Empathy in clinical practice: how individual dispositions, gender, and experience moderate empathic concern, burnout, and emotional distress in physicians.

Gleichgerrcht E, Decety J. · 2013

Read Empathy in clinical practice: how individual dispositions, gender, and experience moderate empathic concern, burnout, and emotional distress in physicians. by Gleichgerrcht E, Decety J. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3631218.txt.

Introduction

Ezequiel Gleichgerrcht and Jean Decety surveyed empathy and exhaustion across 7,584 practicing physicians in PLoS ONE in 2013. Clinical empathy improves care, but feeling with patients can also wear doctors down. Their online battery measured kinds of empathy, distress, burnout, altruism, and emotional awareness, letting them ask which traits travel with satisfaction and which with fatigue.

Satisfaction with compassion rode with empathic concern, perspective taking, and altruism. Fatigue, meaning burnout plus stress absorbed from patients' trauma, rode instead with personal distress and alexithymia, the difficulty naming one's own feelings. Women scored higher on empathic concern. Years of experience alone shifted little once age and sex were accounted for. Doctors worst off combined high fatigue with low satisfaction and the weakest emotion regulation. Training emotional self-awareness is the authors' practical suggestion.

Catalog record

CREATORGleichgerrcht E, Decety J.
YEAR2013
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3631218

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Empathy in Clinical Practice: How Individual Dispositions, Gender, and Experience Moderate Empathic Concern, Burnout, and Emotional Distress in Physicians By Ezequiel Gleichgerrcht, Jean Decety, Tiziana Zalla Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0061526 ABSTRACT To better understand clinical empathy and what factors can undermine its experience and outcome in care-giving settings, a large-scale study was conducted with 7,584 board certified practicing physicians. Online validated instruments assessing different aspects of empathy, distress, burnout, altruistic behavior, emotional awareness, and well-being were used. Compassion satisfaction was strongly associated with empathic concern, perspective taking and altruism, while compassion fatigue (burnout and secondary traumatic stress) was more closely related to personal distress and alexithymia. Gender had a highly selective effect on empathic concern, with women displaying higher values, which led to a wide array of negative and devalued feelings. Years of experience did not influence dispositional measures per se after controlling for the effect of age and gender. Participants who experienced compassion fatigue with little to no compassion satisfaction showed the highest scores on personal distress and alexithymia as well as the strongest indicators of compassion fatigue. Physicians who have difficulty regulating their negative arousal and describing and identifying emotions seem to be more prone to emotional exhaustion, detachment, and a low sense of accomplishment. On the contrary, the ability to engage in self-other awareness and regulate one’s emotions and the tendency to help others, seem to contribute to the sense of compassion that comes from assisting patients in clinical practice. INTRODUCTION Clinical empathy is an essential element of quality care and is associated with improved patient satisfaction, adherence to treatment, and fewer malpractice complaints. It has been suggested that in contrast to models of “detached concern,” physicians who attempt to understand what their patient is feeling and communicate their concern achieve a number of valuable outcomes for their patients and for themselves [1]. Empathy in medicine is challenging though, because doctors are dealing with the most emotionally distressing situations–illness, dying, suffering in every form–and such situations would normally make an empathic person anxious, perhaps too anxious to be helpful [2]. This painful reality may take its toll on these individuals and can lead to compassion fatigue, burn out, professional distress and result in a low sense of accomplishment and severe emotional exhaustion [3]. A recent source of concern was sparked by a cross-sectional survey [4], which reported high prevalence of distress and diminished altruistic attitudes among medical students. Importantly, students who suffered from personal distress were more susceptible to engaging in dishonest clinical behaviors. This study is a clear example of the kind of critical questions that can be raised regarding the relationship between interpersonal sensitivity, empathy, and care-giving behavior and, among other things, suggests that empathy does not come without costs. While everybody views empathy as central to health care and the patient-physician relationship, there is less agreement on what the construct of empathy means. In social science, this term is applied to various phenomena that cover a broad spectrum. Empathy has been described in various ways, such as feelings of concern for others that create the motivation to help, experiencing emotions that match those of another individual, knowing what another is thinking or feeling, and even as blurring of the line between self and other [5]. In medicine, empathy often describes the ability to understand another’s experience, to communicate and confirm that understanding with the other person, and then to act in a helpful manner [6]. This conceptual diversity explains the difficulties in measuring empathy. In fact, none of the attempts to quantify it with self-reports, peer ratings, or patient ratings have been able to capture the entire range of affective, cognitive, and behavioral components of empathy [7]. In the past decade, progress has been made towards a more comprehensive definition of empathy, drawing from empirical research in various academic and clinical domains. There is now a converging agreement that empathy is not a single ability but a complex socio-emotional competency that encompasses different interacting components [8]–[13]. Empathic arousal, the first element of empathy to appear during ontogeny, refers to the contagious sharing of the affective state of another. Empathic understanding entails the formation of an explicit mental representation of the emotional state of another person. Empathic concern refers to other-oriented emotion felt for someone in need, which produces a motivational state of increasing the other’s welfare. Finally, emotion regulation enables the control of emotion, affect, drive, and motivation. Even though these components are intertwined and not independent of one another, it is helpful to dissociate them, as each contributes to various aspects of the experience of empathy [9], [14]. Furthermore, mounting evidence from developmental science, affective social neuroscience in normal individuals as well as in individuals with psychopathologies, and lesion studies in neurological patients indicates that empathy and its component processes are underpinned by specific neural systems. These systems are not limited to the cortex, but are primarily associated with the brainstem, subcortical nuclei, autonomic nervous system, hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, and endocrine systems that regulate bodily states, emotion, and reactivity [15]. Empirical research examining the components of clinical empathy is imperative in order to understand why some studies have shown that empathy declines during medical school and residency [16], [17]. Another important reason for conducting research on the underlying factors that contribute to clinical empathy and potential associated emotional dysfunctions among health-care professionals is the development of educational intervention for medical students [13], [18]. The goal of the current study sought to determine which aspects of empathy are associated with positive or negative outcome (well-being and burnout respectively) in practicing physicians. Validated self-report instruments were used to assess emotional awareness, empathic concern, personal distress, prosocial behavior, burnout, and well-being. METHODS The Ethics Committee at the Institute of Cognitive Neurology (INECO, Buenos Aires, Argentina) approved the present study. Participants Potential participants were board-certified physicians who accessed Intramed (www.intramed.net), an online portal exclusively for health professionals. A banner was placed in each user’s main page, inviting visitors to voluntarily access an online survey. All participants gave their informed consent by pressing an “I agree” button placed beneath an explanatory letter. Potential respondents were informed of the anonymity of their responses, which was achieved by deleting their names from the database. The banner was visible for a period of 3 months, during which 7,584 respondents completed the survey. All measures were in Spanish. Procedure Participants provided demographic and professional data and responded to a series of questionnaires. All measures included in this study are described below. Demographic and professional background Participants provided information about (a) age, (b) gender, (c) current work status, (d) field of practice, (e) number of years in the field, (f) number of years in their current workplace, (g) whether they do “on call” shifts, (h) whether they felt valued by their patients, patients’ caregivers, supervisors, colleagues (Y/N for each one), and (i) whether they felt their medical practice had affected their personal lives, (j) number of sick days they had used during the past 12 months, and (k) whether they had taken a leave of absence during the last year. Empathy Participants completed the Interpersonal Reactivity Inventory (IRI) [19]. Measures derived from the IRI were three 7-item subscales, assessing specific aspects of

Read the complete text