Climate change, adaptation, and phenotypic plasticity: the problem and the evidence.

Merilä J, Hendry AP. · 2014

Read Climate change, adaptation, and phenotypic plasticity: the problem and the evidence. by Merilä J, Hendry AP. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3894893.txt.

Introduction

Juha Merilä and Andrew P. Hendry frame a climate evolution issue in Evolutionary Applications, with the record dated 2014. Wild populations are shifting their traits as the climate warms. Whether those shifts are genetic, flexible responses, or truly adaptive, and whether climate is even the cause, is often assumed rather than shown.

The authors grade the ways each of those claims can be tested and what each test can really prove. Their verdict, built on the issue's review set, is sober. Proof of genetic adaptation to climate change exists in some systems but stays scarce. Most claims rest on weak inference. The paper calls for sharper methods before broad verdicts, and sets the stage for the reviews that follow it in the special issue.

Catalog record

CREATORMerilä J, Hendry AP.
YEAR2014
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3894893

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Climate change, adaptation, and phenotypic plasticity: the problem and the evidence By Juha Merilä, Andrew P Hendry Published in: Evolutionary Applications DOI: 10.1111/eva.12137 ABSTRACT Abstract Many studies have recorded phenotypic changes in natural populations and attributed them to climate change. However, controversy and uncertainty has arisen around three levels of inference in such studies. First, it has proven difficult to conclusively distinguish whether phenotypic changes are genetically based or the result of phenotypic plasticity. Second, whether or not the change is adaptive is usually assumed rather than tested. Third, inferences that climate change is the specific causal agent have rarely involved the testing – and exclusion – of other potential drivers. We here review the various ways in which the above inferences have been attempted, and evaluate the strength of support that each approach can provide. This methodological assessment sets the stage for 11 accompanying review articles that attempt comprehensive syntheses of what is currently known – and not known – about responses to climate change in a variety of taxa and in theory. Summarizing and relying on the results of these reviews, we arrive at the conclusion that evidence for genetic adaptation to climate change has been found in some systems, but is still relatively scarce. Most importantly, it is clear that more studies are needed – and these must employ better inferential methods – before general conclusions can be drawn. Overall, we hope that the present paper and special issue provide inspiration for future research and guidelines on best practices for its execution. Keywords: environmental change, evolution, genetics, global change, individual plasticity, natural selection INTRODUCTION Adaptive evolution occurs when the genetic constitution of a population changes as a consequence of natural selection. Thus, to demonstrate that adaptation has occurred, evidence is needed for genetic change and that natural selection has been the causal force. Given that the genetic underpinnings of most traits are still not known (Ellegren and Sheldon 2008; Mackay et al. 2009; Anderson et al. 2013) and that the accurate measurement of natural selection is difficult (Kingsolver et al. 2001, 2012; Kruuk et al. 2003; Hersch and Phillips 2004; Morrissey and Hadfield 2012), obtaining hard evidence to conclusively demonstrate adaptive evolution in the wild represents a major and ongoing challenge. Given these logistical difficulties, and following from the traditional view that natural selection is a powerful force (Endler 1986), a frequent default has been to infer adaptive evolution based simply on evidence that mean phenotypes have changed in ways that intuition suggests are adaptive. This is not enough. One major reason the above intuition-based inferences are not sufficient is that phenotypic change can be the result of either genetic change or phenotypic plasticity, the latter occurring when individuals of a given genotype adjust their phenotype according to the conditions they experience (West-Eberhard 2003). Indeed, a number of phenotypic differences originally thought to be genetically based were subsequently attributed to phenotypic plasticity (e.g., James 1983; Charmantier et al. 2008; Teplitsky et al. 2008). In the wake of such demonstrations phenotypic plasticity is increasingly adopted as a parsimonious model that is to be rejected only if direct evidence is obtained for genetic change: That is, plasticity is treated as a null model. The reality, however, is that inferences regarding phenotypic plasticity also should be supported by a specific set of evidentiary criteria (see below). Another major reason why the above intuition can fail is that phenotypic changes may or may not be adaptive. On the one hand, maladaptive or nonadaptive genetic changes can occur owing to genetic drift or gene flow, rather than natural selection. On the other hand, maladaptive or nonadaptive plastic changes might occur as a result of stress, nutrient limitation, and a host of other reasons (Gotthard and Nylin 1995; Grether 2005). In reality, then, genetic versus plastic changes and adaptive versus nonadaptive changes should be treated as alternative models to be compared based on the weight of evidence. In the present paper, we consider these issues in the context of contemporary global (climate) change. The possibility of evolution in response to climate change started to gain attention in the late 1980s and early 1990s (e.g., Holt 1990; Lynch and Lande 1993; Bürger and Lynch 1995). Interest has since accelerated rapidly – in the last two decades more than 30 review and perspective articles have emerged on the topic (Merilä 2012), and 12 new reviews are published in this issue. At the same time, concerns have been voiced about the quality of inference: In particular, few studies have convincingly demonstrated that observed phenotypic shifts have a genetic basis (Gienapp et al. 2008; Merilä 2012). Likewise, despite the promise and enthusiasm associated with using molecular genetic and genomic approaches to detect climate-driven evolution (Hoffmann and Daborn 2007; Reusch and Wood 2008), few studies have been able to realize it (but see: Umina et al. 2005; Balanyá et al. 2006) and fewer still have been able to link genetic changes to phenotypes and to confirm that the changes are adaptive. In addition to the scarcity of evidence for genetic change, increasing support has emerged for its main alternative. That is, many studies have now reported a role for plasticity in shaping phenotypic responses to contemporary disturbances such as climate change (e.g., Charmantier et al. 2008; Gienapp et al. 2008; Hendry et al. 2008; Teplitsky et al. 2008). Partly for this reason, it has become increasingly common for authors to assume a role for plasticity unless direct evidence for genetic change has been obtained: that is, the null model approach mentioned above. In most cases, however, the lack of genetic evidence stems from the lack of actual tests for genetic change rather than concrete evidence that no genetic change has occurred. In such instances, all that can be stated with certainty is that the relative contributions of genetic change and plasticity are unknown. In addition, the general point made above that plastic responses might or might not be adaptive also applies to climate change. For instance, Teplitsky et al. (2008) provided evidence that climate-driven plastic decreases in the body size of red-billed gulls (Larus novaehollandiae; Fig. 1) were likely the result of environmental stress, rather than adaptive responses. [Figure: Examples of model species utilized in research on genetic underpinnings of climate change responses. (A) The great tit (Parus major), (B) red-billed gull (Larus novaehollandiae), (C) red squirrel (Tamiasciurus hudsonicus), (D) pink salmon (Oncorhynchus gorbuscha), (E) grove snail (Cepaea nemoralis) and (F) field mustard (Brassica rapa). Photograph credit: (A): S. Caro, (B): J. Merilä, (C): C. Kolacz, (D): A. P. Hendry, (E): M. Ozgo, (F): S. Franks.] Beyond this ambiguity about genetic versus plastic changes and adaptive versus nonadaptive changes, another inferential difficulty comes in determining the specific environmental factor causing a particular phenotypic/genetic change (Endler 1986; Wade and Kalisz 1990; MacColl 2011). A well-known example of this problem is the difficulty in confidently ascribing phenotypic trends in fish stocks to the effects of fishing versus other environmental changes (e.g., Kuparinen and Merilä 2008). In the context of climate change, increasing temperatures are often coincident with many other environmental changes that shape phenotypic responses, whether genetic or plastic. Thus, the demonstration that a phenotypic change is genetic or plastic

Read the complete text