Effective connectivity: influence, causality and biophysical modeling.
Valdes-Sosa PA, Roebroeck A, Daunizeau J, Friston K. · 2011
Read Effective connectivity: influence, causality and biophysical modeling. by Valdes-Sosa PA, Roebroeck A, Daunizeau J, Friston K. (2011) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3167373.txt.
Introduction
Pedro Valdes-Sosa, Alard Roebroeck, Jean Daunizeau, and Karl Friston closed a journal debate series on mapping directed influence between brain areas in a 2011 paper in NeuroImage. Simple correlations show areas active together, but claims about which area drives which need models of cause. The authors argue such claims stand or fall on models grounded in brain biophysics.
They compare the main approaches, including their own dynamic causal modelling and a rival based on prediction timing, and connect both to older statistical ideas about influence and dependency networks. Models, they insist, must include realistic observation and state equations, prior knowledge about parameters, and checks that parameters can actually be identified from data. The paper maps promising fixes for the field's known challenges.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valdes-Sosa PA, Roebroeck A, Daunizeau J, Friston K. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2011 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 145 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effective connectivity: Influence, causality and biophysical modeling By Pedro A Valdes-Sosa, Alard Roebroeck, Jean Daunizeau, Karl Friston Published in: Neuroimage DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.03.058 ABSTRACT Abstract This is the final paper in a Comments and Controversies series dedicated to “The identification of interacting networks in the brain using fMRI: Model selection, causality and deconvolution”. We argue that discovering effective connectivity depends critically on state-space models with biophysically informed observation and state equations. These models have to be endowed with priors on unknown parameters and afford checks for model Identifiability. We consider the similarities and differences among Dynamic Causal Modeling, Granger Causal Modeling and other approaches. We establish links between past and current statistical causal modeling, in terms of Bayesian dependency graphs and Wiener–Akaike–Granger–Schweder influence measures. We show that some of the challenges faced in this field have promising solutions and speculate on future developments. Keywords: Granger Causality, Effective connectivity, Dynamic Causal Modeling, EEG, fMRI INTRODUCTION Following an empirical evaluation of effective connectivity measurements (David et al., 2008) and a primer on its implications (Friston, 2009a), the Comments and Controversy (C&C) exchange, initiated by Roebroeck et al. (2011b-this issue) and continued by David, 2009, Friston, 2011, and Roebroeck et al. (2011a-this issue), has provided a lively and constructive discussion on the relative merits of two current techniques, Granger Causal Modeling (GCM)1 and Dynamic Causal Modeling (DCM), for detecting effective connectivity using EEG/MEG and fMRI time series. The core papers of the C&C have been complemented by authoritative contributions (Bressler and Seth, 2010, Daunizeau et al., 2011a, Marinazzo et al., 2010) that clarify the state of the art for each approach. This final paper in the series attempts to summarize the main points discussed and elaborate a conceptual framework for the analysis of effective connectivity (Fig. 1, Fig. 2). Inferring effective connectivity comprises the successive steps of model specification, model identification and model (causal) inference (see Fig. 1).These steps are common to DCM, GCM and indeed any evidence-based inference. We will look at the choices made at each stage to clarify current areas of agreement and disagreement, of successes and shortcomings. [Figure: Overview of causal modeling in Neuroimaging. Overall view of conceptual framework for defining and detecting effective connectivity in Neuroimaging studies.] [Figure: Data and model driven approaches to causal modeling. Data driven approaches look for nonparametric models that not only fit the data but also describe important dynamical properties. They complement hypothesis driven approaches that are not only constrained by having to explain dynamical behavior but also provide links to computational models of brain function.] This entails a selective review of key issues and lines of work. Although an important area, we will not consider models that are just used to measure statistical associations (i.e. functional connectivity). In other words, we limit our focus to discovering effective connectivity (Friston, 2009a); that is causal relations between neural systems. Importantly, we hope to establish a clear terminology to eschew purely semantic discussions, and perhaps dispel some confusion in this regard. While preparing this material, we were struck with how easy it is to recapitulate heated arguments in other fields (such as econometrics), which were resolved several decades ago. We are also mindful of the importance of referring to prior work, to avoid repeating past mistakes2 and to identify where more work is needed to address specific problems in the neurosciences. We shall emphasize several times in this paper that causality is an epistemological concept that can be particularly difficult to capture with equations. This is because one's intuitive understanding of causality becomes inherently constrained whenever one tries to model it. In brief, one can think of causality in at least two distinct ways: - •Temporal precedence, i.e.: causes precede their consequences; - •Physical influence (control), i.e.: changing causes changes their consequences. This distinction is important, since it is the basis for any statistical detection of causal influence. In the context of brain connectivity, identifying causal relationships between two regions in the brain thus depends upon whether one tests for improvement in predictive capacity between temporally distinct neural events or one assesses the distal effect of (experimentally controlled) interventions. Temporal precedence is the basis for Granger-like (what we call WAGS influence, see WAGS influence section) inferences about causality. In its simplest form, the idea is the following: A WAGS-causes B if one reduces the uncertainty about the future of B given the past of A. Statistical tests of WAGS-causality thus rely upon information theoretic measures of predictability (of B given A). In contradistinction, physical influence speaks to the notion of intervention and control, which has been formalized using a probabilistic framework called causal calculus (Pearl, 2000) (Structural causal modeling: graphical models and Bayes–Nets section). Observing (or estimating) activity at a network node potentially provides information about its effects at remote nodes. However, physically acting upon (e.g., fixing) this activity effectively removes any other physical influence this node receives. This means that inferences based on the effects of an intervention are somewhat different in nature from those based on purely observational effects. Generally speaking, inference on structural causality rests on modeling the effects of (controlled) experimental manipulations of the system, c.f. the popular quote ‘no causes in, no causes out’ (Cartwright, 2007). As we shall see later, these two approaches can be combined (Dynamic structural causal modeling section). The structure of the paper is as follows. We first review the types of models used for studying effective connectivity. We then touch briefly on the methods used to invert and make inferences about these models. We then provide a brief summary of modern statistical causal modeling, list some current approaches in the literature and discuss their relevance to brain imaging. Finally, we list outstanding issues that could be addressed and state our conclusions. MODEL SPECIFICATION State-space models of effective connectivity From the C&C discussion, there seems to be a consensus that discovering effective connectivity in Neuroimaging is essentially a comparison of generative models based on state-space models (SSM) of controllable (i.e., “causal” in a control theory sense) biophysical processes that have hidden neural states and possibly exogenous input. While having a long history in engineering (Candy, 2006, Kailath, 1980), SSM was only introduced recently for inference on hidden neural states (Valdes-Sosa et al., 1999, Valdes-Sosa et al., 1996, Valdés-Sosa et al., 1996). For a comprehensive review of SSM and its application in Neuroscience see the forthcoming book (Ozaki, 2011). Neural states describe the activity of a set of “nodes” that comprise a graph, the purpose of causal discovery being the identification of active links (edges or connections) in the graph. The nodes can be associated with neural populations at different levels; most commonly at the macroscopic (whole brain areas) or mesoscopic (sub-areas to cortical columns) level. These state-space models have unknown parameters (e.g., effective connectivity) and hyperparameters (e.g., the amplitude of random fluctuations). The specific model, states, parameters, hyperparameters and observables chosen determines the type of analysis and the nature of the final inference about causality. These choices are summarized in Fig. 1 (Step 1). Given a set of observations or brain measurements, the first problem is: which data features are relevant for detecting causal influences? The most efficient way to address this question is to specify a