The influence of the patient-clinician relationship on healthcare outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.

Kelley JM, Kraft-Todd G, Schapira L, Kossowsky J, Riess H. · 2014

Read The influence of the patient-clinician relationship on healthcare outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. by Kelley JM, Kraft-Todd G, Schapira L, Kossowsky J, Riess H. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3981763.txt.

Introduction

John M. Kelley and four colleagues ask whether the doctor-patient bond changes health. Their paper appeared in PLoS ONE in 2014. Warmth, trust, and good communication are widely believed to heal. Belief is not measurement, though. The team reviewed randomized trials that changed the relationship on purpose. Trials had to measure objective or validated health outcomes. Routine checkups and mental health visits were excluded. So were studies that scored only satisfaction.

Thirteen trials met all the rules. Their effects ranged from slightly negative to moderately positive. Pooled, the benefit of a better relationship was small. It was statistically significant all the same. The authors stay careful in their reading. Few of the trials were built for this question. The evidence base is thin. They call for purpose-built trials that test the relationship itself. It should be studied as a treatment ingredient in its own right.

Catalog record

CREATORKelley JM, Kraft-Todd G, Schapira L, Kossowsky J, Riess H.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3981763

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Influence of the Patient-Clinician Relationship on Healthcare Outcomes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials By John M Kelley, Gordon Kraft-Todd, Lidia Schapira, Joe Kossowsky, Helen Riess, Antje Timmer Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0094207 ABSTRACT Abstract Objective To determine whether the patient-clinician relationship has a beneficial effect on either objective or validated subjective healthcare outcomes. Design Systematic review and meta-analysis. Data Sources Electronic databases EMBASE and MEDLINE and the reference sections of previous reviews. Eligibility Criteria for Selecting Studies Included studies were randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in adult patients in which the patient-clinician relationship was systematically manipulated and healthcare outcomes were either objective (e.g., blood pressure) or validated subjective measures (e.g., pain scores). Studies were excluded if the encounter was a routine physical, or a mental health or substance abuse visit; if the outcome was an intermediate outcome such as patient satisfaction or adherence to treatment; if the patient-clinician relationship was manipulated solely by intervening with patients; or if the duration of the clinical encounter was unequal across conditions. Results Thirteen RCTs met eligibility criteria. Observed effect sizes for the individual studies ranged from d = −.23 to .66. Using a random-effects model, the estimate of the overall effect size was small (d = .11), but statistically significant (p = .02). Conclusions This systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs suggests that the patient-clinician relationship has a small, but statistically significant effect on healthcare outcomes. Given that relatively few RCTs met our eligibility criteria, and that the majority of these trials were not specifically designed to test the effect of the patient-clinician relationship on healthcare outcomes, we conclude with a call for more research on this important topic. INTRODUCTION One of the great challenges of modern medicine is to preserve the finest elements of caregiving in an environment that is increasingly dominated by market forces and routinized practices [1]. Excellent clinicians strive to master not only the theory of disease and treatment, but also to cultivate a therapeutic presence that is commonly believed to improve the experience of patients and to have a beneficial effect on medical outcomes [2], [3]. However, despite this widespread and longstanding belief, the effect of the patient-clinician relationship on healthcare outcomes has rarely been tested in randomized controlled trials. In fact, most empirical studies examining the effect of the patient-clinician relationship on medical outcomes have been observational in nature [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9], [10], [11] and therefore cannot assess causality. Nevertheless, these observational studies do suggest that relationship factors may hold important potential to affect health outcomes. The patient-clinician relationship has both emotional and informational components – what Di Blasi and colleagues have termed emotional care and cognitive care [12]. Emotional care includes mutual trust, empathy, respect, genuineness, acceptance and warmth [13]. Cognitive care includes information gathering, sharing medical information, patient education, and expectation management. Initially, our primary aim was to investigate the emotional component of the patient-clinician relationship. However, most studies of the patient-clinician relationship include both cognitive and emotional care, and consequently, we expanded our focus to include these studies also. We note, however, that studies that do not separately measure emotional care while investigating communication interventions leave unclear which factor – emotional care or cognitive care – is responsible for any beneficial effects. We also note that the boundary between cognitive care such as communications training and emotional care that enhances the patient-clinician relationship is unclear. For example, communications interventions often train clinicians to ask more open-ended questions, to resist interrupting patients, to identify and respond to patient expectations and fears, and to check patients' understanding of the diagnosis and recommended treatment. While these techniques are intended to improve the quality of information exchange, they are also likely to produce richer interpersonal interactions. Indeed, any intervention designed to improve communication – if effectively employed – is also likely to improve the quality of the interpersonal relationship. Previous reviews have attempted to estimate the magnitude of the effect of relational factors on health outcomes and to discern the relative impact of discrete interventions and contextual factors [12], [14], [15], [16], [17]. Since the last review was published almost a decade ago, and in response to enormous changes in conceptual thinking about how best to restructure the delivery of healthcare services, we undertook an updated systematic review and meta-analysis examining whether the patient-clinician relationship has a beneficial effect on healthcare outcomes. In contrast to previous reviews, we included in our review only randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that had either objective or validated subjective medical outcomes; and we excluded studies that only examined intermediate outcomes such as patient satisfaction or comprehension of medical advice. Therefore, the current review focuses on the most rigorous sources of evidence to determine whether the relationship between patient and clinician can produce improvements in health. We report here on the thirteen studies that met our selection criteria for study design and methods. METHODS We searched the electronic databases EMBASE and MEDLINE from their earliest entries to November 1, 2012. The exact electronic search strategy and a full description are provided in File S1. Briefly, the electronic search strategy required that articles: (1) be RCTs written in English and published in a peer-reviewed journal; (2) include in the title or abstract at least one word related to interpersonal skills (e.g., empathy, rapport, relationship, etc.); (3) include in the title or abstract at least one word referring to a clinician (e.g., physician, nurse, dentist, etc.). For the review by hand, the inclusion criteria were: (1) RCT in adult patients (age ≥18), written in English and published in a peer-reviewed journal; (2) patients were being treated for a specific disorder (i.e., routine physicals were not included); (3) the patient-clinician relationship was systematically manipulated (e.g., improved communication skills, increased empathy, better attention to non-verbal signals, not interrupting, sitting down, making appropriate eye contact, etc.); (4) there was either an objective outcome measure (e.g., blood pressure) or a validated subjective measure (e.g., pain scores). Studies were excluded if: (1) the patient-clinician relationship was manipulated solely by intervening with the patients with no manipulation of clinician comportment; (2) the clinicians were mental health professionals; (3) the patients had psychiatric disorders or substance abuse; and (4) clinical encounter time was unequal across conditions. For a detailed description of the inclusion and exclusion criteria, please see File S2. Our electronic search yielded 6,459 articles. We reviewed the titles and abstracts and eliminated any articles that clearly fell outside our inclusion/exclusion criteria. If there was any doubt, the article was retained for the next level of scrutiny. This process yielded 407 articles. Two authors examined each article's title and abstract more closely and determined that 36 of these should be inspected in depth; again, if there was any doubt, the paper was retained. We also examined the reference sections of previous reviews, and identified an additional 7 articles that potentially met our eligibility criteria. Combined, these processes yielded 43 articles. Three authors then examined the full text of each article and made independent judgments as to whether the article met inclusion/exclusion criteria. Disagreements were resolved by face-to-face discussion, leading to a consensus judgment. Thirteen articles met our inclusion and exclusion criteria. The selection process

Read the complete text