of the remaining fraction of metalloenzymes that are devoid of delivery systems, noting that another subset of iron enzymes does have metal delivery systems and iron is commonly found in preassembled cofactors. The divalent ions of manganese and iron have similar ligand affinities, radii, coordination preferences, and solvation free energies, creating a distinct challenge for proteins to discern between these elements when they compete for a site (9). UNCERTAIN METALLATION IN VIVO AND CAMBIALISTIC PROTEINS With a few pioneering exceptions (16, 17), the extent of mismetallation in vivo is unknown. Current methods for native metalloproteomics are neither global nor high throughput (7, 18), and so the extent of post-translational regulation through metallation is unclear. The picture is further complicated because multiple metals support catalysis in so-called cambialistic enzymes. Acireductone dioxygenase (ARD)2 from Klebsiella oxytoca is currently a rare example of an enzyme that can catalyze two different reactions dependent upon metal occupancy (19). Iron·ARD is widespread, and the nickel·ARD-dependent pathway has been observed in Bacillus subtilis and Escherichia coli, but both forms have been recovered from K. oxytoca. However, there is currently no evidence that both forms of the enzyme confer a selective advantage to K. oxytoca. Fractional occupancies of ARD with nickel and iron remain to be investigated in vivo, as does the tantalizing possibility that metallation is switched to match