PRISMA for Abstracts: reporting systematic reviews in journal and conference abstracts.
Beller EM, Glasziou PP, Altman DG, Hopewell S, Bastian H, Chalmers I, Gøtzsche PC, Lasserson T, Tovey D, PRISMA for Abstracts Group. · 2013
Read PRISMA for Abstracts: reporting systematic reviews in journal and conference abstracts. by Beller EM, Glasziou PP, Altman DG, Hopewell S, Bastian H, Chalmers I, Gøtzsche PC, Lasserson T, Tovey D, PRISMA for Abstracts Group. (2013) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3621753.txt.
Introduction
Elaine Beller and colleagues issued a checklist for writing review abstracts in PLoS Medicine in 2013, as the PRISMA for Abstracts group. Systematic reviews are often read only as abstracts, in journals or conference programs, and those summaries were being written badly: methods hidden, findings cherry-picked, searches hard to repeat. A structured abstract should let a reader judge validity and fit quickly and let databases index the review properly. Existing guidance had not fixed the habit.
The group built its checklist by consensus as an official extension of the main PRISMA reporting statement. Items walk an author through the essentials: the question, eligibility rules, sources searched, how bias was judged, the headline numbers with their uncertainty, limits, and funding. Conference abstracts, squeezed for space, get the same skeleton. The authors frame the list as a floor, not a ceiling, meant to make the world's review literature screenable at a glance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Beller EM, Glasziou PP, Altman DG, Hopewell S, Bastian H, Chalmers I, Gøtzsche PC, Lasserson T, Tovey D, PRISMA for Abstracts Group. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2013 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| LICENSE | CC0 1.0 Universal |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
PRISMA for Abstracts: Reporting Systematic Reviews in Journal and Conference Abstracts By Elaine M Beller, Paul P Glasziou, Douglas G Altman, Sally Hopewell, Hilda Bastian, Iain Chalmers, Peter C Gøtzsche, Toby Lasserson, David Tovey Published in: PLoS Medicine DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001419 ABSTRACT Abstract Elaine Beller and colleagues from the PRISMA for Abstracts group provide a reporting guidelines for reporting abstracts of systematic reviews in journals and at conferences. Summary PointsThe abstract of a systematic review should provide a structured summary that enables a quick assessment of the review's validity and applicability, and easy identification in electronic searching.Despite published guidance on writing the abstract in the PRISMA Statement guiding the reporting of systematic reviews in general and elsewhere, evaluations show that reporting of systematic reviews in journal and conference abstracts is poor.We developed consensus-based reporting guidelines as an extension to the PRISMA Statement on good reporting of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in abstracts.The PRISMA for Abstracts checklist gives authors a framework for condensing their systematic review into the essentials for an abstract that will meet the needs of many readers. INTRODUCTION When readers screen the title of an article, and parts of its abstract, they try to determine whether or not to devote their scarce time to reading on. Some may be screening literature to identify the articles that are systematic reviews. Thus, the main function of an abstract of a systematic review should be to signal its systematic methodology. For most readers, the findings described in the abstract will also be key, either as the sole part of an article that will be read, or to determine whether reading the full text is required. Abstracts of systematic reviews are very important, as some readers cannot access the full paper, such that abstracts may be the only option for gleaning research results. This can be because of a pay wall, low Internet download capacity, or if the full article is only available in a language not understood by the reader. Readers in countries where English is not the primary language may have access to an abstract translated to their own language, but not to a translated full text. Conversely, a large proportion of systematic reviews are published by health technology agencies in non-English speaking countries [1], many of which provide only the abstract in English. The predominance of the abstract in biomedical literature use is clear. Within queries to PubMed, most readers look only at titles; only half of searches result in any clicks on content [2]. The average number of titles clicked on to obtain the abstract or full text, even after retrieving several searches in a row, is less than five. Of those clicks, abstracts will be represented about 2.5 times more often than full texts of articles [2]. Even people going straight to a PDF or full text are likely to start, and perhaps end, with reading the abstract. The frequency of viewing full texts is somewhat higher among people searching the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews [3], but the same pattern is clear. After the title, the abstract is the most read part of a biomedical article. Abstracts can be useful for screening by study type [4]; facilitating quick assessment of validity [4],[5]; enabling efficient perusal of electronic search results [4],[6]; clarifying to which patients and settings the results apply [4],[5]; providing readers and peer reviewers with explicit summaries of results [5]; facilitating the pre-publication peer review process [7]; and increasing precision of computerised searches [6],[7]. Structured abstracts were introduced in the medical literature about 25 years ago [4]–[6]. They provide readers with a series of headings, generally about the purpose, methods, results, and conclusions of the report, and have been adopted by many journals and conferences. They act as a prompt to the writer to give more complete information, and facilitate the finding of information by the reader. Despite the adoption of structured abstracts, studies of the quality of abstracts of clinical trials have demonstrated that improvement is needed [8],[9], and a study of systematic review abstracts demonstrated that the direction of the effect or association could not be determined in one in four abstracts from the general and specialty medical literature [10]. The PRISMA Statement [11] gives some guidance for abstracts, closely linked to commonly used headings in structured abstracts. After observing that the quality of abstracts of systematic reviews is still poor [10], we decided to develop an extension to the PRISMA Statement to provide guidance on writing abstracts for systematic reviews. We also wanted to provide a checklist enabling the items suggested to fit into any set of headings mandated by a journal or conference submission. METHODS FOR DEVELOPMENT OF THE CHECKLIST We established a steering committee (EMB, PPG, SH, DGA). In collaboration with the steering group of the PRISMA Statement [11], we used the Statement to inform our selection of potential items for the checklist of essential items that authors should consider when reporting the primary results of a systematic review in a journal or conference abstract. The committee generated a list of items from PRISMA and other sources of guidance and information on structured abstracts and abstract composition and reporting [7],[11],[12], which were found using a thorough search of the literature. In preparation for a consensus meeting, we used a modified Delphi consensus survey method [13] to select and reduce the number of possible checklist items. Each item was rated by survey participants as “omit”, “possible”, “desirable”, or “essential” to include in the final checklist. From the first round of the survey, the ranked items were divided into three lists for the second round. The first list contained the items with the highest rankings, and participants for the second round were instructed that these would be contained in the checklist unless they received low rankings in the second round. The second list contained the items with moderate rankings, and participants were instructed that these items were likely to be removed from the checklist unless they received high rankings in the second round. The third list contained the items with low rankings, and participants were instructed that these items would be removed unless they received very high rankings in the second round. For the third round of the Delphi survey, a draft checklist was presented, which included only the items ranked highest in rounds one and two. The five next highest-ranked items were then presented, giving participants an opportunity to choose to include these in the checklist as well. One hundred and forty-seven participants, who were authors of research on abstracts, established authors of systematic reviews, methodologists or statisticians related to systematic reviews, and journal editors, were invited by email to complete the three rounds of the web-based survey. The response rate was 68% (n = 100) for the first round. Only those who completed round one were invited to participate in rounds two and three. The response rate for round two was 80% (n = 80) and for round three 88% (n = 88). The results of the survey were reported at a two-day consensus-style meeting on 13–14 October 2011, in Oxford, United Kingdom. Fifteen invited experts attended, most of whom had participated in the survey. The meeting began with a review