Hitting hotspots: spatial targeting of malaria for control and elimination.

Bousema T, Griffin JT, Sauerwein RW, Smith DL, Churcher TS, Takken W, Ghani A, Drakeley C, Gosling R. · 2012

Read Hitting hotspots: spatial targeting of malaria for control and elimination. by Bousema T, Griffin JT, Sauerwein RW, Smith DL, Churcher TS, Takken W, Ghani A, Drakeley C, Gosling R. (2012) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3269430.txt.

Introduction

Teun Bousema and colleagues argued for aiming malaria control at transmission hotspots, in this 2012 paper in PLoS Medicine. Malaria, like many infections, is unevenly spread: a small share of households bears a greatly increased risk of transmission. Those clusters occur in every setting, though they blur into the background where transmission is intense.

The authors marshal the logic and evidence for spatial targeting. Hotspots sustain transmission through the dry, low season and ignite it again when the rains return, so suppressing them should cut transmission community-wide. They contend that focusing resources on these pockets is highly efficient at every level of transmission intensity, from places battling heavy malaria to those nearing elimination. The piece is a policy argument for making geography a deliberate part of malaria strategy.

Catalog record

CREATORBousema T, Griffin JT, Sauerwein RW, Smith DL, Churcher TS, Takken W, Ghani A, Drakeley C, Gosling R.
YEAR2012
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3269430

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hitting Hotspots: Spatial Targeting of Malaria for Control and Elimination By Teun Bousema, Jamie T Griffin, Robert W Sauerwein, David L Smith, Thomas S Churcher, Willem Takken, Azra Ghani, Chris Drakeley, Roly Gosling Published in: PLoS Medicine DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001165 ABSTRACT Abstract Teun Bousema and colleagues argue that targeting malaria “hotspots” is a highly efficient way to reduce malaria transmission at all levels of transmission intensity. Summary PointsHeterogeneity is a common facet of infectious diseases, whereby infection and disease are concentrated in a small proportion of individuals.In malaria, heterogeneity is manifested as small groups of households, or hotspots, that are at a substantially increased risk of malaria transmission.These hotspots exist in all transmission settings but are less easily detected at high transmission intensity.Hotspots maintain transmission in low transmission seasons and fuel transmission in the high transmission seasons.Targeting hotspots is a highly efficient way to reduce malaria transmission at all levels of transmission intensity. INTRODUCTION Current malaria elimination guidelines are based on the concept that malaria transmission becomes heterogeneous in the later phases of malaria elimination [1]. In the pre-elimination and elimination phases, interventions have to be targeted to entire villages or towns with higher malaria incidence until only individual episodes of malaria remain and become the centre of attention [1]. With increasing evidence of clustering of malaria episodes within villages, we argue that there is an intermediate step. Heterogeneity in malaria transmission within villages is present long before areas enter the pre-elimination phase, and identifying and targeting hotspots of malaria transmission should form the cornerstone of both successful malaria control and malaria elimination. HETEROGENEITY, CLUSTERING, TRANSMISSION FOCI, AND HOTSPOTS Variation in the risk of malaria between villages in endemic regions has long been recognized [2]–[4]. This variation is common for many infectious and parasitic diseases where a small number of human hosts are most frequently or most heavily infected while the majority of a local population carry few or no infections [5]–[8]. In malaria, this is exemplified by a study in Dielmo, Senegal, where children were monitored daily during their first 2 years of life. Some children suffered only one episode of clinical malaria, whilst others suffered up to 20 episodes [9]. In Kenya, researchers noted that malaria exposure could not be homogenous as malaria incidence did not follow a Poisson distribution, a phenomenon they describe as over-dispersion [10]. Over-dispersion is commonly recognized in other infectious diseases, where a small proportion (20%) of the population is responsible for the majority (80%) of transmission, the so-called “20/80 rule” [8],[11]–[13]. Micro-epidemiological variations in malaria exposure are most easily recognized in areas of low or moderate transmission intensity where a considerable proportion of the population may remain malaria free for several years while others experience multiple episodes [8],[11],[14]. In areas exposed to intense malaria transmission, heterogeneity in exposure is also present [15],[16], but may be obscured because the majority of the population experiences at least one infection per year and many infections are carried asymptomatically. At present, the factors underlying the micro-epidemiology of malaria are not fully understood but include variation in distance to the nearest mosquito breeding site, water body or vegetation [14]–[17], household structural features [14]–[17], and both human behavioural [15],[17] and genetic factors [15],[17] that may also result in differential attractiveness to mosquitoes [18]. These factors differ at global and local geographical scales and lead to different and confusing definitions of foci of malaria transmission and hotspots of malaria transmission. Entire countries or islands have been classified as malaria hotspots [19],[20], or the term hotspots of malaria transmission may be reserved for smaller geographical areas [14],[21]–[23], sometimes smaller than 1 km2 [22],[23]. DEFINING A HOTSPOT OF MALARIA TRANSMISSION Two related but distinct geographical units in malaria transmission can be defined: (1) The World Health Organization defines a focus of malaria transmission as a defined and circumscribed locality situated in a currently or former malarious area containing the continuous or intermittent epidemiological factors necessary for malaria transmission. Foci of malaria transmission can be classified as residual active, residual nonactive, cleared up, new potential, new active, endemic, or pseudofoci [1]. In more academic terms, an active focus of malaria transmission is a geographical area that supports malaria transmission, where the local Anopheles population sustains the basic reproductive rate (R 0; average number of secondary infections arising in a susceptible population as a result of a single individual with malaria over the course of their malaria infection) at a level above 1 [16]. Its size depends on the mosquito breeding site that forms the centre of the focus and the effective dispersal range of vector mosquitoes, which is several kilometres. The border is the furthest location where malaria is still supported by the breeding site. (2) A hotspot of malaria transmission is defined as a geographical part of a focus of malaria transmission where transmission intensity exceeds the average level. Several hotspots of malaria transmission may be present in a single focus of malaria transmission. Micro-epidemiological conditions for malaria transmission are favourable in a hotspot of malaria transmission, resulting in R 0 estimates that exceed the average for the focus of malaria transmission. The size of a hotspot of malaria transmission is variable but typically <1 km2 and smaller than the maximum dispersal range of vector mosquitoes; its borders are defined by the distance from the centre of the hotspot where transmission intensity is no longer (statistically significantly) higher than the average for the focus of malaria transmission [14],[21]. WHY HOTSPOTS ARE IMPORTANT IN MALARIA TRANSMISSION Heterogeneity in mosquito exposure is key to understanding the differences between foci and hotspots of malaria transmission and their implications for malaria control. Individuals who are bitten most often are most likely to be infected and can amplify transmission by transmitting the malaria parasites to a large number of mosquitoes. Estimates of R 0 are very susceptible to variations in mosquito biting behaviour. R 0 may increase considerably as a consequence of heterogeneity in this behaviour [8],[12]; the susceptibility of R 0 to heterogeneous bitingthis is illustrated by Table 1 where estimates of R 0 increased 1.5- to 4.5-fold as a consequence of introducing heterogeneous biting into a mathematical model of malaria [24] in four villages exposed to moderate transmission intensity in northern Tanzania [14]. [Table: Estimates of the basic reproductive number (R 0) for a given parasite prevalence and heterogeneous mosquito exposure in four villages in northern Tanzania.] There are two reasons why hotspots are relevant for malaria control [8],[12],[25]. Firstly, if interventions are untargeted, hotspots are likely to be the areas where residual malaria transmission will persist. This hypothesis is supported by observations that hotspots of malaria transmission remained unaltered after overall malaria transmission is reduced [22],[23],[26]. Hotspots of malaria transmission can thereby form a major stumbling block in efforts to eliminate malaria [25]. Secondly, hotspots of malaria transmission are likely to play a catalysing role in areas of stable transmission. Figure 1 shows a schematic of the hotspot theory whereby a few households maintain higher transmission at all time periods. In the dry season the hotspot supports continuing transmission; in the wet season it acts as a source of infection for the rest of the village. This exemplifies the difference between hotspots and foci of

Read the complete text