Interventions targeting social isolation in older people: a systematic review.

Dickens AP, Richards SH, Greaves CJ, Campbell JL. · 2011

Read Interventions targeting social isolation in older people: a systematic review. by Dickens AP, Richards SH, Greaves CJ, Campbell JL. (2011) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3170621.txt.

Introduction

Andy Dickens and colleagues reviewed programmes tackling loneliness and isolation in older people in a 2011 paper in BMC Public Health. Isolation harms health and well-being, and a quarter of the population will soon be over sixty. Thirty-two trials and comparison studies of social interventions, published before mid 2009, met their criteria.

Group-based programmes improved at least one health outcome far more often than one-to-one schemes. Programmes where older people take an active part, rather than passively receiving visits, also did better, as did those built on a stated theory. Activity and support groups beat home visiting, and internet training fared worst. Oddly, programmes aimed squarely at isolated people did worse than open ones. Study quality was shaky overall, so the authors demand better trials.

Catalog record

CREATORDickens AP, Richards SH, Greaves CJ, Campbell JL.
YEAR2011
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3170621

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interventions targeting social isolation in older people: a systematic review By Andy P Dickens, Suzanne H Richards, Colin J Greaves, John L Campbell Published in: BMC Public Health DOI: 10.1186/1471-2458-11-647 ABSTRACT Background Targeting social isolation in older people is a growing public health concern. The proportion of older people in society has increased in recent decades, and it is estimated that approximately 25% of the population will be aged 60 or above within the next 20 to 40 years. Social isolation is prevalent amongst older people and evidence indicates the detrimental effect that it can have on health and wellbeing. The aim of this review was to assess the effectiveness of interventions designed to alleviate social isolation and loneliness in older people. Methods Relevant electronic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, ASSIA, IBSS, PsycINFO, PubMed, DARE, Social Care Online, the Cochrane Library and CINAHL) were systematically searched using an extensive search strategy, for randomised controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies published in English before May 2009. Additional articles were identified through citation tracking. Studies were included if they related to older people, if the intervention aimed to alleviate social isolation and loneliness, if intervention participants were compared against inactive controls and, if treatment effects were reported. Two independent reviewers extracted data using a standardised form. Narrative synthesis and vote-counting methods were used to summarise and interpret study data. Results Thirty two studies were included in the review. There was evidence of substantial heterogeneity in the interventions delivered and the overall quality of included studies indicated a medium to high risk of bias. Across the three domains of social, mental and physical health, 79% of group-based interventions and 55% of one-to-one interventions reported at least one improved participant outcome. Over 80% of participatory interventions produced beneficial effects across the same domains, compared with 44% of those categorised as non-participatory. Of interventions categorised as having a theoretical basis, 87% reported beneficial effects across the three domains compared with 59% of interventions with no evident theoretical foundation. Regarding intervention type, 86% of those providing activities and 80% of those providing support resulted in improved participant outcomes, compared with 60% of home visiting and 25% of internet training interventions. Fifty eight percent of interventions that explicitly targeted socially isolated or lonely older people reported positive outcomes, compared with 80% of studies with no explicit targeting. Conclusions More, well-conducted studies of the effectiveness of social interventions for alleviating social isolation are needed to improve the evidence base. However, it appeared that common characteristics of effective interventions were those developed within the context of a theoretical basis, and those offering social activity and/or support within a group format. Interventions in which older people are active participants also appeared more likely to be effective. Future interventions incorporating all of these characteristics may therefore be more successful in targeting social isolation in older people. BACKGROUND In the United Kingdom, people aged 60 or above currently account for approximately 20% of the population [1], and this proportion is expected to rise to 24% by 2030 [2]. In comparison, 11% of the world's population was aged 60 or above in 2007, rising to an estimated 22% by 2050 [3]. The ageing population has resulted in emphasis being placed on health status trends of older people and how these trends may change in future, due to the anticipated increased demand for health and social care services [4]. The concept of social isolation has been defined in various ways in academic literature. Many authors agree that it is a uni-dimensional concept referring to the lack of social integration [5-8]. However, this assumes that all social contacts have the same social value or importance [9]. Alternate definitions of social isolation incorporate both 'structural' and 'functional' social support [10,11]. Structural social support is an objective assessment of size and frequency, while functional social support is a subjective judgement of the quality or perceived value of emotional, instrumental and informational support provided by others [12]. The second definition of social isolation is therefore multi-dimensional, including both the minimal quantity and quality of social support. We adopted the latter definition for the purposes of our review. Two terms often used interchangeably in academic literature are 'social isolation' and 'loneliness'. Loneliness is a subjective concept resulting from a perceived absence or loss of companionship [6,13-15]. Social loneliness refers to negative feelings resulting from the absence of meaningful relationships and social integration, whereas emotional loneliness refers to the perceived lack of an attachment figure or confidant [16]. The two forms of loneliness differ in potential duration, as the former may be alleviated through gaining new acquaintances while the latter can only be resolved by the formation of an intimate bond [17], which may take longer. While social isolation concerns the lack of structural and functional social support, loneliness relates specifically to one's negative feelings about that situation [18]. Expanding the distinction further, while social isolation may be either voluntary or involuntary, loneliness is always involuntary [6,19]. A recent meta-analysis of 148 longitudinal studies (308,849 participants, mean age of 64 years) reported a 50% reduction in the likelihood of mortality for individuals with strong social relationships [20]. A limitation of this review is that 'strong social relationships' was a composite variable that combined conceptually distinct measures of an individual's social context (e.g. loneliness, social isolation etc). Notwithstanding this, the authors observed that the impact of social relationships on the risk of mortality is comparable with major, well-established risk factors such as smoking and alcohol consumption, and exceeds that of physical inactivity and obesity. Studies focusing specifically on the measurement of social isolation and health report similar relationships. For example, social isolation is associated with increased mortality [21], poor self-rated physical health [22] and increased susceptibility to dementia [23] in the general population of older people, and with the onset of disability among older males living alone [24]. In a recent study we found that social isolation was negatively associated with health status and health-related quality of life of older people [25]. Risk factors for social isolation in older people include a lack of access to private transport, minimal or no contact with friends and family, low morale and living alone [26-28]. The prevalence of social isolation amongst older people is substantial, estimated to be 7 - 17% depending on the definition and outcome measure used [14,27,29-31]. The related, but distinct concept of loneliness is reported to be experienced by approximately 40% of this age group [32-34]. The prevalence of social isolation, combined with the evidence that it can impact on an individual's health and wellbeing, supports the targeting of social isolation as an important public health issue. The development of strategies to increase older people's participation in society has been a major, cross-cutting component of recent UK government policies regarding the delivery of health and social care, as well as wider policies and reviews relating to social cohesion and the tackling of social inequalities [35-39]. However, while there is a substantial evidence base supporting the targeting of social isolation as a public health priority, as well as a clear policy agenda advocating the implementation of interventions to ameliorate its effects, there remains considerable uncertainty regarding the characteristics of interventions that are effective and

Read the complete text