Accuracy and usefulness of BMI measures based on self-reported weight and height: findings from the NHANES & NHIS 2001-2006.

Stommel M, Schoenborn CA. · 2009

Read Accuracy and usefulness of BMI measures based on self-reported weight and height: findings from the NHANES & NHIS 2001-2006. by Stommel M, Schoenborn CA. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2784464.txt.

Introduction

Stommel and Schoenborn examined in 2009 how accurate body mass index values are when they rest on self-reported height and weight. They used the national NHANES and NHIS surveys from 2001 to 2006. Interviews gather such figures cheaply, but people misreport them, so the error pattern needed mapping. They compared self-reported values against physical measurements and hunted for traits that predict the gaps.

Self-reported BMI ran too high at the low end of the scale, below about twenty-two. It ran too low at the high end, especially above twenty-eight. Errors also varied with age, sex, and ethnic background. Adjusting for those traits narrowed the mistakes but still misclassified some obese people as merely overweight. Health risk estimates, however, came out virtually the same from self-reported and measured values. Corrected self-reports, they conclude, can serve risk estimation well.

Catalog record

CREATORStommel M, Schoenborn CA.
YEAR2009
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2784464

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Accuracy and usefulness of BMI measures based on self-reported weight and height: findings from the NHANES & NHIS 2001-2006 By Manfred Stommel, Charlotte A Schoenborn Published in: BMC Public Health DOI: 10.1186/1471-2458-9-421 ABSTRACT Background The Body Mass Index (BMI) based on self-reported height and weight ("self-reported BMI") in epidemiologic studies is subject to measurement error. However, because of the ease and efficiency in gathering height and weight information through interviews, it remains important to assess the extent of error present in self-reported BMI measures and to explore possible adjustment factors as well as valid uses of such self-reported measures. Methods Using the combined 2001-2006 data from the continuous National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, discrepancies between BMI measures based on self-reported and physical height and weight measures are estimated and socio-demographic predictors of such discrepancies are identified. Employing adjustments derived from the socio-demographic predictors, the self-reported measures of height and weight in the 2001-2006 National Health Interview Survey are used for population estimates of overweight & obesity as well as the prediction of health risks associated with large BMI values. The analysis relies on two-way frequency tables as well as linear and logistic regression models. All point and variance estimates take into account the complex survey design of the studies involved. Results Self-reported BMI values tend to overestimate measured BMI values at the low end of the BMI scale (< 22) and underestimate BMI values at the high end, particularly at values > 28. The discrepancies also vary systematically with age (younger and older respondents underestimate their BMI more than respondents aged 42-55), gender and the ethnic/racial background of the respondents. BMI scores, adjusted for socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents, tend to narrow, but do not eliminate misclassification of obese people as merely overweight, but health risk estimates associated with variations in BMI values are virtually the same, whether based on self-report or measured BMI values. Conclusion BMI values based on self-reported height and weight, if corrected for biases associated with socio-demographic characteristics of the survey respondents, can be used to estimate health risks associated with variations in BMI, particularly when using parametric prediction models. BACKGROUND The use of the Body Mass Index (BMI) based on self-reported height and weight in epidemiologic studies remains controversial, both because it is an imperfect measure of a person's percentage of body fat [1] and because self-reported height and weight are subject to substantial measurement error [2]. However, BMI measures calculated from data obtained through interviews continue to be used as a common tool because of the relative ease and efficiency in gathering such information. Thus, it remains important to assess the extent of error present in BMI measures that are based on self-reported height and weight (self-reported BMI) compared with BMI measures based on physical measurement of height and weight (measured BMI) and to understand the limitations of using the self-reported measures. A review of the literature reveals both random and systematic errors ("bias") in the use of self-reported measures, but there remains some controversy over the magnitude of such errors. In particular, researchers have shown that over-reporting of height is more common among older survey respondents [3,4]. In addition, it has often been reported that men are more likely than women to overestimate their height, while women, particularly young women, are more likely to underestimate their weight [3,5]. Some researchers have also found systematic variations in the BMI based on the racial or ethnic background of interview respondents. For instance, Mexican Americans and, in particular, Mexican American women tend to underestimate their weight, resulting in underestimates of the prevalence of obesity in this group [6]. In a study of Mexican citizens, others also found that BMI values calculated from self-reported height and weight underestimated BMI values based on measured height and weight --- a tendency that increased with age [7]. However in one study [8], it was reported that Mexican American adults tend to underestimate their weight less than non-Hispanic white adults. A similar pattern also seems to hold for non-Hispanic African American adults, for whom BMI values computed from self-reported height and weight seem to produce smaller underestimates of their measured BMIs than among non-Hispanic whites [6,8]. Conversely, compared to non-Hispanic African American and Hispanic women, non-Hispanic white women are more prone to underestimate their weight [4], which may reflect different sensitivities about being overweight [9]. Marital status and income also appear to influence a survey participants' responses to height and weight questions, with single/never married as well as divorced persons more likely to underreport weight, and high income respondents reporting their weight and height more accurately [8,10]. Finally, there is strong evidence that the actual BMI itself is a predictor of the error in BMI measures based on self-reported height and weight, with underestimates of BMI becoming larger for respondents with higher-end weight and BMI values [11-13]. While developing correction factors that could be applied to self-reported data to eliminate, or at least lessen, the biases in BMIs associated with self-reported height and weight is an attractive idea [14], the few attempts that have been made [15,16] are discouraging. Use of additional variables beyond self-reported height and weight provides only small improvements in the prediction of measured BMI scores and does not appear to eliminate biases associated with the size of the measured BMI [16]. Beyond the question of possible errors and biases in BMI measures based on self-reported height and weight, there is also the question of the purpose for which self-reported BMI measures are employed. For instance, biases in self-report may have a great impact on our ability to classify people as "overweight" or "obese", but may have a smaller impact on the use of a continuous BMI measure to estimate risks associated with body mass. In much of the literature, researchers employ the BMI categories based on the 1998 National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) Guidelines, which use the following groupings: BMI < 18.5 ("underweight"), 18.5 < 25 ("normal weight"), 25 < 30 ("overweight"), 30 < 35 ("low obesity"), 35 < 40 ("medium obesity"), and ≥ 40 ("extreme obesity"). Even though a comparison of BMI categories based on measured and self-reported height and weight may reveal substantial misclassifications, it is unclear whether such misclassification is based on small or large deviations between self-reported and measured BMI values. If the errors tend to be small, the use of continuous BMI measures based on self-reported height and weight may result in fairly accurate estimates of the morbidity and mortality risks associated with the BMI, even though relatively large misclassifications occur at the margins with the use of broadly defined BMI categories. This study is designed to provide estimates of the extent to which survey respondents are misclassified with respect to their body mass categories if BMI estimates computed from self-reported weight and height are used. We will also provide estimates of the overall measurement errors involved in using self-report measures and examine the predictors reviewed, while adding an indicator for current pregnancy, on the assumption that temporary weight gain may lead to under-reporting of weight. Since it has been well established that the risk of diabetes rises with higher BMI values [17-19], we will analyze to what extent

Read the complete text