What is the total number of protein molecules per cell volume? A call to rethink some published values.

Milo R. · 2013

Read What is the total number of protein molecules per cell volume? A call to rethink some published values. by Milo R. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3910158.txt.

Introduction

Ron Milo asks a deceptively simple question in Bioessays in 2013: how many protein molecules fill a given volume of a cell? New mass-spectrometry methods can count copies of most proteins in a cell, from bacteria to human cells. Milo checks those counts against basic facts about what cells are made of, such as the share of cell mass that is protein.

His arithmetic gives an expected range of about two to four million proteins per cubic micron, much the same for bacteria, yeast, and mammal cells. Yet published counts for fission yeast and mammal cells often run three to ten times lower. Milo urges researchers to use his range as a benchmark, recheck their counting methods, and revisit old assumptions about cell makeup.

Catalog record

CREATORMilo R.
YEAR2013
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3910158

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

What is the total number of protein molecules per cell volume? A call to rethink some published values By Ron Milo Published in: Bioessays DOI: 10.1002/bies.201300066 ABSTRACT Novel methods such as mass-spectrometry enable a view of the proteomes of cells in unprecedented detail. Recently, these efforts have culminated in quantitative measurements of the number of copies per cell for most expressed proteins in organisms ranging from bacteria to mammalian cells. Here, we estimate the expected total number of proteins per unit of cell volume using known parameters related to the composition of cells such as the fraction of cell mass that is protein, and the average protein length. Using simple arguments, we estimate a range of 2–4 million proteins per cubic micron (i.e. 1 fL) in bacteria, yeast, and mammalian cells. Interestingly, we find that measured values that are reported for fission yeast and mammalian cells are often about 3–10 times lower. We discuss this apparent discrepancy and how to use the estimate as benchmark to recalibrate proteome-wide quantitative censuses or to revisit assumptions about cell composition. We estimate the expected total number of proteins per unit cell volume as 2–4 million proteins per cubic micron. Some reported values for fission yeast and mammalian cells using mass spectrometry are 3–10 times lower than these estimates. We discuss this apparent discrepancy and how to recalibrate proteome-wide quantitative censuses. INTRODUCTION Proteins are dominant players in the cell in terms of both functionality and biomass, accounting for about half of the total dry mass. They are thus a focus of attention in biological research. With the advent of quantitative proteomics there has been a growing capability to report the copy numbers of proteins in a wide variety of cell types. However, the explicit question of how many protein molecules are in a cell in total often baffles even experienced researchers. Here, we show how it is possible to estimate this value from properties of the cell for which we have quite accurate measurements, and compare it with reported values based on different measurement techniques. Various techniques were used throughout the years to measure protein abundances ranging from colorimetric 1 and spectroscopic 2 to amino acid analysis and radioimmunoassays. Those methods are focused on either total protein or specific protein quantification after proper purification, identification, and calibration. The pioneering efforts to quantify a significant fraction of the proteome using radio isotopic labeling and 2D gels 3 has since given way to a torrent of information from mass spectrometry, which enables comprehensive proteome-wide quantification 4–14. Discussions of the cell content in terms of absolute values are becoming more common as techniques facilitating such measurements become ever more advanced and the functional implications such as the stochasticity that accompanies the many proteins that exist at very low copy numbers, become exposed 15. Absolute values can also serve as sanity checks on measured reports where, for example, the number of histones in a cell can be constrained by the known DNA length. Similarly, the number of sugar transporters can be constrained, given the growth rate and turnover numbers, as their flux has to suffice to build the cell biomass 16. Ribosomes have been quantified in various studies and can also serve as benchmarks for the absolute copy numbers per cell at a given growth condition. Careful analysis of the absolute values can thus reveal biases in quantification 17. Recent work showed how values from even the most reliable mass spectrometry methods such as iBAQ 18 should be normalized 19 to give reasonable overall cellular concentrations. While experimental measurements are the foundation of our knowledge of biological systems, estimates serve as predictions that are useful in testing where we might be holding misconceptions about cells or about methods that measure their properties. We begin by deriving an expression for the number of proteins per cell volume. We then use known parameter values to arrive at concrete predictions for the number of proteins per cell volume. These predictions are contrasted with a survey of the reported values in the literature. It is shown how these values differ markedly, and possible reasons for these seeming discrepancies are discussed. Renormalization factors are given that can be used to reinterpret previously reported protein copy numbers to be consistent with the analysis given here. ESTIMATING THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PROTEINS PER CELL VOLUME Protein content scales roughly linearly with cell mass and volume. Given that cell volume can change several fold as a consequence of growth conditions or strain identity, we choose to discuss protein content per unit cell volume. Later, we can multiply by cell volume to arrive at the total protein number per cell under a given growth condition. Our first method of estimate is shown as a back-of-the-envelope calculation in Fig. 1 using rounded “generic” parameter values. The estimate relies on knowledge of the protein mass per unit volume (denoted by cp). The units of cp are [g protein]/[mL cell volume] and this parameter has been reported for different cell types (see e.g. 20 and also BNID 105938, where here and later in this manuscript pointers for directly assessing values from the literature are given using the BioNumbers database identifiers 21, http://www.bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu). We denote by laa the average length, in amino acids, of a protein, and the average mass of an amino acid by maa. The number of proteins per unit volume is equal to: N/V = cp/(laa × maa). [Figure: A back of the envelope calculation of the number of proteins per cell volume. Application for selected model organisms based on their characteristic cell volumes is also given. Estimate is based on generic parameter values. For more accurate organism specific values see main text.] In Escherichia coli and other bacteria, we use an average protein length, laa, of 300 aa/protein and in budding yeast, fission yeast, and human cells, we adopt the value of 400 aa/protein (where values are rounded to within about 10–20% accuracy). These average lengths were calculated by weighting the lengths of proteins by their abundance in the cell. This takes into account that high abundance proteins tend to be smaller than low abundance proteins. This calculation used published datasets mentioned in Table 1 (see also 22–23 and BNID 107049, 108983). [Table: Range of values for the number of proteins per cell based on published studies] Moving on to the protein concentration in the cells, reports are surprisingly scarce: old measured values for cp are 0.24 g/mL for E. coli and 0.28 g/mL for budding yeast (BNID 105938, 108879, 108263, see also 24. Values are expected to be similar when the concentration values refer to either the total cell volume and protein complement including membrane associated proteins, or solely to cytoplasmic volume and proteins). Assuming an average amino acid mass of 110 Da – and with some unit conversions – we arrive at: and The reader might be wondering about the accuracy of the value of cp used. We can derive it based on other, better known, properties: cell density, water content, and protein fraction of dry mass. The total cell density, d, is about 1.1 g/mL (BNID 103875, 102239, 106439). The water content, which we denote by w, is in E. coli ≈70% and in

Read the complete text