Sexual dimorphism in the fly brain.
Cachero S, Ostrovsky AD, Yu JY, Dickson BJ, Jefferis GS. · 2010
Read Sexual dimorphism in the fly brain. by Cachero S, Ostrovsky AD, Yu JY, Dickson BJ, Jefferis GS. (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2957842.txt.
Introduction
Cachero and colleagues searched the whole fruit fly brain for structural differences between the sexes in a 2010 study. Male courtship depends on a set of about two thousand neurons marked by the fruitless gene, yet wiring differences were poorly mapped.
Comparing registered male and female brain images, they found large volume gaps concentrated in higher brain centres. A saturating clone-labelling effort traced dozens of cell lineages making fruitless neurons and uncovered many new sex differences, including female-only branches in some lines. The map predicts hundreds of spots where connections likely differ, with strong proof in smell pathways.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cachero S, Ostrovsky AD, Yu JY, Dickson BJ, Jefferis GS. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Sexual Dimorphism in the Fly Brain By Sebastian Cachero, Aaron D Ostrovsky, Jai Y Yu, Barry J Dickson, Gregory SXE Jefferis Published in: Current Biology DOI: 10.1016/j.cub.2010.07.045 ABSTRACT Summary Background Sex-specific behavior may originate from differences in brain structure or function. In Drosophila, the action of the male-specific isoform of fruitless in about 2000 neurons appears to be necessary and sufficient for many aspects of male courtship behavior. Initial work found limited evidence for anatomical dimorphism in these fru+ neurons. Subsequently, three discrete anatomical differences in central brain fru+ neurons have been reported, but the global organization of sex differences in wiring is unclear. Results A global search for structural differences in the Drosophila brain identified large volumetric differences between males and females, mostly in higher brain centers. In parallel, saturating clonal analysis of fru+ neurons using mosaic analysis with a repressible cell marker identified 62 neuroblast lineages that generate fru+ neurons in the brain. Coregistering images from male and female brains identified 19 new dimorphisms in males; these are highly concentrated in male-enlarged higher brain centers. Seven dimorphic lineages also had female-specific arbors. In addition, at least 5 of 51 fru+ lineages in the nerve cord are dimorphic. We use these data to predict >700 potential sites of dimorphic neural connectivity. These are particularly enriched in third-order olfactory neurons of the lateral horn, where we provide strong evidence for dimorphic anatomical connections by labeling partner neurons in different colors in the same brain. Conclusion Our analysis reveals substantial differences in wiring and gross anatomy between male and female fly brains. Reciprocal connection differences in the lateral horn offer a plausible explanation for opposing responses to sex pheromones in male and female flies. INTRODUCTION The fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster displays robust, highly stereotyped and dimorphic sexual behaviors [1] that provide an ideal model system to study the genetic and neural basis of innate behavior. The genetic pathways that translate chromosomal sex into dimorphic behavior have been studied extensively [2, 3] (Figure 1O). Early studies using sex mosaics mapped different steps of male courtship to broad regions of the central nervous system [4, 5]. Such results suggest that there are anatomical and functional differences between the sexes in these brain regions. At the level of gross anatomy, few structural dimorphisms have been found, and most are small [6, 7]. However, three olfactory glomeruli show volume differences of 25%–60% [8, 9], and two of these have been linked to sex-specific odor processing. [Figure: Male-Enlarged Regions Are Genotype Specific and Colocalize with fruitless Expression(A) Schematic of Drosophila neuropil compartments and olfactory system. Projection neurons are cyan, mushroom body neurons are green.(B) Surface rendering of male (green)- and female (magenta)-enlarged regions on our template brain.(C) Summary of main male-enlarged regions (MERs). Green: pars intercerebralis; red: arch; mustard: ring; turquoise: lateral junction; light blue: DA1 glomerulus; yellow: tips of mushroom body gamma lobes.(D–K) Two individual slices from average template brains for control male (D and H), control female (E and I), tra mutant female (F and J), and fruM mutant female (G and K). In (D)–(G), arrow indicates male-enlarged arch; in (H)–(K), it shows the male expansion of the ring neuropil.(L) Overlap between MERs (blue) and fruGal4 expression pattern (green).(M and N) Z projections (standard deviation) of the fruGal4 driving CD8-GFP in males (M) and females (N). For clarity, cell bodies in the surface of the brain and the mushroom bodies have been removed. A false color lookup table has been applied to emphasize contrast.(O) Schematic of Drosophila sex determination hierarchy. Bold-type gene products are active, gray are inactive.(P) Quantification of the volume of the MER for control and mutant flies. The central line indicates the median, the box represents the 25% and 75% quartiles, and the whiskers extend to ±1.5 times the interquartile range.Scale bar in all panels represents 50 μm. See also Figure S1.] Differences in gross anatomy can identify regions involved in sex-specific behavior, but ultimately we must understand how circuit level anatomy and function differ between the sexes. fruitless (fru) mutant flies, in which male behavior is selectively disrupted [10, 11], have provided a key entry point to this problem. fru is a complex locus with multiple promoters encoding putative transcription factors [12, 13]. The P1 promoter is active in a small fraction of neurons in both sexes and is critical for the sex-specific function of fru. In males, default splicing of P1 transcripts results in functional proteins, collectively termed FruM; in females, alternative splicing produces nonfunctional FruF proteins [14, 15]. Behavioral and molecular analysis of fru mutants suggests that FruM is required for normal courtship behavior, including inhibition of same-sex courtship [3]. Strikingly, when male splicing is forced, the resultant females court wild-type females [16, 17]. Therefore, the action of FruM on P1-mRNA-expressing neurons (henceforth fru+ neurons) appears to be sufficient to determine many aspects of male behavior, and at least some of these neurons must be sexually dimorphic in number, morphology, or function. One major question in understanding the origin of sex-specific behaviors in general, and the actions of fru in particular, is the extent to which they originate from anatomical or functional differences in specific neural circuits. Early anatomical studies that used antibodies against FruM protein [14] counted 1700 fru+ neurons in 20 groups across the brain and ventral nerve cord (VNC) of males but could reveal little about their anatomy. The full arborization pattern of all fru+ neurons was revealed in fruGAL4 transgenic flies, where a Gal4 insertion targeted to the fru locus was used to express GFP [9, 17]. Surprisingly, these studies found no evidence of anatomical differences, although a subsequent study identified differences in the VNC [18]. However, visualizing subsets of fru+ neurons identified one clear projection dimorphism [19] and two male-specific lineages [20]. It has been proposed that fru+ neurons form an interconnected circuit [9, 17, 20]. The only clear example of this is in the olfactory system, where both olfactory receptor neurons that detect the male pheromone cVA (a repellent for males and an aphrodisiac for females [21]) and their synaptic partners, the projection neurons (PNs), are fru+ [9, 22]. However, PN responses to cVA are indistinguishable in males and females, strongly suggesting that sex-specific behavior depends on circuit differences beyond the antennal lobe [22]. Intriguingly, these PNs have a subtle difference in axon terminals in the lateral horn (one higher olfactory center, Figure 1A). However, whether this difference is an anatomical substrate for dimorphic olfactory behavior is unclear, because the identity and structure of the relevant downstream neurons is unknown. By carrying out a global characterization of fru+ neurons, we now address three key questions. How many fru+ neurons are anatomically dimorphic? Where are these dimorphisms located? And how can these dimorphisms alter connectivity and information flow? RESULTS Large Structural Dimorphisms in Fly Brains Regional differences in brain anatomy between the sexes can identify the location of circuit level dimorphisms. Previous work examining the whole Drosophila brain measured the volumes of predefined regions of interest and found only weak differences [6]. We used deformation-based morphometry [23, 24], which requires no prior hypotheses about the location of volume differences. The method starts with nonrigid registration of many brains onto a template, followed by