Absolute humidity and the seasonal onset of influenza in the continental United States.
Shaman J, Pitzer VE, Viboud C, Grenfell BT, Lipsitch M. · 2010
Read Absolute humidity and the seasonal onset of influenza in the continental United States. by Shaman J, Pitzer VE, Viboud C, Grenfell BT, Lipsitch M. (2010) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2826374.txt.
Introduction
Shaman, Pitzer, Viboud, Grenfell, and Lipsitch showed in 2010 that dry air explains when winter flu epidemics start across the continental United States. Lab work had already shown flu virus survives longer and spreads better between guinea pigs as air dries. The team tested whether real epidemic timing follows the same rule.
They matched thirty years of epidemic onset dates against humidity records for the same places. Drops in absolute humidity, the actual water content of air, lined up with outbreak starts across states. A transmission model driven only by humidity reproduced the timing and geography of real epidemics. The result names a physical driver behind flu's winter season in temperate lands.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shaman J, Pitzer VE, Viboud C, Grenfell BT, Lipsitch M. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2010 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| LICENSE | CC0 1.0 Universal |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Absolute Humidity and the Seasonal Onset of Influenza in the Continental United States By Jeffrey Shaman, Virginia E Pitzer, Cécile Viboud, Bryan T Grenfell, Marc Lipsitch, Neil M Ferguson Published in: PLoS Biology DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1000316 ABSTRACT Here, the authors demonstrate that variations of absolute humidity explain both the onset of wintertime influenza transmission and the overarching seasonality of this pathogen in temperate regions. INTRODUCTION In temperate regions, wintertime influenza epidemics are responsible for considerable morbidity and mortality [1]. These seasonal epidemics are maintained by the gradual antigenic drift of surface antigens, which enables the influenza virus to evade host immune response [2]. Recent influenza epidemics have resulted from the cocirculation of three virus (sub)types, A/H1N1, A/H3N2, and B, with one generally predominant locally in a given winter [3]–[5]. In contrast, influenza pandemic activity can occur any time of year, including during spring or summer months, in the rare instances when a novel virus to which humans have little or no immunity jumps from avian or mammalian hosts into the human population, as in the on-going H1N1v pandemic [6]–[9]. Despite numerous reports describing wintertime transmission of epidemic influenza in temperate regions [10], our understanding of the mechanisms underlying influenza seasonal variation remains very limited. Experimental studies suggest that influenza virus survival within aerosolized droplets is strongly associated with the absolute humidity (AH) of the ambient air, such that virus survival improves markedly as AH levels decrease [11]. A similar relationship is observed between AH and airborne influenza virus transmission among laboratory guinea pigs, in that transmission increases markedly as AH levels decrease (Figure 1). Within temperate regions of the world, AH conditions are minimal in winter and maximal in summer (Figure 1D). This seasonal cycle favors a wintertime increase of both influenza virus survival and transmission, and may explain the observed seasonal peak of influenza morbidity and mortality during winter. Annual wintertime mortality peaks are evident in the long-term mortality records of excess pneumonia and influenza (P&I) in the US, a robust indicator of the timing and impact of epidemics at national and local scales [4] (Figure S1). [Figure: Analyses of laboratory data, environmental data, and SIRS model simulations.(A) Log-linear regression of guinea pig airborne influenza virus transmission data [14],[15] on specific humidity (a measure of AH); (B) log-linear regression of 1-h influenza virus survival data [28] on specific humidity; (C) functional relationship between R 0(t) and q(t) per Equation 4; (D) 1972–2002 daily climatology of 2-m above-ground NCEP-NCAR reanalysis specific humidity [23] for Arizona, Florida, Illinois, New York state, and Washington state; (E) 1972–2002 average daily values of R 0(t) derived from the specific humidity climatology using the best-fit parameter combination from SIRS simulations (R 0max = 3.52; R 0min = 1.12) and the functional form (Figure 1C and Equation 4); (F) average R E(t) for all wintertime outbreaks in the ten best-fit simulations at each state shown for 100 d prior to through 150 d post outbreak onset (minimum 400 infections/day during 2 wk prior; minimum 5,000 infections/day at least 1 d during subsequent 30 d). Figure 1A and 1B are redrawn from Shaman and Kohn [11] using specific humidity as the measure of AH.] Here, we develop epidemiological support for these previous laboratory-based findings implicating AH as a driver of seasonal influenza transmission. First, we analyze the spatial and temporal variation of epidemic influenza onset across the continental US, 1972–2002, and correlate this observed variability with records of AH for the same period and locations. Second, we show that a mathematical model of influenza transmission in the US can reproduce the spatial and temporal variation of epidemic influenza when daily AH conditions within each state are used to modulate the basic reproductive number, R 0(t), of the influenza virus. RESULTS AH and the Onset of Wintertime Influenza Outbreaks Our first test of the hypothesis that low AH drives wintertime increases of influenza transmission is to assess whether the onset of the influenza epidemic each winter—which shows substantial annual variation (Figure S1)—corresponds to a period of unusually low AH. We define the onset of wintertime influenza as the date at which, for the 2 wk prior, the observed excess P&I mortality rate had been at or above a prescribed threshold level (e.g., 0.01 deaths/100,000 people/day). This onset date was identified separately for each of the 30 winters in the 1972–2002 observational record at each of the 48 contiguous states plus the District of Columbia (DC). We then examined the anomalous AH (AH′) conditions prior to and following these onset dates. AH′ is the local daily deviation of AH from its 31-y mean for each day (as shown for five states in Figure 1D), defined as: [formula: (1)] where denotes the 1972–2002 daily average value. At temperate latitudes, such as in the US, wintertime AH levels are already much lower than summer (Figure 1D). By using AH′, we can determine whether the onset of wintertime influenza occurs when AH is above or below typical local daily AH levels. Negative AH′ values are typically observed beginning 4 wk prior to the onset of influenza epidemics (Figure 2), with the largest excursion occurring 17 d prior to onset. This result is robust to the choice of the mortality threshold level used to define onset date (from 0.001 to 0.02 excess P&I deaths/100,000 people/day). To assess the statistical significance of the association between negative wintertime AH′ and epidemic onset, we bootstrapped the distribution of observed wintertime AH′ records and found strong statistical support (p<0.0005, see Text S1). Depending on the threshold used to define onset, 55%–60% of onset dates demonstrate negative AH′ averaged over the 4 wk prior to onset. Although highly statistically significant, this shift from the expected 50% likelihood is small. These findings indicate that negative AH′ are not necessary for wintertime influenza onset but instead presage an increased likelihood of these onset events. In effect, negative AH′ in the weeks prior to onset provide an additional increase of influenza virus survival and transmission over typical local wintertime levels and may further facilitate the spread of the virus. [Figure: AH′ associated with the observed onset of epidemic influenza.Top, plots of AH′ averaged for the site-winters with an influenza outbreak showing the 6 wk prior to and 4 wk following outbreak onset. The conditions at each of the site-winters are defined based on the onset date for that site-winter. The onset dates are defined as the date at which wintertime observed excess P&I mortality had been at or above a prescribed threshold level for two continuous weeks (e.g., 0.01 deaths/100,000 people/day). Not every site-winter produced an outbreak as defined by a particular onset threshold. Depending on the threshold level used, 1,181–1,420 epidemics were identified among 1,470 possible (30 winters each for the 48 contiguous states plus the District of Columbia). Each solid line is the averaged AH′ associated with influenza onset as defined by a different threshold mortality rate. The dashed line shows AH′ = 0. Bottom, plot of R 0(t) anomalies using the above AH′ values. The R 0(t) anomalies are calculated using the best combined-fit estimates of R 0max and R 0min (Table 1). The dashed line shows R 0(t)′ = 0.] Regional differences in the association of negative AH′