A systematic review of interventions to reduce HIV-related stigma and discrimination from 2002 to 2013: how far have we come?

Stangl AL, Lloyd JK, Brady LM, Holland CE, Baral S. · 2013

Read A systematic review of interventions to reduce HIV-related stigma and discrimination from 2002 to 2013: how far have we come? by Stangl AL, Lloyd JK, Brady LM, Holland CE, Baral S. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3833106.txt.

Introduction

Anne L. Stangl, Jennifer K. Lloyd, Laura M. Brady, Claire E. Holland, and Stefan Baral review efforts to cut HIV stigma in the Journal of the International AIDS Society in 2013. Shame and bias around HIV block testing, care, and prevention. The team ask which programs have truly lowered that stigma over the past decade.

Their search swept journal bases and agency reports, keeping only studies that measured stigma before and after a program. Programs spoke to many groups, from health staff to whole towns, across many countries. Most used information and contact with people living with HIV. Few were tested with strong designs, and measures varied so much that gains were hard to compare. The review calls for sharper tools and proof before scale-up.

Catalog record

CREATORStangl AL, Lloyd JK, Brady LM, Holland CE, Baral S.
YEAR2013
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3833106

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A systematic review of interventions to reduce HIV-related stigma and discrimination from 2002 to 2013: how far have we come? By Anne L Stangl, Jennifer K Lloyd, Laura M Brady, Claire E Holland, Stefan Baral Published in: Journal of the International AIDS Society DOI: 10.7448/IAS.16.3.18734 ABSTRACT Introduction HIV-related stigma and discrimination continue to hamper efforts to prevent new infections and engage people in HIV treatment, care and support programmes. The identification of effective interventions to reduce stigma and discrimination that can be integrated into national responses is crucial to the success of the global AIDS response. Methods We conducted a systematic review of studies and reports that assessed the effectiveness of interventions to reduce HIV stigma and discrimination between 1 January 2002 and 1 March 2013. Databases searched for peer-reviewed articles included PubMed, Scopus, EBSCO Host –CINAHL Plus, Psycinfo, Ovid, Sociofile and Popline. Reports were obtained from the www.HIVAIDSClearinghouse.eu, USAID Development Experience Clearinghouse, UNESCO HIV and AIDS Education Clearinghouse, Google, WHO and UNAIDS. Ancestry searches for articles included in the systematic review were also conducted. Studies of any design that sought to reduce stigma as a primary or secondary objective and included pre- and post-intervention measures of stigma were included. Results Of 2368 peer-reviewed articles and reports identified, 48 were included in our review representing 14 different target populations in 28 countries. The majority of interventions utilized two or more strategies to reduce stigma and discrimination, and ten included structural or biomedical components. However, most interventions targeted a single socio-ecological level and a single domain of stigma. Outcome measures lacked uniformity and validity, making both interpretation and comparison of study results difficult. While the majority of studies were effective at reducing the aspects of stigma they measured, none assessed the influence of stigma or discrimination reduction on HIV-related health outcomes. Conclusions Our review revealed considerable progress in the stigma-reduction field. However, critical challenges and gaps remain which are impeding the identification of effective stigma-reduction strategies that can be implemented by national governments on a larger scale. The development, validation, and consistent use of globally relevant scales of stigma and discrimination are a critical next step for advancing the field of research in this area. Studies comparing the effectiveness of different stigma-reduction strategies and studies assessing the influence of stigma reduction on key behavioural and biomedical outcomes are also needed to maximize biomedical prevention efforts. INTRODUCTION More than two decades into the HIV epidemic, stigma and discrimination continue to hamper efforts to prevent new infections and engage people in HIV treatment, care and support programmes. Numerous studies have linked HIV-related stigma with refusal of HIV testing, non-disclosure to partners and poor engagement in biomedical prevention approaches [1–6]. Similarly, internalized stigma, which refers to the negative consequences that result when people believe that stigmatizing public attitudes apply to them [7, 8], is a well-established barrier to medication adherence [9–13]. In response to this evidence, stigma reduction is now a key priority in PEPFAR's Blueprint for Achieving an AIDS-Free Generation [14] and UNAIDS’ HIV investment framework [15]. The recent shift in the global AIDS response to biomedical prevention will require acceptance and uptake of prevention approaches, such as voluntary medical male circumcision, pre-exposure prophylaxis and universal testing and treatment, at the population level [16, 17]. Effective interventions to reduce stigma and discrimination are crucial to the success of biomedical prevention [15, 18]. Such interventions need to be integrated into national responses and address the stigmatization process [19]. Stigma conceptualizations and terminology Stigma has been conceptualized from the perspective of both the individual and the society. According to Erving Goffman, stigma occurs when an attribute creates a deeply discrediting gap between who we think we are – our “actual social identity” – and how we are seen by others – our “virtual social identity” [20]. This gap creates a “spoiled identity” that cuts the stigmatized person “off from society and from himself, so that he stands as a discredited person against an unaccepting world” [20]. Building on Goffman's work, Link and Phelan described stigma as a harmful societal phenomenon – enabled by underlying social, political and economic powers – that begins when a difference is labelled, then is linked to negative stereotypes, leading to a separation of “us” from “them,” and finally to status loss and discrimination for those carrying the trait [21]. Deacon suggested that HIV-related discrimination be analyzed separately from stigma to explore the range of stigma-related disadvantages that may result from the stigmatization process, as well as positive responses such as resilience and activism [22]. The stigmatization process can be broken into specific domains, each of which can be addressed through programmatic and policy efforts [19, 23]. These domains are: drivers, facilitators, intersecting stigmas and manifestations of stigma [19]. Drivers are individual-level factors that negatively influence the stigmatization process such as: lack of awareness of stigma and its harmful consequences, fear of HIV infection through casual contact with people living with HIV (PLHIV), fear of economic ramifications or social breakdown due to HIV-positive family and community members, and prejudice and stereotypes towards PLHIV and key populations at highest risk of HIV infection [24–27]. Facilitators are societal-level factors that influence the stigmatization process either negatively or positively, including: protective or punitive laws, availability of grievance redressal systems, awareness of rights, structural barriers at the public policy level, cultural and gender norms, existence of social support for PLHIV, and power/powerlessness among PLHIV to resist and overcome the manifestations of stigma [19]. Drivers and facilitators combine to influence whether a stigma is applied to individuals or groups based on HIV status. Intersecting, or layered, stigmas, refer to the multiple stigmas that people often face due to HIV status, gender, profession, migrancy, drug use, poverty, marital status, sexual and gender orientation [28–31]. Manifestations are the immediate results, mostly negative, of a stigma being applied to individuals or groups, including: anticipated stigma (fear of experiencing stigma if HIV status becomes known) [32], perceived stigma (perceptions about how PLHIV are treated in a given context) [33], internalized stigma [34], shame [35], experienced, or enacted, stigma (experiencing stigmatizing behaviours outside the purview of the law) [36, 37], discrimination (experiencing stigmatizing behaviours within the purview of the law) and resilience (ability to overcome threats to health and development after stigma is experienced) [18, 19]. Distinguishing between experienced stigma and experienced discrimination based on their legality informs the intervention strategies needed. Individuals experience, internalize and/or perpetuate the manifestations of stigma [19]. Additionally, the social and structural environments in which individuals live and work influence the drivers and manifestations of stigma [38, 39], indicating the need for interventions that target multiple levels [40]. The socio-ecological framework [41], which recognizes that societal norms and structures influence individual attitudes and behaviours, identifies key levels at which stigma-reduction activities can be targeted: individual (knowledge, attitudes, skills), interpersonal (family, friends, social networks), organizational (organizations, social institutions, workplace), community (cultural values, norms, attitudes) and public policy (national and local laws and policies) [42]. Previous reviews Brown et al. [43] conducted the first global review of interventions to reduce HIV-related stigma in 2003. The authors articulated four intervention categories based on psychosocial conceptualizations of the stigmatization process that have remained applicable a decade later. The categories include:information-based

Read the complete text