An integrative model of patient-centeredness - a systematic review and concept analysis.

Scholl I, Zill JM, Härter M, Dirmaier J. · 2014

Read An integrative model of patient-centeredness - a systematic review and concept analysis. by Scholl I, Zill JM, Härter M, Dirmaier J. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4168256.txt.

Introduction

Isabelle Scholl, Jörg Dirmaier, and three co-authors tackled a fuzzy term in PLoS ONE in 2014: patient-centeredness. Health care groups praise the idea, but each group defines it in its own way. That spread makes the term hard to measure and hard to compare across studies.

The team searched five databases and coded every article that defined the term, ending with 417 papers. From those definitions they drew out 15 dimensions, among them clinician-patient communication, patient involvement in care, emotional support, and access to care. They then mapped the dimensions onto levels of care to form one shared model. The model gives policy makers, clinicians, and researchers a common language for planning and judging patient-centered care.

Catalog record

CREATORScholl I, Zill JM, Härter M, Dirmaier J.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4168256

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An Integrative Model of Patient-Centeredness – A Systematic Review and Concept Analysis By Isabelle Scholl, Jördis M Zill, Martin Härter, Jörg Dirmaier, Wen-Chih Hank Wu Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0107828 ABSTRACT Abstract Background Existing models of patient-centeredness reveal a lack of conceptual clarity. This results in a heterogeneous use of the term, unclear measurement dimensions, inconsistent results regarding the effectiveness of patient-centered interventions, and finally in difficulties in implementing patient-centered care. The aim of this systematic review was to identify the different dimensions of patient-centeredness described in the literature and to propose an integrative model of patient-centeredness based on these results. Methods Protocol driven search in five databases, combined with a comprehensive secondary search strategy. All articles that include a definition of patient-centeredness were eligible for inclusion in the review and subject to subsequent content analysis. Two researchers independently first screened titles and abstracts, then assessed full texts for eligibility. In each article the given definition of patient-centeredness was coded independently by two researchers. We discussed codes within the research team and condensed them into an integrative model of patient-centeredness. Results 4707 records were identified through primary and secondary search, of which 706 were retained after screening of titles and abstracts. 417 articles (59%) contained a definition of patient-centeredness and were coded. 15 dimensions of patient-centeredness were identified: essential characteristics of clinician, clinician-patient relationship, clinician-patient communication, patient as unique person, biopsychosocial perspective, patient information, patient involvement in care, involvement of family and friends, patient empowerment, physical support, emotional support, integration of medical and non-medical care, teamwork and teambuilding, access to care, coordination and continuity of care. In the resulting integrative model the dimensions were mapped onto different levels of care. Conclusions The proposed integrative model of patient-centeredness allows different stakeholders to speak the same language. It provides a foundation for creating better measures and interventions. It can also be used to inform the development of clinical guidance documents and health policy directives, and through this support the shift towards patient-centered health care. INTRODUCTION In recent years, patient-centeredness has gained in importance [1], [2], including policy and practice developments to promote patient-centered care on the level of legislation and regulation of health care [3]. In the UK, patient-centered care has been encouraged by several policy papers, e.g., the “Public and patient experience and engagement (PPE)” [4], and the “Liberating the NHS: No decision about me, without me” [5] both by the Department of Health. However, a recent BMJ editorial pointed out that part of the political discussions on “putting the patients first” seem to be “rhetorical lip service” [6]. Furthermore, the topic is on the agenda of influential British think tanks, e.g. the Health Foundation [7], and the King's Fund [8]. In the US, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) claimed patient-centeredness to be one of the six aims for improvement of the US health care system [9], [10]. The importance of patient-centered care has also been stressed by the 2010 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act [11], which led to the formation of the Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute (PCORI) [12]. In Australia, patient-centeredness is one of the three core principles of the Australian Safety and Quality Framework for Health Care, which was endorsed in 2010 [13]. In Germany, the Federal Ministry of Education and Research, together with the pension and health insurance schemes, established a large research priority program on patient-centeredness and chronic diseases [14]. On the international stage, the topic has also been driven forward by various associations, e.g. by the International College of Person-centered Medicine (ICPCM), which emerged from the Geneva Conferences on Person-centered Medicine [15], [16]. According to the systematic review of Rathert et al. [17] studies on processes and outcomes of patient-centered care show generally positive relationships between patient-centered care with intermediate and distal outcomes. Yet, two Cochrane reviews [2], [18] concluded that the evidence on the effects of patient-centered interventions on patient healthcare behaviors or health status is mixed. Inconsistent results have also been described elsewhere [19], [20]. In light of this extensive amount of ongoing research on patient-centeredness and its prominent position on the political agenda, one could assume that the theoretical conceptualization of what constitutes patient-centeredness is clear. However, the literature draws a different picture, describing the concept as fuzzy [21], elusive [22], or even as a “poorly conceptualized phenomenon” [23]. Looking closely at existing conceptual work reveals that several models exist, which describe various dimensions of patient-centeredness. For example while Mead and Bower [24], [25] include five key dimensions of patient-centeredness in their model (e.g., biopsychosocial perspective, sharing power, and responsibility), Stewart et al. [26], [27] describe six elements of the patient-centered method (e.g., exploring both the disease and the illness experience, enhancing the patient-doctor relationship) and Ouwens et al. [28] include eight domains of patient-centered care (e.g., access to care, communication, and respect). Another model [29] focuses on the aspect of communication and highlights four domains of patient-centered communication (e.g., eliciting and understanding the patient's perspective). Furthermore, patient-centered care has often been described by statements of what is was not, rather than explanations of what is was, e.g. doctor-centered, disease-centered [16]. All in all, the existing literature reveals that there is little consensus on the concept's meaning. This leads to a heterogeneous use of the term [21], resulting in a wide variation in the dimensions included in scales that purport to measure patient-centeredness [30]–[32]. Thus, research results regarding the effectiveness of patient-centered interventions, found by such various measurement instruments, are inconsistent [19], [20]. Part of the mixed results regarding outcomes of patient-centered care could be explained by the variation in the definition of the concept which may constitute a barrier to the implementation of patient-centered care into routine clinical practice [33]. Recently, efforts have been made to disentangle conceptual ambiguities by focusing on specific aspects (e.g. patient-centered communication [34] or ethical considerations [35]) or disease-specific dimensions (e.g. cancer care [32]). However, a comprehensive and systematic analysis of existing conceptual definitions is lacking. Thus, the aim of this systematic review was to identify and analyze the different dimensions of patient-centeredness described in the literature and to propose an integrative model of patient-centeredness based on these results. METHODS This study is part of a larger research project on the “Evaluation of dimensions and measurement scales in patient-centeredness”. More information on the project can be found in the published study protocol [36]. A registration of this systematic review in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) was attempted but not possible because a review of definitions does not fulfill the inclusion criteria. Search strategy The search strategy included an electronic protocol driven search, combined with a comprehensive secondary search, based on the recommendations of Greenhalgh and Peacock [37]. Original articles as well as theoretical and conceptual articles, book chapters, and books were considered. Five databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycInfo, Cochrane Library, Psyndex) were searched from their inception to January 2012. We searched for references that had the term “patient-centered” or “patient-centeredness” (both with American and British English spelling) in their title in order to restrict the work to a manageable amount of full texts, which clearly focus on the topic of interest. We did not include search terms, which are sometimes used as synonyms,

Read the complete text