Web Apollo: a web-based genomic annotation editing platform.
Lee E, Helt GA, Reese JT, Munoz-Torres MC, Childers CP, Buels RM, Stein L, Holmes IH, Elsik CG, Lewis SE. · 2013
Read Web Apollo: a web-based genomic annotation editing platform. by Lee E, Helt GA, Reese JT, Munoz-Torres MC, Childers CP, Buels RM, Stein L, Holmes IH, Elsik CG, Lewis SE. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4053811.txt.
Introduction
Eduardo Lee and nine colleagues introduce Web Apollo, a browser-based editor for genome annotation, in Genome Biology in 2013. Sequencing a new genome is now common. Describing its genes still takes expert hand work, long done with desktop tools at big centres.
Web Apollo moves that editing onto the web. Several annotators can open the same genome in ordinary browsers and refine gene structures together, seeing each other's changes at once, from the same room or across the world. Curators can correct predicted exons, merge or split genes, and record evidence as they go. The paper describes the design and early use by research communities. The aim is to spread careful annotation beyond the large centres, so the many groups now sequencing their own organisms can describe them to a shared standard.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lee E, Helt GA, Reese JT, Munoz-Torres MC, Childers CP, Buels RM, Stein L, Holmes IH, Elsik CG, Lewis SE. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2013 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 57 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Web Apollo: a web-based genomic annotation editing platform By Eduardo Lee, Gregg A Helt, Justin T Reese, Monica C Munoz-Torres, Chris P Childers, Robert M Buels, Lincoln Stein, Ian H Holmes, Christine G Elsik, Suzanna E Lewis Published in: Genome Biology DOI: 10.1186/gb-2013-14-8-r93 ABSTRACT Web Apollo is the first instantaneous, collaborative genomic annotation editor available on the web. One of the natural consequences following from current advances in sequencing technology is that there are more and more researchers sequencing new genomes. These researchers require tools to describe the functional features of their newly sequenced genomes. With Web Apollo researchers can use any of the common browsers (for example, Chrome or Firefox) to jointly analyze and precisely describe the features of a genome in real time, whether they are in the same room or working from opposite sides of the world. INTRODUCTION The multitude of genome browsers in genomics all grew out of the need to 'see' the full array of predictions and alignments, their relative positions and their component parts. Among these are a small number of more sophisticated genome 'editors' which allow users to go beyond passive viewing to interactively modifying and refining precise locations and structures of genome functional elements. The desktop version of Apollo [1], Artemis [2], and FMAP [3] are all examples of such tools. The genome sequencing and annotation paradigm typically involved a large, national genome center that undertook the raw sequencing in coordination with gene prediction pipelines and subsequent manual curation (for example, RefSeq [4], Ensembl [5], FlyBase [6], Wormbase [7], Saccharomyces Genome Database [8], The Arabidopsis Information Resource [9], and Mouse Genome Informatics [10]). The Model Organism Databases (MODs) often include staff members (that is, biocurators) who review and amend the gene structures. The Human and Vertebrate Analysis and Annotation (HAVANA) team at the Sanger Institute manually annotates the human [11], mouse [12], and zebrafish [13] genomes. The amended predictions are subsequently used either as training sets or as empirical standards whose alignments are used to improve prediction software's accuracy. For example, the HAVANA team uses their in-house genome editor (Otterlace [14]) to manually annotate, and then the improved annotations are fed back into the Ensembl [15] pipeline during subsequent quarterly runs [16]. Unfortunately, while this model of a central biocuration team is considered the gold standard for genome annotation, it scales poorly. Technical advances have made sequencing faster and cheaper, thereby democratizing genome-scale sequencing and allowing a rapidly growing number of researchers to launch sequencing projects ranging from population, to evolutionary, to phenotype, to disease, to classroom projects across a huge spectrum of organisms. And, while next generation sequencing technology provides annotators with significantly more information, this, perhaps paradoxically, actually increases the need for manual review because there are more biological data points to assess and integrate. Individual researchers and small research groups do not have access to a centralized biocuration team, but their need for hand curation is often greater than that of a large genome center due to their focused interest in a particular gene family, pathway or evolutionary relationship, and the generally lower quality of the genome assembly. An ideal solution would conceptually be a 'genome wiki', where curators could collaboratively edit genome annotations online, much like the distributed curators of a wiki document [17]. Biological text corpora, successfully exposed to 'crowd-sourced' curation via the wiki-type model, include Wikipedia pages directly associated with human genes [18] along with pages for protein [19] and RNA domain families [20]. Other projects offer similar wiki-like editing features for text, including revision control [21]. However, while editable textboxes have been present in browsers since the earliest days of the web, a completely integrated genome editor that operates seamlessly in the web browser (and saves annotations to a persistent data store in a client-server model) has been lacking. The natural user interface for genome data is the genome browser, and a true 'genome wiki' should allow curators to edit annotations seamlessly from within the genome browser. For this reason, we built Web Apollo, a browser-based genome editor that supports geographically dispersed researchers whose work is coordinated through automatic synchronization. The overall platform is currently comprised of a visualization component - JBrowse [22], and an editing and user authentication component - Apollo. Just as the costs of sequencing have gone down our aim was to make manual annotation correspondingly cost-effective. With Web Apollo the task of manual curation is spread out among many hands and eyes, enabling the creation of virtual research networks of researchers linked by a common interest in a particular organism or population (Figure 1). [Figure: Web Apollo architecture. Web Apollo (components within the central turquoise box) acts as a mediating agent between users (top blue box) and external sources and sinks of data (lower green and peach boxes). Two user interface components operate on the client-side, within the browser environment. The JBrowse component visualizes various DNA features, and the Web Apollo component captures user manipulations. The Data Services module dynamically delivers genomic data and features to the user interface as JBrowse compatible JSON. Most of the primary genomic data is harvested and formatted in advance as part of the initial server setup. In addition, data from other sources may be dynamically provided using the Trellis framework or uploaded by the user from the browser. The Annotation Editing Engine and User Management components also sit on the server side. The first responds to users actions on the client by modifying the underlying data models appropriately, and second manages user accounts and login services. Annotations created by users can be exported as either GFF3 or FASTA file, or directly saved to a Chado database (plug-in adapters may be added to export genomic annotations to additional repositories). The arrows indicate where there are interactions between components, with the arrowhead indicating the direction of data flow.] Our development team included investigators representing multiple genome research communities who carried out usability testing to evaluate the effectiveness of Web Apollo's interface and annotation management. We took this user-centered-design approach to ensure real world usability was built into the system from the ground up. They evaluated usability by revising annotations for honeybee (Apis mellifera) and, from the outset, for community annotation of insect genomes such as ants (Cardiocondyla obscurior, Pogonomyrmex barbatus, and Wasmannia auropunctata), leading to a better understanding of the biology of these insects and simultaneously evaluating the effectiveness of the software. RESULTS This section briefly explains Web Apollo's core operations for importing data, editing, and exporting protein-coding gene models. Additionally we describe additional features supporting the annotation of corrections to lower quality genome assemblies, import and visualization of transcriptome data, and real-time collaboration. Protein-coding gene annotation To annotate a gene, curators commonly proceed by: (1) locating the region of interest; (2) inspecting all available gene predictions and biological evidence aligned to the region; (3) creating a gene model; (4) if necessary, modifying these gene models using the editing functions; (5) corroborating the accuracy of the annotation by comparing the resulting annotation with available homologs; and (6) ensuring that correct naming conventions and relevant comments have been added, utilizing available literature as needed. Importing genomic data: Using server-side middleware, the system can load data tracks from a