Ethics and best practice guidelines for training experiences in global health.
Crump JA, Sugarman J, Working Group on Ethics Guidelines for Global Health Training (WEIGHT). · 2010
Read Ethics and best practice guidelines for training experiences in global health. by Crump JA, Sugarman J, Working Group on Ethics Guidelines for Global Health Training (WEIGHT). (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2990028.txt.
Introduction
Crump and Sugarman, writing for a working group on ethics in global health training, set out guidelines in 2010 for students' field placements abroad. Such programmes were multiplying fast, and the trips could burden host communities even while helping trainees.
Built from published literature and members' experience, the guidelines address universities, trainees, and funders together, covering preparation, supervision, and benefit sharing. Because hard data on harms and gains were thin, the group urges building assessment into programmes from the start. The aim is training that serves hosts as fairly as it educates visitors.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Crump JA, Sugarman J, Working Group on Ethics Guidelines for Global Health Training (WEIGHT). |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ethics and Best Practice Guidelines for Training Experiences in Global Health By John A. Crump, Jeremy Sugarman Published in: The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene DOI: 10.4269/ajtmh.2010.10-0527 ABSTRACT GUIDELINE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS The international, peer-reviewed literature was searched for publications relevant to ethics of global health training and a paper was published raising ethical concerns for global health training programs.1 Reflecting the nascent nature of ethics research and scholarship in the area of global health training, published literature on the topic represented case reports, case series, and expert opinion. Following the formation of WEIGHT, the literature review was updated and an annotated bibliography was sent to members. The WEIGHT met in person in March 2010 in London to draft a preliminary set of ethics and good practice guidelines through group discussion around ethical issues that have arisen for individuals and institutions that send or receive trainees in global health. The guidelines were developed through a moderated workshop format. All members were given the opportunity to raise and discuss dissenting views for each recommendation. Agreement was reached by consensus. The primary goal of the guidelines is to facilitate the structuring of an ethically responsible global health training program and to discourage the implementation and perpetuation of imbalanced and inequitable global health training experiences and programs. SCOPE OF THE GUIDELINES The guidelines are structured to address the multiple stakeholders involved with global health training experiences. The main stakeholders are host institutions, including program directors, mentors, other faculty, and support staff based at the receiving institution; trainees both foreign and local; sending institutions, including program directors, mentors, administrators, and managers; patients and the community at the host site; sending countries, including committees or councils responsible for medical and research ethics, and other health professional education; and sponsors of global health training. The guidelines are designed to apply to multiple levels of trainees, including undergraduates, graduate and medical students, post-graduate students, and others such as faculty or other professionals seeking to apply or expand their skills in the global health arena. Although the guidelines are predominantly focused on ethical issues for programs sending trainees from wealthier to less wealthy settings, many of the principals also apply to bi-directional trainee exchanges. The guidelines encompass the multiple disciplines and multiple activities that take place under the umbrella of global health including in the clinical, public health, research, and education arenas. Although these guidelines were developed in response to the global health activities of educational institutions, the principles are applicable and adaptable to informal programs and individual global health efforts. They also apply to programs of varying duration, while recognizing that duration can affect the nature of issues encountered. Although the guidelines can apply to exchange programs locally and internationally, they are not intended to address ethics issues encountered during long-term (> 1 year) global health service or by experts providing technical assistance. The WEIGHT recognizes that the evidence available to inform the guideline development process was limited and expects that the proposed approach to global health training will be refined in the future as new data are accumulated. GUIDELINES Sending and host institutions. Well-structured programs seem to be the optimal means of ensuring optimal training programs in global health. Developing and maintaining well-structured programs generally involves a sustained series of communications and seems to have a common set of attributes as listed below, and may include clear delineation of roles and responsibilities of all parties, budgets, duration of attachments, participation in and distribution of written reports, and other products. We recommend that sending and host institutions should do the following:1.Develop well-structured programs so that host and sender as well as other stakeholders derive mutual, equitable benefit including:a.Discuss expectations and responsibilities of both host and sending institutions and agree on terms before program implementation; the terms may be outlined within a memorandum of understanding. Revisit the expectations and responsibilities on a periodic basis;b.Consider local needs and priorities regarding the optimal structure of programs;c.Recognize the true cost to all institutions (e.g., costs of orientation, insurance, translation, supervision and mentoring, transportation, lodging, health care, administration) and ensure that they are appropriately reimbursed;d.Aspire to maintain long-term partnerships so that short-term experiences may be nested within them; ande.Promote transparency regarding the motivations for establishing and maintaining programs (e.g., to meet an educational mission, to establish a relationship that might be used to support research, to meet student need) and identifying and addressing any conflicts of interests and conflicts of obligations (e.g., to local patients, communities, or local trainees compared with the global health trainees) that may result from such a program.2.Clarify goals, expectations, and responsibilities through explicit agreements and periodic review bya.Senders and hosts;b.Trainees and mentors; andc.Sponsors and recipients.3.Develop, implement, regularly update, and improve formal training for trainees and mentors, both local and foreign regarding material that includes:a.Norms of professionalism (local and sending);b.Standards of practice (local and sending);c.Cultural competence, e.g., behavior (local and sending) and dealing effectively with cultural differences;d.Dealing appropriately with conflicts (i.e., professionalism, culture, scientific and clinical differences of approach);e.Language capability;f.Personal safety; andg.Implications of differential access to resources for foreign and local trainees.4.Encourage non-threatening communication to resolve ethical conflicts as they arise in real-time and identify a mechanism to involve the host and sending institutions when issues are not readily resolved.5.Clarify the trainees' level of training and experience for the host institution so that appropriate activities are assigned and patient care and community well-being is not compromised.6.Select trainees who are adaptable, motivated to address global health issues, sensitive to local priorities, willing to listen and learn, whose abilities and experience matches the expectations of the position, and who will be good representatives of their home institution and country.7.Promote safety of trainees to the extent possible (e.g., vaccinations, personal behaviors, medications, physical barriers, security awareness, road safety, sexual harassment, psychological support, insurance and knowledge of relevant local laws).8.Monitor costs and benefits to host institutions, local trainees, patients, communities, and sponsoring institutions to assure equity.9.Establish effective supervision and mentorship of trainees by the host and sending institution, including the selection of appropriate mentors and supervisors and facilitating communication among them.10.Establish methods to solicit feedback from the trainees both during and on completion of the program, including exit interviews, and track the participants post-training to evaluate the impact of the experience. Trainees. Trainees themselves play an important role in the quality of global health experiences. It is essential that trainees understand their responsibility in this regard, not only to ensure their personal experience is a good one, but that their actions and behaviors can have far-reaching and important implications. To help meet such responsibilities, we recommend that trainees should do the following:1.Recognize that the primary purpose of the experience is global health learning and appropriately supervised service. The duration of the training experience should be tailored so that the burden to the host is minimized.2.Communicate with their local mentor through official channels regarding goals and expectations for the experience before the training, and maintain communication with mentors throughout the experience.3.Learn appropriate language skills relevant to the host's locale as well as socio-cultural, political, and historical aspects of the host community.4.Seek to acquire knowledge and learn new skills with appropriate training and supervision, but be cognizant and respectful of their current capability