Modeling causes of death: an integrated approach using CODEm.

Foreman KJ, Lozano R, Lopez AD, Murray CJ. · 2012

Read Modeling causes of death: an integrated approach using CODEm. by Foreman KJ, Lozano R, Lopez AD, Murray CJ. (2012) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3315398.txt.

Introduction

Foreman, Lozano, Lopez, and Murray described a new system for estimating what people die of around the world, in a 2012 paper. Cause of death figures guide health spending, yet many countries lack good records, and even strong systems classify deaths inconsistently. Earlier estimation methods leaned on a single model, which risks building in the model maker's bias.

Their tool, called CODEm, tries many combinations of explanatory factors across four families of models for each cause of death. It then grades every model by how well it predicts data it has not seen, and blends the best performers into one combined estimate. In tests, the blended models beat every single model at accuracy, trend prediction, and honest uncertainty ranges. Results are shown in detail for maternal deaths and in summary for heart disease and several cancers.

Catalog record

CREATORForeman KJ, Lozano R, Lopez AD, Murray CJ.
YEAR2012
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3315398

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling causes of death: an integrated approach using CODEm By Kyle J Foreman, Rafael Lozano, Alan D Lopez, Christopher JL Murray Published in: Population Health Metrics DOI: 10.1186/1478-7954-10-1 ABSTRACT Background Data on causes of death by age and sex are a critical input into health decision-making. Priority setting in public health should be informed not only by the current magnitude of health problems but by trends in them. However, cause of death data are often not available or are subject to substantial problems of comparability. We propose five general principles for cause of death model development, validation, and reporting. Methods We detail a specific implementation of these principles that is embodied in an analytical tool - the Cause of Death Ensemble model (CODEm) - which explores a large variety of possible models to estimate trends in causes of death. Possible models are identified using a covariate selection algorithm that yields many plausible combinations of covariates, which are then run through four model classes. The model classes include mixed effects linear models and spatial-temporal Gaussian Process Regression models for cause fractions and death rates. All models for each cause of death are then assessed using out-of-sample predictive validity and combined into an ensemble with optimal out-of-sample predictive performance. Results Ensemble models for cause of death estimation outperform any single component model in tests of root mean square error, frequency of predicting correct temporal trends, and achieving 95% coverage of the prediction interval. We present detailed results for CODEm applied to maternal mortality and summary results for several other causes of death, including cardiovascular disease and several cancers. Conclusions CODEm produces better estimates of cause of death trends than previous methods and is less susceptible to bias in model specification. We demonstrate the utility of CODEm for the estimation of several major causes of death. BACKGROUND Data on causes of death by age and sex are a critical input into health decision-making. Nations devote considerable resources to collecting, collating, and analyzing various types of cause of death data for this reason [1-3]. Priority setting in public health, however, should be informed not only by the current magnitude of health problems but by trends in them. Whether or not a cause of death is increasing or decreasing is important information as to whether current disease control efforts are working or inadequate. The rising burden of diabetes and the policy debate it has triggered is a good example of the importance of monitoring national trends in causes of death [4,5]. The fundamental challenge for most countries, however, is that cause of death data are often not available or subject to substantial problems of comparability. Even in the 89 countries with complete vital registration systems and medical certification of causes of death in 2009, many issues of comparability remain [6-8]. Dramatic changes from year to year in death rates from a cause can be due to changes in International Classification of Diseases (ICD) revision [9,10] or national modifications of coding rules [11-14]. In some cases, causes such as HIV or diabetes may be systematically misclassified [8,15-21]. The fraction of deaths assigned to causes that are not true underlying causes of death can vary widely and change over time [20,22-27]. In places without complete vital registration, a range of sources such as verbal autopsy studies (national or subnational), partial urban vital registration, or survey/census data may be available. Data may be available only for a limited number of years and these data are often subject to substantial sampling and even larger nonsampling error. Generating national assessments of causes of death by age, sex, and year requires a strategy and methodology to deal with this diverse set of data issues. Efforts to model causes of death using available data have a long history [28-34]. Initial attempts focused on estimating causes of death for a cross-section of countries by modeling cause as a function of overall mortality levels. For example, Preston's 1976 Mortality Patterns in National Populations: With Special Reference to Recorded Causes of Death [28] was the initial effort to assess trends in causes of death taking into account misclassification of deaths. The demand for estimates of both levels and trends in key causes from diverse groups have led to multiple recent studies on diarrhea, maternal mortality, and other causes of death [29-31,35-37]. These studies have used a wide variety of analytical strategies and specific model implementations. The recent debate on maternal mortality estimation [35,36,38-41] is an illustration of quite different choices of the dependent variable and model specifications. The use of Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) and other related techniques has been used for all-cause mortality in children and adults and in time series cross-sectional work on key risk factors [5,42-45]. Affordable computational power and innovations in Bayesian statistical modeling have fueled a steady growth in alternative estimation strategies. This innovation is likely to continue for the foreseeable future. Comparing alternative modeling approaches applied to the same cause of death is complicated by a lack of accepted standards for good cause of death modeling practice. Preferences for the results of alternative strategies may be based not on documented performance but on impressionistic grounds. In this paper, we propose five general principles for cause of death model development, validation, and reporting. We then detail a specific implementation of these principles that is embodied in an analytical tool, CODEm - the Cause of Death Ensemble model. Principles for cause of death model development 1. Identify all the available data Good cause of death modeling practice begins with a systematic attempt to identify all the available data. Most cause of death data is captured through a variety of national data collection systems such as partial or complete vital registration or national or sample registration systems with verbal autopsy. Most of these data are not published in the scientific literature but are available through national sources or the World Health Organization (in the case of vital registration with medical certification of causes of death). These main sources can also be supplemented with subnational studies on select causes or age groups from the published literature through systematic reviews. For some diseases, there may be special sources of information, such as population-based cancer registry data for mortality from selected cancers in particular catchment areas. 2. Maximize the comparability and quality of the dataset After all the available data have been identified, several common challenges for the comparability and quality of cause of death data need to be addressed, including mapping across various revisions of the ICD, variation in garbage coding across countries and time, misclassification due to poor diagnostic capacity, comparability of alternative verbal autopsy methods, completeness of cause of death registration, and large nonsampling variance. There is an extensive literature on the mapping for different causes across revisions of the ICD [13,46]; the challenge is greater for certain specific causes of death. A second important source of known bias is the assignment of a substantial fraction of deaths to causes of death that are not underlying causes of death, often called "garbage codes"[27,47-49]. Preston in 1976 already noted that trends in cardiovascular disease over time were profoundly different if garbage codes were taken into account [28,36]. The Global Burden of Diseases, Injuries,

Read the complete text