Evidence of Selection upon Genomic GC-Content in Bacteria

Falk Hildebrand, Axel Meyer, Adam Eyre-Walker, Michael W Nachman

Read Evidence of Selection upon Genomic GC-Content in Bacteria by Falk Hildebrand, Axel Meyer, Adam Eyre-Walker, Michael W Nachman in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2936529.txt.

Introduction

Hildebrand, Meyer, Eyre-Walker, and Nachman tested whether natural selection shapes the base makeup of bacterial genomes, in a study published in PLoS Genetics. Bacterial genomes differ hugely in how much of their DNA uses the bases G and C, a spread usually blamed on mutation habits.

Looking at silent DNA variants across well over a hundred species, they found changes eroding G and C far outnumbered changes building them up. Mutation bias alone would then imply most GC-rich species are steadily losing GC, which cannot hold. They conclude selection favours higher GC content in many bacteria.

Catalog record

CREATORFalk Hildebrand, Axel Meyer, Adam Eyre-Walker, Michael W Nachman
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2936529

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evidence of Selection upon Genomic GC-Content in Bacteria By Falk Hildebrand, Axel Meyer, Adam Eyre-Walker, Michael W Nachman Published in: PLoS Genetics DOI: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1001107 ABSTRACT Abstract The genomic GC-content of bacteria varies dramatically, from less than 20% to more than 70%. This variation is generally ascribed to differences in the pattern of mutation between bacteria. Here we test this hypothesis by examining patterns of synonymous polymorphism using datasets from 149 bacterial species. We find a large excess of synonymous GC→AT mutations over AT→GC mutations segregating in all but the most AT-rich bacteria, across a broad range of phylogenetically diverse species. We show that the excess of GC→AT mutations is inconsistent with mutation bias, since it would imply that most GC-rich bacteria are declining in GC-content; such a pattern would be unsustainable. We also show that the patterns are probably not due to translational selection or biased gene conversion, because optimal codons tend to be AT-rich, and the excess of GC→AT SNPs is observed in datasets with no evidence of recombination. We therefore conclude that there is selection to increase synonymous GC-content in many species. Since synonymous GC-content is highly correlated to genomic GC-content, we further conclude that there is selection on genomic base composition in many bacteria. INTRODUCTION Bacteria show an astonishing diversity of genomic GC-contents, from species such as the endosymbiont Carsonella ruddii, which has a GC-content of 16.5% [1], to Anaeromyxobacter dehalogens, which has a GC-content of 75%. This is particularly surprising given that bacteria generally have little intergenic DNA, so the extreme variation in base composition must affect both coding and non-coding sites; this is evident in the correlation between the GC-content of the first two codon positions of protein coding genes, and genomic GC-content [2]–[4] (Figure S1). The variation in base composition is not restricted to particular groups of bacteria. Although, genomic GC content shows a fair level of phylogenetic inertia [5], most classes of bacteria show substantial variation in genomic GC content; one of the most dramatic examples is afforded by the α-proteobacteria, which have genomic GC-contents ranging from less than 30% to greater than 60% [6]. The reasons for the variation in genomic GC-content are controversial. In the first example of a “neutral” theory being used to explain a phenomenon at the molecular level, Sueoka [7] and Freese [8] independently suggested that the extreme variation in genomic base composition between bacteria was a consequence of differences in the mutation pattern. Fifty years on and there is little evidence to contradict this view. It has been shown that genomic GC-content is correlated with a number of factors including genome size [6], whether the bacterium is free-living or not [9], [10], the environment [11], aerobiosis [12], nitrogen utilization [13] and possibly temperature [14] (but see [15]–[17]). However, it is still unknown whether these correlations are due to the influence of these factors on the process of mutation, or whether natural selection is involved. For a few bacteria there is evidence that the genomic GC-content is not a simple consequence of mutation bias. The mutation pattern has been directly measured in Escherichia coli and found to be AT-biased [18], [19]. If the genomic GC-content was simply determined by mutation bias it would be expected to decline from its current value of 0.5 to 0.32 [20]. The fact that the genomic GC-content is higher than this value can be explained by functional constraints. However, even sites that appear to be under little selection, such as synonymous sites in lowly expressed genes, have a GC-content of ∼57% [21], which is considerably above the equilibrium inferred from the mutation studies. Of course, it is likely that the mutation pattern measured in the laboratory is not identical to that experienced by the bacterium in the wild. However, a phylogenetic analysis of substitutions between closely related E.coli strains also shows the same tendency for an excess of GC→AT mutations [22]. Furthermore this bias towards GC→AT mutations is less acute amongst common polymorphisms, consistent with natural selection acting against GC→AT mutations [22]. A similar excess of GC→AT substitutions is seen in the pseudogenes between strains of Mycobacterium leprae [23], again suggesting that the mutation pattern is AT biased relative to the current genomic GC-content, and that it will, given the opportunity, decrease the GC-content [20]. However, M. leprae is an intra-cellular parasite and this has led to the loss of many genes; it is possible that one of these is a DNA repair enzyme that has shifted the mutation bias towards being AT-rich. Here we test whether genomic GC-content is a simple consequence of mutation bias by investigating the pattern of synonymous genetic variation in 149 bacterial species. RESULTS To investigate whether genomic GC-content is solely a consequence of mutation bias, we analysed the pattern of synonymous polymorphism at the third position of 4-fold degenerate codons. Since, the GC-content of 4-fold sites (GC4) is strongly correlated to genomic GC-content [2]–[4] (Figure S1) we expect many of the forces that act upon synonymous sites to also act upon the genome as a whole. If GC4 is simply a consequence of mutation bias and the base composition is at equilibrium, then we expect equal numbers of GC→AT and AT→GC synonymous mutations at 4-fold sites to be segregating within a species [24], [25]. To test this prediction we assembled polymorphism datasets from 149 bacterial species from 8 phyla, 15 classes and 77 genera, in which we had at least 8 sequences from species members, 10 or more synonymous polymorphisms at 4-fold degenerate sites and the nucleotide diversity at four-fold sites for GC↔AT mutations was less than 0.1 (see Table S1 for a full list of species). The concept of a species is potentially problematic in bacteria because they do not undergo conventional sexual reproduction. However, “population genetic” species do exist, in the sense that strains exist that undergo random genetic drift and selection together [26]. Unfortunately, it is not possible to determine which strains meet this criterion. A named bacterial species may include two groups of strains that are effectively two different population genetic species. As a consequence some single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) may be substitutions between species. However, this should not affect our results in a consistent direction. Ideally we would infer the pattern of mutation from our SNPs within a likelihood framework, integrating across all possible phylogenetic trees and ancestral states. However, this approach was not possible because a closely related outgroup was not available for most datasets. We therefore used two alternative methods to infer the direction of mutation. In the first we used the allele frequencies, inferring the minor allele to be the new mutation; we also reconstructed the phylogenetic tree between strains for each gene and used parsimony to infer the ancestral state and hence the direction of mutation. These two approaches gave qualitatively similar results, but we present the results from the frequency method because the potential biases are easier to estimate; simulations suggest that parsimony typically outperforms the frequency method, but the biases are less easy to predict. We restrict the analysis to datasets in which synonymous diversity was less 0.1 for two reasons; first to concentrate the analysis on strains that are likely to form a species, in

Read the complete text