Fluctuating selection: the perpetual renewal of adaptation in variable environments.

Bell G. · 2010

Read Fluctuating selection: the perpetual renewal of adaptation in variable environments. by Bell G. (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2842698.txt.

Introduction

Bell argued in 2010 that Darwin's picture of evolution inching along under weak, steady selection needs a major supplement: strong selection whose direction keeps flipping. Field studies now routinely measure fierce selection in wild populations, and gene studies pin adaptation to a few genes of large effect. Yet traits stay highly heritable, and fossil lineages show amounts of change unrelated to elapsed time, which clashes with the fast-selection picture.

Changing environments resolve the clash, Bell contends. Conditions vary on every timescale, so the fitness target keeps moving and variation never drains away. Long-term studies confirm selection reversing direction again and again. Adaptation, he concludes, often rests on a handful of genes exposed to commonplace, strong, fluctuating selection.

Catalog record

CREATORBell G.
YEAR2010
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2842698

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Fluctuating selection: the perpetual renewal of adaptation in variable environments By Graham Bell Published in: Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences DOI: 10.1098/rstb.2009.0150 ABSTRACT Abstract Darwin insisted that evolutionary change occurs very slowly over long periods of time, and this gradualist view was accepted by his supporters and incorporated into the infinitesimal model of quantitative genetics developed by R. A. Fisher and others. It dominated the first century of evolutionary biology, but has been challenged in more recent years both by field surveys demonstrating strong selection in natural populations and by quantitative trait loci and genomic studies, indicating that adaptation is often attributable to mutations in a few genes. The prevalence of strong selection seems inconsistent, however, with the high heritability often observed in natural populations, and with the claim that the amount of morphological change in contemporary and fossil lineages is independent of elapsed time. I argue that these discrepancies are resolved by realistic accounts of environmental and evolutionary changes. First, the physical and biotic environment varies on all time-scales, leading to an indefinite increase in environmental variance over time. Secondly, the intensity and direction of natural selection are also likely to fluctuate over time, leading to an indefinite increase in phenotypic variance in any given evolving lineage. Finally, detailed long-term studies of selection in natural populations demonstrate that selection often changes in direction. I conclude that the traditional gradualist scheme of weak selection acting on polygenic variation should be supplemented by the view that adaptation is often based on oligogenic variation exposed to commonplace, strong, fluctuating natural selection. Keywords: natural selection, fluctuating selection, selection coefficient, environmental variation, infinitesimal model, oligogenic model THE TRADITION OF GRADUALISM The central problem of evolutionary biology is to explain how adaptation to particular environmental conditions evolves through natural selection. For almost the whole history of the field, the prevailing view has been that selection is weak and can be effective only when it acts over very long periods of time. "That natural selection always acts with extreme slowness I fully admit.(Darwin 1859, p. 121)" "Thus we come to the conclusion that Darwin was right in regarding transformation as taking place by minute steps, which, if useful, are augmented in the course of innumerable generations …(Weismann 1909, p. 24)" "It must never be forgotten that a very slight advantage will in the course of generations come to predominate.(Haldane & Huxley 1927, p. 222)" "… the extreme slowness of the change revealed whenever we trace evolution in action.(Wells et al. 1934, p. 207)" "For ordinary natural selection involving a simple dominant with a selective advantage of 1 in 1000 … it will take nearly 5000 generations to increase the proportion of the dominant from 1 to 50% …(Huxley 1942, p. 57)" "Such calculations are extremely rough, but they suggest the remarkably small magnitude of the selective ‘forces’ which are at work if natural selection is largely responsible for evolution, and the extreme difficulty of detecting them in action.(Haldane 1949, p. 56)" "These estimates of the cost of evolution lead to the conclusion that evolutionary change is normally an exceedingly slow process.(Mayr 1966, p. 259)" There were few dissentient voices. A remarkable early example was A. R. Wallace, the acolyte of Darwin: "Mr Darwin was rather inclined to exaggerate the necessary slowness of the action of natural selection; but with the knowledge we now possess of the great amount and range of individual variation, there seems no difficulty in an amount of change, quite equivalent to that which usually distinguishes allied species, sometimes taking place in less than a century, should any rapid change in conditions necessitate an equally rapid adaptation.(Wallace 1889, p. 125)" His was a lone voice. The insistence of Darwin, and his successors, on the prevalence of weak selection operating over long periods of time dominated evolutionary biology for over a century, and inflicted two serious wounds on the development of the field. The first was that attempts to observe natural selection in action would be futile because of the extreme slowness of change. The second was that experiments were out of the question, as no appreciable change could occur within the lifetime of the experimenter. There were brilliant early efforts in both fieldwork (Weldon 1901) and experimentation (Dallinger 1887), but they led nowhere. Field studies were taken over by ecology and laboratory experiments by transmission genetics. Evolution itself became a system of interpretation, almost philosophical in character, operating at the margins of the new disciplines, and promising more than it could perform. A book published to mark the centenary of the publication of the theory of natural selection (Barnett 1958) included chapters on animal breeding, classification, the fossil record, embryology and so forth, but includes no treatment of natural selection in the field or in the laboratory. This extreme gradualism was codified by Fisher (1930) and others as the infinitesimal model of population genetics. Quantitative characters are taken to be governed by an effectively infinite number of loci bearing alleles of infinitesimal effect. Consequently, character state can be modified by selection with no appreciable change in gene frequencies. This is a convenient calculating device that enables a mathematical theory of quantitative genetics to be built on normal distribution theory (Bulmer 1985, ch. 9). It is not a realistic description of real populations, of course, but it is usually taken to be approximately correct, insofar as the state of a quantitative character is usually governed by a large number of loci each of small effect. Hence, most evolutionary change within a lineage will involve the successive substitution of alleles of small effect. The common-sense justification for this is that any substantial alteration of character state in a well-adapted population is almost certain to be deleterious, whereas very small alterations will often be beneficial (Fisher 1930, ch. 2). The gradual modification of characters in fossil time-series is attributed to stabilizing selection (acting against extreme phenotypes) around an optimal value that changes slowly over time so as to generate very weak but consistent directional selection. In this way, the mathematical theory of population genetics that was developed during the twentieth century formalized and reinforced the gradualist foundation laid down in the nineteenth century. THE OLIGOGENIC MODEL The renaissance of evolutionary biology as an empirical and experimental science began in the 1950s, from a variety of sources. They included the Oxford school of ecological genetics, and especially the careful fieldwork of Cain and his colleagues (Cain & Shepherd 1954), the analysis of chromosome polymorphism in Drosophila by Dobzhansky and colleagues (Dobzhansky 1948) and the artificial selection experiments on Drosophila at Leeds and Edinburgh (Clayton & Robertson 1957). By the mid-1980s, the number of field studies had become large enough for Endler (1986) to review the field and conclude that directional selection in natural populations was commonplace and often strong. At about the same time, the emphasis of field research programmes was shifting from measuring the frequencies of discrete morphs to estimating the relationship between the state of continuous characters and fitness components. When this field became mature enough to be reviewed, the results reinforced the conclusions based on polymorphism (Hendry & Kinnison 1999; Kingsolver et al. 2001). Moreover, laboratory selection experiments had demonstrated

Read the complete text