Attributable risk from distributed lag models.

Gasparrini A, Leone M. · 2014

Read Attributable risk from distributed lag models. by Gasparrini A, Leone M. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc4021419.txt.

Introduction

Antonio Gasparrini and Michela Leone extend a health risk measure to cover delayed effects, in BMC Medical Research Methodology in 2014. Attributable risk states how much illness an exposure causes, a key figure for planning public action. Standard forms ignore timing, yet many exposures act with a lag or over a stretch of days.

The authors rebuild the measure inside a model family that handles delayed, curved exposure effects. The forward view counts future burden from an exposure event; the backward view counts current burden from past events. Parts tied to ranges of exposure can be split out, such as cold versus heat. They show the method on death counts and outdoor heat in London and Rome over more than a decade each. The split shows how much of the toll came from mild versus extreme heat or cold. The tools ship as free code.

Catalog record

CREATORGasparrini A, Leone M.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4021419

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Attributable risk from distributed lag models By Antonio Gasparrini, Michela Leone Published in: BMC Medical Research Methodology DOI: 10.1186/1471-2288-14-55 ABSTRACT Abstract Background Measures of attributable risk are an integral part of epidemiological analyses, particularly when aimed at the planning and evaluation of public health interventions. However, the current definition of such measures does not consider any temporal relationships between exposure and risk. In this contribution, we propose extended definitions of attributable risk within the framework of distributed lag non-linear models, an approach recently proposed for modelling delayed associations in either linear or non-linear exposure-response associations. Methods We classify versions of attributable number and fraction expressed using either a forward or backward perspective. The former specifies the future burden due to a given exposure event, while the latter summarizes the current burden due to the set of exposure events experienced in the past. In addition, we illustrate how the components related to sub-ranges of the exposure can be separated. Results We apply these methods for estimating the mortality risk attributable to outdoor temperature in two cities, London and Rome, using time series data for the periods 1993–2006 and 1992–2010, respectively. The analysis provides estimates of the overall mortality burden attributable to temperature, and then computes the components attributable to cold and heat and then mild and extreme temperatures. Conclusions These extended definitions of attributable risk account for the additional temporal dimension which characterizes exposure-response associations, providing more appropriate attributable measures in the presence of dependencies characterized by potentially complex temporal patterns. Keywords: Attributable risk, Attributable fraction, Distributed lag models BACKGROUND Epidemiological studies usually rely on effect summaries based on ratio measures, such as relative risk, odds ratio or rate ratio, with the choice depending on the specific study design [1]. Although these measures are ideal for summarizing the association of interest, they offer limited information on the actual impact of the exposure. This information is critical for the planning and evaluation of public health interventions, and it is better provided by relative excess measures such as the attributable fraction (AF), or absolute excess measures such as the attributable number (AN). Steenland and Armstrong offer a thorough overview on the topic [2]. Here we generally refer to these summaries as attributable risk measures. Problems in the definition of these measures may arise in the presence of delayed associations, occurring when an exposure generates a risk lasting well beyond the exposure period. Researchers in different fields, during the last thirty years, have proposed approaches for modelling this type of association [3-6]. In time series analysis, a popular approach is based on distributed lag models (DLMs) [7,8], generalized to distributed lag non-linear models (DLNMs) when including non-linear exposure-response associations [9,10]. Recently, the DLNM framework has been extended beyond time series data for modelling such dependencies, defined exposure-lag-response associations, in different study designs [11]. However, attributable risk measures have not been developed for the DLM and DLNM class, with the result that their current definitions do not take into account the additional temporal structure in the exposure-response association. Previous work investigated the issue in time series analysis, although without producing a general approach [12,13]. In this contribution, we extend this research and attempt to formalize the definition of attributable risk measures within the DLNM modelling framework. In particular, we illustrate how complex non-linear and temporal patterns can be accounted for in the computation of the attributable risk. Also, we show how attributable components related to different exposure ranges can be separated. We propose an example on the estimation of the health burden attributable to temperature with time series data, a problem which has received quite a lot of interest recently due to climate change predictions. However, the approach can be easily applied to other exposure-lag-response associations. The method is implemented in simple functions developed within the R software package and provided as additional files. METHODS Attributable risk measures A general definition of the attributable fraction AFx and number ANx for a given exposure x can be provided by: [formula: (1a)AFx=1−exp−βx,] [formula: (1b)ANx=n·AFx,] with n as the total number of cases. The parameter βx used in Eq. (1a) represents the risk associated with the exposure, and it usually corresponds to the logarithm of a ratio measure such as relative risk, relative rate or odds ratio. It is generally obtained from regression models while adjusting for potential confounders. The general definition of βx used here refers to the association with a specific exposure intensity x compared to a reference value x0. For linear exposure-response relationships, the association can also be reported as β·x, where in this case β refer to a unit increase in x. For binary variables reporting presence/absence of the exposure, Eq. (1a) simplifies to AF=(RR−1)/RR, with RR as relative risk, as reported by Steenland and Armstrong [2]. We keep the more general definition of βx, which is easily applicable to non-linear exposure-response relationships, throughout the manuscript. The theoretical nature of these effect measures is based on a counterfactual, where the observed condition is compared with a reference state which never occurred. This state postulates that the same population is followed in an identical situation where only the exposure level changes to the reference value x0. Typically, such a reference is represented by the absence of association, meaning x0=0 and βx0=0. However, different counterfactual conditions can be used, for example a lower exposure which can be determined by an intervention. In this case the quantity βx can be simply re-parameterized as βx∗=βx−βx0, and Eq. (1) still applies. Eq. (1a) can be extended to define the risk attributable to multiple exposures x1,…,xp: [formula: (2)AFx1,…,xp=1−exp−∑i=1pβxi=1−∏i=1p1−AFxi,] with ANx1,…,xp obtained by substituting Eq. (2) in Eq. (1b) [2]. For the specific form of Eq. (2), it should be noted that AFx1,…,xp≤AFx1+…+AFxp, i.e. the sum of the attributable risk measured for individual exposures is usually higher than their concurrent attributable risk. A review of the DLNM modelling framework The basic idea underpinning the development of DLNMs is that the risk at time t can be described as the weighted sum of effects cumulated from a series of exposures xt−ℓ0,…,xt−L experienced in the past over the lag period ℓ=ℓ0,…,L, with ℓ0 and L corresponding to minimum and maximum lags, respectively. The risk can be described by the function f(x), determining the exposure-response, and the function w(ℓ), specifying the lag-response, related to the weights given to exposures at different lags ℓ. These functions are combined in a bi-dimensional exposure-lag-response functionf · w(x,ℓ). Algebraically, the risk is defined by a function s(x,t;η), written in terms of parameters η as: [formula: (3)s(x,t;η)=∫ℓ0Lf·w(xt−ℓ,ℓ)dℓ≈∑ℓ=ℓ0Lf·w(xt−ℓ,ℓ)=wx,tTη.] The function s(x,t) is computed as the approximate integral of the exposure-lag-response function over the lag dimension, representing the cumulated risk over the lag period. The parameterization in the final step of Eq. (3) is obtained through a cross-basis, involving a tensor product between the basis chosen for f(x) and w(ℓ), generating the transformed variables wx,t linearly combined with the parameters η. Simpler DLMs are defined by Eq. (3) by assuming f(x) as linear. Algebraic details and additional information are provided elsewhere [11]. The cross-basis is specified with a reference value x0 used later as a centering point for the function f(x), which is used to define the counterfactual condition. The complex

Read the complete text