A unified view of "how allostery works".
Tsai CJ, Nussinov R. · 2014
Read A unified view of "how allostery works". by Tsai CJ, Nussinov R. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3916236.txt.
Introduction
Chung-Jung Tsai and Ruth Nussinov offer a unified account of allostery in PLoS Computational Biology in 2014. Allostery is the process by which a molecule binding at one site on a protein changes what happens at a distant site. The question of how it works was posed almost fifty years earlier and matters for basic biology and for drug design.
Earlier models could describe allostery, but the qualitative schemes lacked a shared math that tied energy, structure, and shifting protein populations together. Tsai and Nussinov show that the same set of descriptors works from all three standpoints. Their unified view sharpens thinking about cancer-causing mutations, biased drug action, and the design of drugs that act through allosteric sites.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tsai CJ, Nussinov R. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2014 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| LICENSE | CC0 1.0 Universal |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Unified View of “How Allostery Works” By Chung-Jung Tsai, Ruth Nussinov, Dennis R. Livesay Published in: PLoS Computational Biology DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003394 ABSTRACT The question of how allostery works was posed almost 50 years ago. Since then it has been the focus of much effort. This is for two reasons: first, the intellectual curiosity of basic science and the desire to understand fundamental phenomena, and second, its vast practical importance. Allostery is at play in all processes in the living cell, and increasingly in drug discovery. Many models have been successfully formulated, and are able to describe allostery even in the absence of a detailed structural mechanism. However, conceptual schemes designed to qualitatively explain allosteric mechanisms usually lack a quantitative mathematical model, and are unable to link its thermodynamic and structural foundations. This hampers insight into oncogenic mutations in cancer progression and biased agonists' actions. Here, we describe how allostery works from three different standpoints: thermodynamics, free energy landscape of population shift, and structure; all with exactly the same allosteric descriptors. This results in a unified view which not only clarifies the elusive allosteric mechanism but also provides structural grasp of agonist-mediated signaling pathways, and guides allosteric drug discovery. Of note, the unified view reasons that allosteric coupling (or communication) does not determine the allosteric efficacy; however, a communication channel is what makes potential binding sites allosteric. In cell biology the ability to perform a biological function is determined by how populated a macromolecule in its active conformation is. Rather than direct manipulation of the active (functional) site, allostery is capable of altering the active state population by some perturbation away from the active site, such as that elicited by ligand binding, post-translational modifications (PTMs), and more [1]. Nature has exploited allosteric regulation in the cellular network for signal transduction [2], enzyme activation [3], metabolism regulation [4], motor work [5], and transcription control [6], [7]. To perform cellular functions via allostery, evolution has optimized multiple free energy basins at the bottom of the folding funnel [8], [9]. As illustrated in Figure 1, in a typical free energy landscape [10] allosteric activation operates as a robust bi-stable switch through a narrow window of allosteric ligand concentration, shifting the population from the inactive to the active state. Such concentration-dependent behavior is taken for granted and only gets noticed when homeostasis is broken, through constitutive activation by mutations. Not surprisingly, the important role of allostery in cellular circuits, spelled by genetic sequences blueprints, has been recognized as “the second secret of life,” second only to the genetic code [11], [12]. [Figure: A typical allosteric activation via a bi-stable switch.A node in the cellular network is illustrated by only two populated states, active and inactive, separated by a sizeable but surmountable free energy barrier. Before activation, the inactive state dominates the population as indicated by the relative basin depth in the free energy landscape and a balance level. Within a narrow increment range in ligand concentration, the allosteric activation event shifts the population in favor of the active state. The activation is highlighted in the embedded plot with a typical sigmoid transition from the inactive to the active state.] Numerous approaches have been undertaken over the last 50 years in an effort to explain allostery and to study its underpinnings and consequences [13]. Each theme contributed to deepen and strengthen our grasp of the allosteric phenomena. However, until recently the principles did not intersect nor converge to provide a global picture [14], [15]. Broadly, studies of allostery fall into three mainstream categories. The first is based on the principle of thermodynamic equilibrium. Several mathematical models have been formulated, seeking a quantitative description with measurable allosteric properties. Even though they offered allosteric quantification, the thermodynamic outlook gave no indication as to why similar ligands bound at the same allosteric site may result in opposite agonism [16]. Second, conceptual models such as conformational selection versus induced fit were developed to explain the mechanism of how biological functions are achieved through allostery. Although in terms of the free energy landscape the conceptual thermodynamic view of conformational selection with population shift is directly linked to structural changes, to date no quantitative connection has been construed. The third embodies numerous implicit and explicit approaches which exploited the inferred structural coupling between the functional (active) and allosteric binding sites in a host protein. These implied that structural linkage is a necessary condition for an allosteric action. However, the structural view of allostery has been questioned since according to one of the thermodynamic models detailed structural information is not required [14]. Here, our first goal is to quantitatively link between experimental allosteric properties and the relative changes in energy between the distinct (active, inactive) conformational states in an allosteric switch. To accomplish this for the conceptual population shift between these two dominant states, we employ the simplest thermodynamic allosteric two-state model (Figure 1). The emerging linkage serves as a new fundamental basis for unravelling the structural mechanism of allostery. Simply put, the linkage indicates that an allosteric ligand binding event, whether acting as an agonist or an (inverse) antagonist, depends on specific interactions between the ligand and the host protein. Surprisingly, this simple reasoning of agonism is opposite to the ensemble allosteric model (EAM) [17] which postulated that agonism is robustly encoded in the ensemble and does not require different interactions between the ligand and the host. Next, we acknowledge that the structural coupling between the functional and allosteric sites of a host protein is indeed specified by a connecting allosteric propagation pathway. We reason that while the propagation pathway itself does not play a role in determining ligand agonism, it both specifies the relative populations (i.e., stabilities) of the conformational states before ligand binding and modulates the allosteric ligand efficacy. We then proceed to apply the established linkage which is based on a thermodynamic view to the structural view of allostery by assigning the quantitative allosteric measure to be the structural coupling factor between two communicating sites. The simplified structural description with one allosteric ligand and two conformational states then paves the way toward specifying the criteria of agonist classification for two allosteric ligands with two functional sites. We note that over the years the Karplus' group has carried out several dynamic analyses from these three angles, including on chaperonin GroEL [18], yeast chorismate mutase [19], and Myosin V [20]. The first realization of allostery in biology was the cooperative binding of O2 to tetrameric hemoglobin (Hb). Among the many models formulated to account for this cooperativity, the two-state concerted MWC model [21] put forth by Monod, Wyman, and Changeux in 1965, which with only three parameters adequately described allosteric cooperativity, stands out as the best model at that time. The lack of a structural mechanism in the MWC model was filled by Perutz in 1970 based on careful comparison between x-ray structures of liganded Hb and deoxy Hb [22]. In 1972, Szabo and Karplus presented an allosteric model of the statistical mechanics of cooperativity [23]. To formulate the dependence of the three parameters in the MWC model [21] on structure, this allosteric model incorporated structural information relating to the conformational change in the salt bridge as observed by Perutz,