Behavior change techniques implemented in electronic lifestyle activity monitors: a systematic content analysis.

Lyons EJ, Lewis ZH, Mayrsohn BG, Rowland JL. · 2014

Read Behavior change techniques implemented in electronic lifestyle activity monitors: a systematic content analysis. by Lyons EJ, Lewis ZH, Mayrsohn BG, Rowland JL. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4147713.txt.

Introduction

Elizabeth J. Lyons, Zakkoyya H. Lewis, Brian G. Mayrsohn, and Jennifer L. Rowland took stock of the change tricks built into wrist and clip-on step tools. Their study came out in the Journal of Medical Internet Research in 2014. Tools from brands such as Fitbit add auto feedback and guided steps to the plain step counts of old meters.

The team found thirteen tools for sale and had trained raters use each one for a week or more. They scored the tools on a set list of change tricks, with more checks for tricks shown to work in past pooled work. All tools gave feedback. The span of tricks built in ran wide from brand to brand. The team sees the tools as a way to bring clinic-grade change plans to a mass scale.

Catalog record

CREATORLyons EJ, Lewis ZH, Mayrsohn BG, Rowland JL.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4147713

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Behavior Change Techniques Implemented in Electronic Lifestyle Activity Monitors: A Systematic Content Analysis By Gunther Eysenbach, Christine Pellegrini, William Evans, Alexander Tallner, Elizabeth J Lyons, Zakkoyya H Lewis, Brian G Mayrsohn, Jennifer L Rowland Published in: Journal of Medical Internet Research DOI: 10.2196/jmir.3469 ABSTRACT Background Electronic activity monitors (such as those manufactured by Fitbit, Jawbone, and Nike) improve on standard pedometers by providing automated feedback and interactive behavior change tools via mobile device or personal computer. These monitors are commercially popular and show promise for use in public health interventions. However, little is known about the content of their feedback applications and how individual monitors may differ from one another. Objective The purpose of this study was to describe the behavior change techniques implemented in commercially available electronic activity monitors. Methods Electronic activity monitors (N=13) were systematically identified and tested by 3 trained coders for at least 1 week each. All monitors measured lifestyle physical activity and provided feedback via an app (computer or mobile). Coding was based on a hierarchical list of 93 behavior change techniques. Further coding of potentially effective techniques and adherence to theory-based recommendations were based on findings from meta-analyses and meta-regressions in the research literature. Results All monitors provided tools for self-monitoring, feedback, and environmental change by definition. The next most prevalent techniques (13 out of 13 monitors) were goal-setting and emphasizing discrepancy between current and goal behavior. Review of behavioral goals, social support, social comparison, prompts/cues, rewards, and a focus on past success were found in more than half of the systems. The monitors included a range of 5-10 of 14 total techniques identified from the research literature as potentially effective. Most of the monitors included goal-setting, self-monitoring, and feedback content that closely matched recommendations from social cognitive theory. Conclusions Electronic activity monitors contain a wide range of behavior change techniques typically used in clinical behavioral interventions. Thus, the monitors may represent a medium by which these interventions could be translated for widespread use. This technology has broad applications for use in clinical, public health, and rehabilitation settings. INTRODUCTION Background Insufficient physical activity is a major worldwide public health problem. Even small increases in activity at a population level could have far-reaching positive impacts on chronic diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and several cancers [1-4]. Despite evidence supporting improved health outcomes from regular physical activity, population levels of physical activity remain low [5], and inactivity is prevalent [6]. Behavioral physical activity interventions are typically successful in increasing activity levels [7-9], but these interventions are costly and require professional expertise in delivering behavior change techniques (BCTs). Electronic activity monitors show promise as a delivery medium, as they can replicate most aspects of pedometer-based interventions while providing options for individually tailored intervention content. These monitors measure physical activity (and sometimes other health and behavior indicators such as heart rate) and interface with a computer or mobile app to provide extensive feedback tools. The feedback can be as or more rich and individualized than that provided in a clinical study, often including multiple charts, social comparisons, and indicators of progress towards individual goals. Initial intervention results using these monitors have been very promising, showing increases in physical activity and decreases in weight for two monitor brands [10-13]. The market for wearable technology activity monitors is large and growing quickly. Numerous options are currently available for use by consumers and researchers [14]. However, little is known about how these monitors differ from one another, what options they provide in their apps, and how these options may impact their effectiveness. The low cost, wide reach, and apparent effectiveness of electronic activity monitors make them appealing for recommendation by practitioners, but the growing number of options precludes practitioners’ ability to provide informed recommendations to patients. Similarly, individuals interested in using a monitor to change their behavior must rely on review websites or word of mouth to compare the variety of options. Information about the functionality of the devices and the content of their companion apps could provide guidance in choosing options most similar to standard intervention practices and best suited to individual preferences and needs. Behavior Change Techniques and Content Analyses There is no consensus as to the best method for analyzing content of new media. A common method has been to use health behavior theory to create codes and/or percentage scores of the number of theoretical constructs represented. This process has been used with active video games [15], exercise apps [16], and weight loss apps [17]. A more involved method uses recently developed systematic taxonomies of BCTs to code for content that matches components of traditional behavioral interventions. Behavior change techniques are “observable, replicable, and irreducible component[s] of an intervention designed to alter or redirect causal processes that regulate behavior” [18]. A general hierarchical taxonomy of 93 BCTs has recently been published [18], and a similar taxonomy specific to physical activity and dietary interventions is also available [19]. These validated taxonomies likely provide a more informational and rigorous coding tool than previously used theory-based instruments. In addition to describing the content of biomedical media, there is also a need to determine the extent to which the behavior change strategies are evidence-based. Several recent analyses have reviewed mobile apps using different sources for their evidence base. Sources have included the Expert Committee for Pediatric Obesity Prevention [20], the Health Education Curriculum Analysis Tool [21], best practices such as those used by the Diabetes Prevention Program [22,23], and clinical recommendations from the American Association of Diabetes Educators [24] and US Public Health Service [25,26]. Although no compendium of evidence-based best practices exists for exercise and weight loss behavioral interventions, several meta-analyses and meta-regressions have provided a general idea of the BCTs typically associated with successful change [27-29]. Investigating the prevalence of these techniques in particular may provide insight into future directions for research and development. Further, determining how evidence-based BCTs are implemented may also improve standard coding methods. Preliminary evidence suggests that for several of the most common and effective techniques, fidelity to theory-based recommendations in their implementation enhances their effectiveness [30-32]. Thus, more in-depth analysis of implementation would provide valuable additional information, particularly for practitioners and those developing theory-based interventions. Content Analysis and Electronic Activity Monitors There has been a call for study of health apps [33-35], due to their widespread use and the absence of guidelines for determining their adherence to standard practices. In addition to standalone apps, for which there are now several published content analyses [16,17,20-22,24,25], we believe that there is a need to study electronic activity monitors and their companion apps. Development of a tool for coding the content of these apps would provide valuable information for practitioners, consumers, and researchers, and could also be used to create a decision aid for determining an appropriate match of monitoring system to individual or research/clinical intervention. The purpose of this study was to systematically investigate currently available commercial electronic activity monitors to (1) characterize their behavior change techniques, (2) determine the extent to which they include techniques associated with successful outcomes, and (3) compare implementation of several critical techniques to theory-based and evidence-based recommendations. METHODS Activity Monitor Inclusion Criteria and Descriptions Monitors were included based on three

Read the complete text