The CARE guidelines: consensus-based clinical case reporting guideline development.
Gagnier JJ, Kienle G, Altman DG, Moher D, Sox H, Riley D, CARE Group. · 2013
Read The CARE guidelines: consensus-based clinical case reporting guideline development. by Gagnier JJ, Kienle G, Altman DG, Moher D, Sox H, Riley D, CARE Group. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3844611.txt.
Introduction
Joel J. Gagnier, Gunver Kienle, Douglas G. Altman, David Moher, Harold Sox, and David Riley report a reporting guideline in the Journal of Medical Case Reports in 2013. Case reports tell the story of one patient's illness for teaching and science. Without shared rules, many reports skip facts that readers need.
The guideline, called CARE, was built by group agreement in three phases. Experts reviewed past work, met to draft items, then tested and refined the list. The final checklist has thirteen items, from title and patient facts to timeline, treatments, outcomes, the patient's own view, and consent. The authors urge journals to adopt the list so case reports grow more complete and open, and thus more useful for care and study design.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gagnier JJ, Kienle G, Altman DG, Moher D, Sox H, Riley D, CARE Group. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2013 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The CARE guidelines: consensus-based clinical case reporting guideline development By Joel J Gagnier, Gunver Kienle, Douglas G Altman, David Moher, Harold Sox, David Riley Published in: Journal of Medical Case Reports DOI: 10.1186/1752-1947-7-223 ABSTRACT Background A case report is a narrative that describes, for medical, scientific, or educational purposes, a medical problem experienced by one or more patients. Case reports written without guidance from reporting standards are insufficiently rigorous to guide clinical practice or to inform clinical study design. Primary Objective. Develop, disseminate, and implement systematic reporting guidelines for case reports. Methods We used a three-phase consensus process consisting of (1) pre-meeting literature review and interviews to generate items for the reporting guidelines, (2) a face-to-face consensus meeting to draft the reporting guidelines, and (3) post-meeting feedback, review, and pilot testing, followed by finalization of the case report guidelines. Results This consensus process involved 27 participants and resulted in a 13-item checklist—a reporting guideline for case reports. The primary items of the checklist are title, key words, abstract, introduction, patient information, clinical findings, timeline, diagnostic assessment, therapeutic interventions, follow-up and outcomes, discussion, patient perspective, and informed consent. Conclusions We believe the implementation of the CARE (CAse REport) guidelines by medical journals will improve the completeness and transparency of published case reports and that the systematic aggregation of information from case reports will inform clinical study design, provide early signals of effectiveness and harms, and improve healthcare delivery. INTRODUCTION A case report is a detailed narrative that describes, for medical, scientific, or educational purposes, a medical problem experienced by one or several patients Case reports present clinical observations customarily collected in healthcare delivery settings. They have proved helpful in the identification of adverse and beneficial effects, the recognition of new diseases, unusual forms of common diseases, and the presentation of rare diseases [1]. For example, our understanding of the relationship between thalidomide and congenital abnormalities [2] and the use of propranolol for the treatment of infantile hemangiomas began with case reports [3]. Case reports may generate hypotheses for future clinical studies, prove useful in the evaluation of global convergences of systems-oriented approaches, and guide the individualization and personalization of treatments in clinical practice [4,5]. Furthermore, case reports offer a structure for case-based learning in healthcare education and may facilitate the comparison of healthcare education and delivery across cultures. Case reports are common and account for a growing number of articles in medical journals [6]; however their quality is uneven [7,8]. For example, one study evaluated 1316 case reports from four peer-reviewed emergency-medicine journals and found that more than half failed to provide information related to the primary treatment that would have increased transparency and replication [9]. Written without the benefit of reporting guidelines, case reports often are insufficiently rigorous to be aggregated for data analysis, inform research design, or guide clinical practice [7,9]. Reporting guidelines exist for a variety of study designs including randomized controlled trials (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials, or CONSORT) [10], observational studies (Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology, or STROBE) [11], and systematic reviews and meta-analyses (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses, or PRISMA) [12]. Empirical evidence suggests that a journal’s adoption of the CONSORT statement as a guide to authors is associated with an increase in the completeness of published randomized trials [13]. Guidelines have been developed for adverse-event case reports [14]; however, general reporting guidelines for case reports do not exist. Our primary objective was to develop reporting guidelines for case reports through a consensus-based process. METHODS Research design We followed the Guidance for Developers of Health Research Reporting Guidelines [15] and developed a three phase consensus process [16]. This consisted of (1) a pre-meeting literature review followed by interviews to generate items for a case report checklist, (2) a face-to-face consensus meeting for drafting a reporting guideline, and (3) post-meeting feedback and pilot testing followed by finalization of the case report guidelines. Participants We contacted 28 individuals who fulfilled at least one of four criteria [17-19]: (1) publication of articles related to case reports; (2) publication of a manual, handbook, or method guidelines related to case reports; (3) publication of a systematic review of methods or reporting related to case reports; and (4) publication of other reporting guidelines for clinical research. Consensus process Phase 1: Four of the authors, the steering committee (JG, GK, DM, and DR), searched the literature for publications on the role of case reports, recommendations for their publication, and surveys on reporting quality. A letter was sent to 28 potential participants explaining the purpose of the meeting, details of the consensus technique, and requesting their participation in generating specific recommendations for case reporting. Twenty-seven people agreed to participate and were scheduled for a telephone interview and sent a selection of key articles on case reports. During the telephone interview, participants were asked (1) what information was required to be included in case-reporting guidelines, (2) the rationale for their suggestions, and (3) for references that supported their reasoning. Three of the authors (JG, GK, and DR) grouped the recommendations from the literature search and interviews by theme together with their rationale, references, and operational definitions. No quantitative scoring was done. Phase 2: The face-to-face consensus meeting at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor (October 2012) included 18 participants from Phase 1, one research assistant and two student observers. The meeting began with a review of the blinded recommendations elicited during the Phase 1 interviews, in whole group and small group sessions. On the second day, open discussion of each potential item continued, during which clarifications, opinions, justifications, operational definitions, and new ideas were expressed. By the end of the second day, the group had agreed upon a set of preliminary reporting recommendations. Phase 3: The draft checklist was refined by the steering committee and sent for two rounds of review to the complete group (Phase 1 and 2 participants). The finalized reporting guidelines incorporated the feedback from the entire CARE group. RESULTS The CAse REport (CARE) guidelines checklist is structured to correspond with key components of a case report and capture useful clinical information (including ‘meaningful use’ information mandated by some insurance plans). The checklist begins with a statement that describes the narrative of a case report. The meeting CARE group felt that a case report should tell a story using prose that has a consistent style across all sections, including the rationale for any conclusions and take-away messages. We recommend a timeline (item 7) in the form of a table or figure that gives the specific dates and times of important components of the case. This might include family and past medical history, genetic information, current symptoms, diagnostic test results, interventions, and events that occurred during follow-up. The timeline should show how the key events of the case unfolded. We created separate checklist items for diagnostic assessments (item 8) and therapeutic interventions (item 9) with the recognition that both items will often be relevant in a case report. The group discussed at length whether to include the patient’s perspective on his or her experience. In the end, we advocated for patient-reported outcomes and experiences whenever possible (item 12). There was also discussion about the need