Adult consequences of late adolescent alcohol consumption: a systematic review of cohort studies.

McCambridge J, McAlaney J, Rowe R. · 2011

Read Adult consequences of late adolescent alcohol consumption: a systematic review of cohort studies. by McCambridge J, McAlaney J, Rowe R. (2011) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc3035611.txt.

Introduction

McCambridge, McAlaney, and Rowe reviewed in 2011 what happens in adulthood to people who drank alcohol heavily as older teenagers. Many cohort studies had followed young drinkers over time, linking teen drinking to later poor health and social trouble. The reviewers set out to judge how strong that long term evidence really was.

Their verdict was cautious. Studies did suggest links between late teen drinking and worse adult physical and mental health, plus wider social costs. Yet the overall quality of the evidence was poor, with bias and confounding hard to rule out. Heavy drinking late in the teen years is common and peaks before the early twenties in rich countries. The authors argue better long term studies are needed before firm claims about lasting harm can guide policy.

Catalog record

CREATORMcCambridge J, McAlaney J, Rowe R.
YEAR2011
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC3035611

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Adult Consequences of Late Adolescent Alcohol Consumption: A Systematic Review of Cohort Studies By Jim McCambridge, John McAlaney, Richard Rowe, Bruce P. Lanphear Published in: PLoS Medicine DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000413 ABSTRACT In a systematic review of cohort studies of adolescent drinking and later outcomes, Jim McCambridge and colleagues show that although studies suggest links to worse adult physical and mental health and social consequences, existing evidence is of poor quality. INTRODUCTION Alcohol is responsible for approximately 4% of the global burden of disease [1]. This burden is higher in high income countries and among men, accounting for 11% of all male deaths in the World Health Organization (WHO) European region in 2004 [1]. There is global concern about drinking trends among young people, particularly in heavy episodic or “binge” drinking. Prominent among policy responses, in the UK and elsewhere, have been attempts to manage antisocial behaviour related to intoxication in public spaces [2]. Much less attention has been given to risks to adult health and well being. There have been many cohort studies of the longer term harms associated with adolescent drinking. Some studies suggest that individuals “mature out” of late adolescent drinking patterns [3], whilst others identify enduring effects on drinking and broader health and social functioning in adulthood [4]. In the only available meta-analysis of life-course variability, Johnstone and colleagues [3] evaluated stability in drinking frequency and found settled patterns after the age of 30 following earlier marked discontinuity. There has, however, been no systematic review addressing the consequences of late adolescent drinking in adulthood. If adolescent drinking does not cause later difficulties with which it may be associated, early intervention on and management of the acute consequences of alcohol consumption, such as antisocial behaviour and unintentional injuries [5], may be the most appropriate community safety and public health responses. If causal relationships do exist, however, this approach will not address the cumulative harms produced by alcohol, unless such intervention successfully modifies the long-term relationship with alcohol, which seems unlikely. The obstacles to causal inference are well known, and bias and confounding in particular must be addressed in cohort studies. A systematic review of cohort studies provides the strongest observational study design to evaluate evidence for causal inference [6]. We thus applied this approach to study the consequences of late adolescent drinking. METHODS Adolescent alcohol involvement and the potential for subsequent harm have been conceptualised and studied in many different ways. We sought therefore to evaluate the possible effects of any behavioural measure of adolescent alcohol consumption on any adult outcome. The durability of any observed effects is an important study theme due to the likely implications for public health. Search Strategy and Selection Criteria The data collection process is illustrated in Figure 1 and the PRISMA checklist is included as Text S1. The literature covering 1964 to 2008 inclusive was initially accessed via electronic databases as proposed by Egger and Davey Smith [7]. This start date identified the oldest cohort study included in the study by Johnstone and colleagues [3]. After piloting the following databases were searched: Medline (via both PubMed and MeSH); Web of Knowledge (including ISI Proceedings); Global Health Archive; Cinhal; PsychInfo; Embase; and HMIC. Configured for a PubMed search, the search terms were (1) Adolescen* OR teen* OR young person OR young people OR young adult; (2) Alcohol* OR binge drinking OR drinking culture OR problem drinking OR drinking problem* OR hazardous drinking OR substance [TI]; (3) Adult* [TI] OR cohort OR longitudinal OR prospective OR lifetime [TI]. Initial screening removed studies that were clearly unrelated to this review. [Figure: PRISMA Flowchart.] Citation searching used both backward and forward procedures, with the bibliographies of relevant studies checked and Science Citation Index used for subsequent citations of these papers. Three journals were hand searched: Addiction Abstracts; Addiction; and Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs. The latter two have been published continuously during 1964 to 2008 and were selected following piloting. A data collection protocol was developed and the entire process was undertaken twice, on the second occasion by a research assistant blinded to the outcome of the first. All subsequent study tasks were also duplicated. Only peer-reviewed published data were used and further unpublished information was not sought from authors. Finally, experts, including the authors of included primary studies, were contacted to identify additional studies that had been missed. The following selection criteria were applied independently by two researchers. Studies of drinking behaviour were included if they collected data on at least two points in time, were at least 3 y apart, and from the same cohort. Data collection regarding alcohol consumption was required between the ages of 15 and 19 y old (or between 9th grade at school or first year of university if age not specified). Drinking is normative in this age group and approaches peak levels towards the end of this age range and into the early 20s in most high income countries [8]. Studies were also required to include a report of at least one quantitative measure of effect, such as an odds ratio (OR), between alcohol involvement and any later outcome assessed at age 20 or greater. Cohorts formed from general population sources, including college students and military conscripts, were included. Studies based on selected or special populations such as children of alcoholics, mental health patients, and offenders were excluded. Data Analysis Quality appraisal of included studies was undertaken to evaluate the potential for bias and the adequacy of control for confounding. We gave particular attention to socioeconomic deprivation and other early life sources of vulnerability, as well as indications of other adolescent behavioural problems, in assessing confounding. We designated studies as having stronger capacity for casual inference in relation to the aims of this review if residual confounding in these areas was assessed as unlikely to be important by two reviewers and they had at least one of the following characteristics: (1) follow-up rates of 80% or greater; or (2) sample sizes of 1,000 participants or more. These characteristics identify two forms of bias at the individual study (attrition bias) and at the review level (small studies having disproportionate influence in reviews), respectively. Also if a study had both these characteristics, it was deemed to have stronger capacity for causal inference if both reviewers agreed there was reasonable control of confounding even though residual confounding was nevertheless still likely. We considered that adjustment for some factors while leaving major individual psychosocial confounders uncontrolled, did not constitute reasonable control of confounding. This subset of studies with stronger capacity for causal inference is individually discussed in the narrative presentation of results in order to summarise the evidence base. Two researchers agreed on all bar two studies (Kappa 0.91) [9],[10], for which disagreements about the strength of control for confounding were resolved by discussion. Meta-analysis of pooled outcomes from these observational studies was deemed inappropriate only after consideration of the nature of findings from included studies, because of the potentially misleading nature of such summary effect estimates in the context of uncontrolled bias and confounding [7]. RESULTS The majority of included studies (n = 35) were multiple reports from ten cohorts (see Table 1), with the Swedish Conscript Study (SCS) of male

Read the complete text