Recent developments in classical density modification.
Cowtan K. · 2010
Read Recent developments in classical density modification. by Cowtan K. (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2852311.txt.
Introduction
Cowtan tested several new tricks in 2010 for sharpening the fuzzy first maps produced in X-ray crystallography, and packaged them in a program called Parrot. Solving a structure starts with rough phase estimates, the missing half of the diffraction data. This editing process then improves them by repeatedly forcing the electron-density map to look like a plausible molecule. Classical methods alternate between editing the map and re-imposing the measurements.
Cowtan tests refinements to the standard edits: flattening solvent regions, matching the expected spread of density values, and averaging over duplicate molecules in the crystal. He judged which additions truly helped phases within the classical framework. Parrot carries the winning combination forward as a working tool for structure-solving pipelines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cowtan K. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Recent developments in classical density modification By Kevin Cowtan Published in: Acta Crystallographica Section D: Biological Crystallography DOI: 10.1107/S090744490903947X ABSTRACT Several new methods are evaluated for use in the improvement of experimental phases in the framework of a classical density-modification calculation. These methods have been implemented in a new computer program, Parrot. Keywords: density modification, phase improvement, Parrot BACKGROUND Phase improvement by density modification has become a routine part of the process of structure solution using experimental phases and is often also used after molecular replacement. There are two families of approaches to density modification: ‘classical’ methods, which iterate modifications to the electron-density map in real space with the reintroduction of the experimental observations in reciprocal space, and ‘statistical’ methods, which construct a probability distribution for the electron-density values as a function of position in real space and transform this distribution to obtain a probability distribution for the phases in reciprocal space. Classical density modification 1.1. Classical density-modification methods have provided a convenient tool for the rapid calculation of ‘improved’ electron-density maps for more than 15 years and have been employed in a number of forms, with the common feature of alternating steps being performed in real and reciprocal space. The calculation commonly follows the following pattern. Starting with a set of experimentally observed structure-factor magnitudes and estimated phase probability distributions, a ‘best’ electron-density map is calculated using the centroid of the phase probability distribution to provide a phase and weight for the structure-factor magnitude. This initial electron-density map is then modified to make it conform more closely to the features expected of a well phased electron-density map. The most common modifications are as follows. - (i) Solvent flattening (Wang, 1985 ▶). Features in the solvent region are flattened under the assumption that noise arising from errors in the phases provides a significant contribution to such features. - (ii) Histogram matching (Zhang et al., 1997 ▶). The histogram of electron-density values for a well phased map differs from the histogram for a randomly phased map. The application of a nonlinear rescaling to the electron density allows the electron-density map to be modified so that its histogram looks more like that of a well phased map. This process tends to sharpen electron-density peaks and suppress negative density. - (iii) Noncrystallographic symmetry (NCS) averaging. In cases where there are several copies of a molecule in the asymmetric unit, the related electron-density values between the molecules may be averaged to improve the signal-to-noise ratio and impose restraints on the phase values. The modified map is then back-transformed, leading to a new set of Fourier coefficients which differ in both magnitude and phase from those used to calculate the initial map. An error estimate is calculated for each phase, usually on the basis of how well the modified magnitudes match the observed values in a particular resolution shell. This error estimate is used to construct a phase probability distribution centred about the modified phase. This phase probability is multiplied by the phase probability distribution from the experimental phasing to provide an updated distribution. The new distribution can be used to calculate an electron-density map for model building or can be used to start a new cycle of density modification. This basic scheme has been implemented with some refinements in the DM (Cowtan et al., 2001 ▶) and SOLOMON (Abrahams & Leslie, 1996 ▶) software, with some variations, as well as in many other packages. The DM software initially implemented solvent flattening, histogram matching and NCS averaging, along with likelihood error estimation using the σA method (Read, 1986 ▶). The SOLOMON software pioneered the use of weighted NCS averaging and also the use of solvent flipping to reduce bias, which was later implemented in DM in the form of the ‘perturbation’ gamma correction (Abrahams, 1997 ▶; Cowtan, 1999 ▶). One distinct technique which is not described here is the use of density modification for resolution extrapolation beyond the limit of the observed data. Pioneered by Caliandro et al. (2005 ▶) and more widely used in the software of Sheldrick (Usón et al., 2007 ▶), this approach can provide significant additional phase improvement, especially when the data already extend to better than 2 Å resolution. Statistical density modification 1.2. Statistical density-modification methods provide a more sound theoretical basis to the problem of phase improvement and as a result reduce the problems of bias associated with classical density-modification methods. This improvement is achieved in two ways. - (i) By the expression of the additional information to be introduced to the electron-density map in terms of probability distributions and then carrying those distributions into reciprocal space, rather than working with a single map representing a single sample from the phase probability distributions. - (ii) By weakening the link between the additional information to be introduced and the initial phases, thus reducing the bias introduced in a single cycle of phase improvement. Since the current centroid map is not used as the basis for phase improvement, the phase probability distributions from which the centroid map is derived are not directly included in the new phase information incorporated during a single density-modification cycle. The only way in which the current phases are used is in the classification of the asymmetric unit into regions of different density types, e.g. solvent and protein. The result of these two changes is that statistical density-modification techniques lead to reduced phase bias and more realistic estimates of the figures of merit. The resulting method has been implemented in the RESOLVE software (Terwilliger, 1999 ▶). In addition to its application to conventional density-modification problems, it has been particularly effective in removing bias from maps phased from an atomic model through the ‘prime-and-switch’ approach (Terwilliger, 2004 ▶). An alternative implementation in a program called Pirate (Cowtan, 2000 ▶) has been employed successfully in a number of cases, but delivers poor results in other cases for reasons which have yet to be determined. Limitations of current methods 1.3. Statistical phase-improvement methods, and in particular the RESOLVE software, have made a substantial contribution to the field of phase improvement, significantly reducing the problem of bias and additionally providing tools for removing bias from existing phasing. Current implementations are also highly automated, making them particularly suitable for use in structure-solution pipelines. The only significant limitation of these approaches is the computational overhead, with calculations taking minutes rather than seconds. During the rise of statistical methods, classical density-modification techniques have been neglected to some extent, most notably in the implementation of automation features. However, another effect of this neglect has been a failure to implement a number of algorithms which are now routine in other steps of the structure-solution pipeline. The aim of this work is to produce an up-to-date classical density-modification method that is updated to incorporate both automation features and the latest applicable algorithms. Where it has been convenient to do so, direct comparisons have been made to demonstrate the effect of updating each step of the process. The resulting algorithm retains the speed benefits of classical density-modification techniques; it is hoped that this will render it suitable for interactive use from within graphical model-building programs, for example in Coot (Emsley & Cowtan, 2004 ▶). METHODS The density-modification algorithm