Most random gene expression signatures are significantly associated with breast cancer outcome.

Venet D, Dumont JE, Detours V. · 2011

Read Most random gene expression signatures are significantly associated with breast cancer outcome. by Venet D, Dumont JE, Detours V. (2011) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3197658.txt.

Introduction

David Venet, Jacques Dumont, and Vincent Detours wrote this 2011 critique in PLoS Computational Biology about gene expression signatures in breast cancer. Researchers often claim a biological process matters in human cancer when a gene signature for it predicts patient outcome. The authors tested how strong that logic really is.

They found that random sets of genes predicted breast cancer outcome about as well as most published signatures. Even signatures from unrelated experiments, on laughter and on social defeat in mice, did so. The hidden driver was cell proliferation: genes tied to a proliferation marker explained nearly all of the predictive power. Adjusting for that marker erased most associations, so the authors urge caution and offer methods to correct for it.

Catalog record

CREATORVenet D, Dumont JE, Detours V.
YEAR2011
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3197658

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Most Random Gene Expression Signatures Are Significantly Associated with Breast Cancer Outcome By David Venet, Jacques E. Dumont, Vincent Detours, Isidore Rigoutsos Published in: PLoS Computational Biology DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1002240 ABSTRACT Bridging the gap between animal or in vitro models and human disease is essential in medical research. Researchers often suggest that a biological mechanism is relevant to human cancer from the statistical association of a gene expression marker (a signature) of this mechanism, that was discovered in an experimental system, with disease outcome in humans. We examined this argument for breast cancer. Surprisingly, we found that gene expression signatures—unrelated to cancer—of the effect of postprandial laughter, of mice social defeat and of skin fibroblast localization were all significantly associated with breast cancer outcome. We next compared 47 published breast cancer outcome signatures to signatures made of random genes. Twenty-eight of them (60%) were not significantly better outcome predictors than random signatures of identical size and 11 (23%) were worst predictors than the median random signature. More than 90% of random signatures >100 genes were significant outcome predictors. We next derived a metagene, called meta-PCNA, by selecting the 1% genes most positively correlated with proliferation marker PCNA in a compendium of normal tissues expression. Adjusting breast cancer expression data for meta-PCNA abrogated almost entirely the outcome association of published and random signatures. We also found that, in the absence of adjustment, the hazard ratio of outcome association of a signature strongly correlated with meta-PCNA (R2 = 0.9). This relation also applied to single-gene expression markers. Moreover, >50% of the breast cancer transcriptome was correlated with meta-PCNA. A corollary was that purging cell cycle genes out of a signature failed to rule out the confounding effect of proliferation. Hence, it is questionable to suggest that a mechanism is relevant to human breast cancer from the finding that a gene expression marker for this mechanism predicts human breast cancer outcome, because most markers do. The methods we present help to overcome this problem. INTRODUCTION Ethics limits experimental investigation on human subjects. Hence, most experimental biomedical research is performed on animal and/or in vitro models. Proving that findings from model systems are relevant to human health is a major bottleneck. Hundreds of studies in oncology have suggested the biological relevance to human of putative cancer-driving mechanisms with the following three steps: 1) characterize the mechanism in a model system, 2) derive from the model system a marker whose expression changes when the mechanism is altered, and 3) show that marker expression correlates with disease outcome in patients—the last figure of such paper is typically a Kaplan-Meier plot illustrating this correlation. Breast cancer has been a test bed in oncogenomics. Several landmark studies (reviewed in ref. [1]) uncovered multi-gene mRNA markers of disease recurrence, which are independent of classical clinical markers and may provide useful information to guide treatment. These clinically motivated multi-genes markers, also called signatures, were derived from compendia of genome-wide mRNA tumoral profiles by selecting genes whose expression correlated with outcome [2]–[5], or with known aggressiveness markers such as proliferation [6]–[9] or grade [10]–[12]. Beyond clinical utility, many signatures were derived as markers of specific mechanisms and/or biological states and their association with outcome was evaluated in the context of studies structured along the 3-steps outlined above. These include signatures of stem cells [13]–[15], aneuploidy [16], wound healing [17], [18], hypoxia [19], [20], stromal component [21], epithelial-mesenchymal transition [22]–[24]; of mutations in TP53 [25], ALK5 [26]; of loss of PTEN [27]; of perturbations of E2F1 [28], bromodomain 4 [29], mir31 targets [30], p18ink4c [31], retinoic acid receptor [32]; of anchorage-independent growth [33], activation of modules related to the proteasome and mitochondrions [34], etc. Contrasting with this diversity, meta-analyses of several outcome signatures have shown that they have essentially equivalent prognostic performances [35], [36], and are highly correlated with proliferation [7]–[8], [37], a predictor of breast cancer outcome that has been used for decades [38]–[40]. This raises a question: are all these mechanisms major independent drivers of breast cancer progression, or is step #3 inconclusive because of a basic confounding variable problem? To take an example of complex system outside oncology, let us suppose we are trying to discover which socio-economical variables drive people's health. We may find that the number of TV sets per household is positively correlated with longer life expectancy. This, of course, does not imply that TV sets improve health. Life expectancy and TV sets per household are both correlated with the gross national product per capita of nations, as are many other causes or byproducts of wealth such as energy consumption or education. So, is the significant association of say, a stem cell signature, with human breast cancer outcome informative about the relevance of stem cells to human breast cancer? Resolving this issue has become more pressing recently. Several large cohorts with genome-wide tumoral expression profiles and patient follow-ups are available in the public domain. Servers resting on these data [41], [42] make step #3 accessible to anyone with an Internet connection. Genome-wide expression profiling has also considerably lowered the barrier to step #2. The search for markers is reduced to a nearly automated screen by comparing microarray profiles in situations where the putative cancer-driving mechanism is active or inactive. The end result is an increasing number of signatures. Few studies using the outcome-association argument present negative controls to check whether their signature of interest is indeed more strongly related to outcome than signatures with no underlying oncological rationale. In statistical terms, these studies typically rest on H0 assuming a background of no association with outcome. The negative controls we present here prove this assumption wrong: a random signature is more likely to be correlated with breast cancer outcome than not. The statistical explanation for this phenomenon lies in the correlation of a large fraction of the breast transcriptome with one variable, we call it meta-PCNA, which integrates most of the prognostic information available in current breast cancer gene expression data. RESULTS Most signatures not biologically related to cancer are statistically associated with breast cancer outcome In order to assess whether association with outcome was specific, we tested the association with breast cancer outcome of three signatures whose rationale does not suggest any connection with cancer: a signature of the effect of postprandial laughter on peripheral blood mononuclear cells [43], a signature of skin fibroblast localization [44] and a signature of social defeat obtained from mice brains [45]. For the sake of simplicity, and because this is the most commonly used setup in the field, we focused on the 295 patients of the Netherlands Cancer Institute (a.k.a. NKI) cohort [2] and the overall survival end-point. Details on the procedure used to estimate association with outcome are provided in Supporting Information (Text S1). Surprisingly, the three control signatures were significantly associated with outcome (Figure 1, panels A–C). [Figure: Association of negative control signatures with overall survival.In plots A–C the NKI cohort was split into two groups using a signature of post-prandial laughter (panel A), localization of skin fibroblasts (panel B), social defeat in mice (panel C). In panels A–C, the fraction of patients alive (overall survival, OS) is shown as a function of time for both groups. Hazard ratios

Read the complete text