Genotyping of genetically monomorphic bacteria: DNA sequencing in Mycobacterium tuberculosis highlights the limitations of current methodologies.
Comas I, Homolka S, Niemann S, Gagneux S. · 2009
Read Genotyping of genetically monomorphic bacteria: DNA sequencing in Mycobacterium tuberculosis highlights the limitations of current methodologies. by Comas I, Homolka S, Niemann S, Gagneux S. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2772813.txt.
Introduction
Comas, Homolka, Niemann, and Gagneux tested in 2009 how well standard genotyping methods reconstruct the family tree of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a pathogen with very little DNA diversity. Such monomorphic bacteria are usually typed by mobile or repeated elements: spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR typing in this case. Using full sequences of eighty-nine genes from a global strain collection as the gold standard, they compared the trees each method produced.
Sequence-based trees were highly consistent and strongly supported, with almost no conflicting signal. Trees from spoligotyping and fifteen-locus MIRU-VNTR clashed with them, distorted by convergent evolution, where unrelated strains gain look-alike patterns. The twenty-four-locus version did better but still missed some lineages, and its power varied by lineage. They advise defining lineages by robust sequence markers and tailoring repeat-based typing to each lineage.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Comas I, Homolka S, Niemann S, Gagneux S. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Genotyping of Genetically Monomorphic Bacteria: DNA Sequencing in Mycobacterium tuberculosis Highlights the Limitations of Current Methodologies By Iñaki Comas, Susanne Homolka, Stefan Niemann, Sebastien Gagneux, Anastasia P Litvintseva Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0007815 ABSTRACT Abstract Because genetically monomorphic bacterial pathogens harbour little DNA sequence diversity, most current genotyping techniques used to study the epidemiology of these organisms are based on mobile or repetitive genetic elements. Molecular markers commonly used in these bacteria include Clustered Regulatory Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR) and Variable Number Tandem Repeats (VNTR). These methods are also increasingly being applied to phylogenetic and population genetic studies. Using the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) as a model, we evaluated the phylogenetic accuracy of CRISPR- and VNTR-based genotyping, which in MTBC are known as spoligotyping and Mycobacterial Interspersed Repetitive Units (MIRU)-VNTR-typing, respectively. We used as a gold standard the complete DNA sequences of 89 coding genes from a global strain collection. Our results showed that phylogenetic trees derived from these multilocus sequence data were highly congruent and statistically robust, irrespective of the phylogenetic methods used. By contrast, corresponding phylogenies inferred from spoligotyping or 15-loci-MIRU-VNTR were incongruent with respect to the sequence-based trees. Although 24-loci-MIRU-VNTR performed better, it was still unable to detect all strain lineages. The DNA sequence data showed virtually no homoplasy, but the opposite was true for spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR, which was consistent with high rates of convergent evolution and the low statistical support obtained for phylogenetic groupings defined by these markers. Our results also revealed that the discriminatory power of the standard 24 MIRU-VNTR loci varied by strain lineage. Taken together, our findings suggest strain lineages in MTBC should be defined based on phylogenetically robust markers such as single nucleotide polymorphisms or large sequence polymorphisms, and that for epidemiological purposes, MIRU-VNTR loci should be used in a lineage-dependent manner. Our findings have implications for strain typing in other genetically monomorphic bacteria. INTRODUCTION Some of the most important bacterial pathogens of humans exhibit strikingly low DNA sequence diversity. On average, these organisms harbour one nucleotide difference every 2–28 k base pairs and are thus referred to as genetically monomorphic [1]. Some prominent examples include Yersinia pestis (the etiologic agent of plague) [2], Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi (typhoid fever) [3], Bacillus anthracis (anthrax) [4], as well as the three most important pathogenic mycobacteria, Mycobacterium leprae (leprosy) [5], Mycobacterium ulcerans (buruli ulcer) [6], and Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) [7]. MTBC includes several sub-species that cause tuberculosis in humans and in various other mammals. Understanding the diversity of bacterial pathogens is important, both for epidemiological and biological reasons. However, because of the low DNA sequence variation in monomorphic bacteria, studying the genetic diversity of these microbes is challenging. Standard sequence-based methods like multilocus sequence typing (MLST) are not applicable because of low phylogenetic resolution [8], [9]. Alternative non-sequence-based tools, such as Pulsfield Gel Electrophoresis (PFGE) and Restriction Fragment Length Phylomorphism (RFLP) have been used for fine typing of monomorphic bacteria. However, these gel-based techniques have many draw-backs and are difficult to reproduce within and between laboratories [1]. More recently, PCR-based genotyping methods have been developed. Two of the most popular techniques are based on Clustered Regulatory Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR) and Variable Number Tandem Repeats (VNTR), respectively (Figure 1) [10], [11]. CRISPRs are regions of the bacterial genome characterized by series of direct repeats interspersed by short unique regions called spacers. CRISPRs have been shown to encode a specialized defence mechanisms against bacteriophages, and changes in the number of spacers have been associated with phage-susceptibility [12]. VNTR-typing on the other hand, compares the strain-specific numbers of repeats of short DNA sequences at different positions of the bacterial genome [11]. [Figure: Schematic illustrating the principles of the CRISPR- and VNTR-based genotyping in MTBC.These genotyping methods are known as ‘spoligotyping’ and ‘MIRU-VNTR-typing’, respectively. Spoligotyping is based on the detection of 43 unique spacers located between direct repeats at a specific locus of the MTBC genome known as the direct repeat (DR) locus. Spoligotyping patterns are commonly represented by black and white squares indicating presence or absence of particular spacers, respectively. The deletion of some of these 43 spacers allows to differentiate between strains. MIRU-VNTR analysis relies on the identification of different number of repeats at several loci scattered around the bacterial genome (marked by A, B, C, and D in the figure). The number of repeats at each locus is combined to generate a unique numerical code used to establish phylogenetic and epidemiological links between strains.] CRISPR- and VNTR-based genotyping has been established for many genetically monomorphic bacterial pathogens, including Y. pestis [13], [14], [15], B. anthracis [16], Salmonella eneterica serovar Typhi [17], Francisella tuleransis [18], Escherichia coli O157 [19], and M. leprae [20]. In MTBC, the corresponding CRISPR- and VNTR-based methodologies are known as spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR, respectively (Figure 1) [21], [22]. These two genotyping techniques were originally developed for molecular epidemiological applications, and are routinely used to trace ongoing chains of tuberculosis transmission [23], to differentiate cases of disease relapse from re-infections [24], and to detect laboratory cross-contamination [25]. Over the years, databases have been populated with spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR-typing results from thousands of patient isolates. For example, the spoligotyping database SpolDB4 contains data from close to 40,000 MTBC isolates from more than 120 countries [26], and MIRU-VNTRplus has been put up as a new online reference database for standard genotyping of MTBC [27]. In addition to routine molecular epidemiological applications, spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR are increasingly also being applied to study evolutionary questions. Two complementary sets of MIRU-VNTR loci have been developed for MTBC [28]; 15-loci-MIRU-VNTR, which includes 15 loci, originally found to be the most discriminatory, and 24-loci-MIRU-VNTR that includes the same 15 loci plus an additional nine, which provide additional phylogenetic information. While 15-loci-MIRU-VNTR is mainly being applied for routine molecular epidemiology, spoligotyping and 24-loci-MIRU-VNTR have been proposed for phylogenetic and population genetic analyses of MTBC [26], [29], [30]. We recently performed a multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) of 108 MTBC strains in which we generated the complete coding sequences of 89 genes, corresponding to ∼70 k base pairs per strain [31]. We used these DNA sequences to generate a highly robust phylogeny of MTBC [31], [32]. Here we used this MLSA-based phylogeny to evaluate the phylogenetic accuracy of spoligotyping and MIRU-VNTR in MTBC. In addition, we used this MLSA dataset to investigate the discriminatory power of the 24 standard MIRU-VNTR loci in the different strain lineages of MTBC. RESULTS DNA Sequencing Defines a New Gold-Standard for the Phylogenetic Classification of MTBC We previously showed that MLSA of 108 global strains of MTBC resulted in a single most parsimonious phylogenetic tree with negligible homoplasy (Figure 2) [31]. This phylogeny was also highly congruent with our previous analyses based on large sequence polymorphisms (LSPs) [33], [34], and earlier DNA sequencing work [8], [35]. To further probe the robustness of our MLSA-based phylogeny, we re-analyzed our DNA sequence data by the Neighbour-joining, Maximum likelihood, and Bayesian inference methods. All three analyses yielded identical tree topologies, which were highly congruent with our previous findings based on Maximum parsimony (Figure 2, Figure 3A, Figure S1). Furthermore, high statistical support was obtained for all main clades and for each method, despite the fact that some