Is non-homologous end-joining really an inherently error-prone process?
Bétermier M, Bertrand P, Lopez BS. · 2014
Read Is non-homologous end-joining really an inherently error-prone process? by Bétermier M, Bertrand P, Lopez BS. (2014) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3894167.txt.
Introduction
Mireille Bétermier, Pascale Bertrand, and Bernard S. Lopez question a textbook claim in PLoS Genetics, with the record dated 2014. Broken DNA ends can be rejoined by a fast path called non-homologous end-joining. That path has long been branded sloppy and error-prone.
The authors argue the main path is in fact careful but flexible. Errors blamed on it often come from a backup joining path that truly is sloppy. The main path also adapts to ragged ends, and many breaks arrive with chemical damage that must be trimmed before joining, which can cost bases. On this view, the ends set the error rate, not the joining machinery. Flexibility pays off in immune diversity and radiation survival.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bétermier M, Bertrand P, Lopez BS. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2014 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Is Non-Homologous End-Joining Really an Inherently Error-Prone Process? By Mireille Bétermier, Pascale Bertrand, Bernard S. Lopez, Sue Jinks-Robertson Published in: PLoS Genetics DOI: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1004086 ABSTRACT DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are harmful lesions leading to genomic instability or diversity. Non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) is a prominent DSB repair pathway, which has long been considered to be error-prone. However, recent data have pointed to the intrinsic precision of NHEJ. Three reasons can account for the apparent fallibility of NHEJ: 1) the existence of a highly error-prone alternative end-joining process; 2) the adaptability of canonical C-NHEJ (Ku- and Xrcc4/ligase IV–dependent) to imperfect complementary ends; and 3) the requirement to first process chemically incompatible DNA ends that cannot be ligated directly. Thus, C-NHEJ is conservative but adaptable, and the accuracy of the repair is dictated by the structure of the DNA ends rather than by the C-NHEJ machinery. We present data from different organisms that describe the conservative/versatile properties of C-NHEJ. The advantages of the adaptability/versatility of C-NHEJ are discussed for the development of the immune repertoire and the resistance to ionizing radiation, especially at low doses, and for targeted genome manipulation. DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are highly toxic lesions. However, in certain essential physiological processes, DSBs are used to promote genetic diversity. Programmed DSBs generated by cellular enzymes are repaired by the same mechanisms as those used for stress-induced DSBs. Thus, DSB repair stands at the crossroads between genetic variability and instability. DSB repair uses two primary strategies: non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ), which is generally considered to be error-prone, and homologous recombination (HR), which is considered to be error-free. However, this view is too simplistic. Herein, we discuss several pieces of data that challenge the fallibility of NHEJ. CANONICAL NHEJ VERSUS ALTERNATIVE END-JOINING The canonical C-NHEJ pathway joins double-strand DNA ends in a Ku- and Xrcc4/ligase IV–dependent manner. This pathway has been extensively described and is summarized in Figure 1A. [Figure: End-joining models and competition between C-NHEJ and A-EJ for DSB repair. A) The canonical C-NHEJ. The heterodimer Ku80-Ku70 binds to the DNA ends, which then recruit DNA-PKcs. Note that DNA-PK is absent from yeast. Several proteins, including Artemis, the polynucleotide kinase (PNK), and members of the polymerase X family, process the DNA ends for subsequent steps [86]–[90]. In the last step, ligase IV, associated with its co-factors Xrcc4 and Cernunos/Xlf, joins the ends [91]–[93]. B) A-EJ. Parp1 plays a role in the initiation process [4], [17], [94], [95]. Without the protection by Ku70/Ku80, the DNA ends are resected in a reaction favored by the nuclease activity of Mre11 and CtIP [11], [13]. It has been proposed that a single-strand DNA resection reveals complementary microhomologies (two to four nt or more) that can anneal; gap filling completes the end-joining. Subsequently, Xrcc1 and ligase III (which can be substituted by ligase I) complete A-EJ [4], [9], [38]. A-EJ is always associated with deletions at the junctions and frequently (but not systematically) involves microhomologies that are distant from the DSB. The histone H1 has also been shown to act in A-EJ [96]. C) Two-step model for the choice of the DSB repair pathway [3], [11] . The MRN complex and ATM are involved in the early steps of DSB signaling and can activate both C-NHEJ and A-EJ. 1) Binding of Ku80/Ku70 protects from ssDNA resection, leading to a conservative DSB repair outcome through C-NHEJ. The nuclease activity of Mre11 and CtIP can initiate ssDNA resection. 2) A short ssDNA resection allows A-EJ but not homologous recombination. A long ssDNA resection allows A-EJ and HR, but HR requires the presence of homologous sequences. A-EJ results in error-prone repair associated with deletions at the repair junctions with frequent use of microhomologies distant from the DSB.] The existence of alternative end-joining pathways has been recently reported (Figure 1B). This alternative end-joining process, which can be unmasked in the absence of functional C-NHEJ genes, is referred to as A-EJ or alt-NHEJ (alternative end-joining), B-NHEJ (backup NHEJ), and MMEJ (microhomology-mediated end-joining) [1]–[11]. Herein, to clearly distinguish it from C-NHEJ and because some repair events do not use microhomologies, it will be referred to as A-EJ. A-EJ is far from being fully characterized and might correspond to different molecular processes [12], but the common points are that it does not require extended sequence homologies, is independent of Ku80 or Xrcc4, and is associated with deletions at the repair junctions, frequently (but not systematically) using microhomologies distant from the DSB. This signature led to the model in Figure 1B, which proposes that A-EJ is initiated by a single-stranded (ssDNA) resection. Consistent with this view are the involvement of the nuclease activities of MRE11 and CtIP/Sae2 [11], [13], [14] and the fact that 53BP1, in association with RIF1 and BLM, protects against long deletions at the A-EJ repair junctions [15]. Consequently, A-EJ is highly mutagenic, typically generating deletions at the repair junction. Because HR is also initiated by a ssDNA resection, a two-step model has been proposed for the choice of the DSB repair pathway [3], [11]. The first alternative is the choice between C-NHEJ and the initiation of the resection; the second alternative is HR versus A-EJ (Figure 1C). Consistent with the first alternative, Ku represses both HR and A-EJ [1], [2], [7], [8], [16], [17]. A defect in Ku leads to extended DNA degradation at the DSBs and to increased deletion sizes at the A-EJ junctions [2], [6], [18]–[20]. Note that a defect in Ku does not significantly decrease, whereas the absence of Xrcc4 leads to a strong decrease in the total efficiency of end-joining [1], [21]. In both cases, the remaining events exhibit the signature of A-EJ at the repair junction (deletions). This shows that the absence of Ku is compensated by A-EJ. In the absence of Xrcc4, Ku is still present and able to repress A-EJ, thus independently of the late steps of C-NHEJ. These data support the concept that Ku protects against initiation of A-EJ. Because A-EJ is exclusively mutagenic, Ku favors the maintenance of genetic stability. Several parameters affect the second choice, such as the presence of a homologous sequence. Moreover, long resections are required for HR (hundreds of nucleotides), whereas short resections (a few tens of nucleotides) are sufficient for A-EJ, as estimated by the deletion sizes at the repair junctions. Nevertheless, long deletions can also lead to A-EJ. The cell cycle can also affect the DSB repair pathway choice; HR is only active in the S and G2 phases [22]–[26], whereas both C-NHEJ and A-EJ are active throughout the cell cycle [23], [24], but A-EJ is more active in the S phase [23]. C-NHEJ IS A CONSERVATIVE BUT VERSATILE DSB REPAIR PROCESS Genetic instability can be evaluated at two levels: at the chromosome level or at the nucleotide level, at the DSB repair scar. At the Chromosome Level C-NHEJ can be involved in translocations and rearrangements [2], [27] and in programmed rearrangements (generating the immune repertoire). Whole genome sequencing of tumors has revealed complex inter- and intra-chromosomal rearrangements in a phenomenon named chromothripsis. Both C-NHEJ and A-EJ have been proposed to be involved in chromothripsis, but they cannot account for events involving sequence duplication (for review see [28], [29]). Nevertheless, a defect in Ku or Xrcc4/lig IV