Concordant regulation of translation and mRNA abundance for hundreds of targets of a human microRNA.
Hendrickson DG, Hogan DJ, McCullough HL, Myers JW, Herschlag D, Ferrell JE, Brown PO. · 2009
Read Concordant regulation of translation and mRNA abundance for hundreds of targets of a human microRNA. by Hendrickson DG, Hogan DJ, McCullough HL, Myers JW, Herschlag D, Ferrell JE, Brown PO. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2766070.txt.
Introduction
Hendrickson and co-authors measured in 2009 how one human microRNA, miR-124, lowers the output of hundreds of target proteins. MicroRNAs pair with messenger RNAs and cut protein production, but whether they act by destroying the message, blocking its translation, or both was unsettled. The team identified direct miR-124 targets by their recruitment to Argonaute proteins, the core of the microRNA machinery.
For more than eight thousand genes they measured message abundance and two gauges of translation, ribosome occupancy and density. A specific microRNA reduced protein synthesis through matching effects on both fronts: target messages fell in abundance and were translated less. The two effects moved together across hundreds of targets. This concordant pattern argues against models in which microRNAs act on translation alone. The scale of the survey is what lets the pattern stand out so clearly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hendrickson DG, Hogan DJ, McCullough HL, Myers JW, Herschlag D, Ferrell JE, Brown PO. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 114 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Concordant Regulation of Translation and mRNA Abundance for Hundreds of Targets of a Human microRNA By David G. Hendrickson, Daniel J. Hogan, Heather L. McCullough, Jason W. Myers, Daniel Herschlag, James E. Ferrell, Patrick O. Brown, Phillip D. Zamore Published in: PLoS Biology DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1000238 ABSTRACT A specific microRNA reduces the synthesis of hundreds of proteins via concordant effects on the abundance and translation of the mRNAs that encode them. INTRODUCTION MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are small noncoding RNAs whose complementary pairing to target mRNAs potentially regulates expression of more than 60% of genes in many and perhaps all metazoans [1]–[6]. Destabilization of mRNA and translational repression have been suggested as the mechanisms of action for miRNAs [1],[3],[7]–[15], and recent work directly measuring endogenous protein levels in response to altered miRNA expression levels found that specific miRNAs modestly inhibit the production of hundreds of proteins [16],[17]. The importance and functional range of miRNAs are evidenced by the diverse and often dramatic phenotypic consequences when miRNAs are mutated or misexpressed, leading to aberrant development or disease [7],[18]–[24]. Although regulation by miRNAs is an integral component of the global gene expression program, there is currently no consensus on either the mechanism by which they decrease the levels of the targeted proteins or even the steps in gene expression regulated by miRNAs [3],[25]–[29]. The proposal that miRNAs decrease protein levels without affecting mRNA stability arose from the observation that the miRNA lin-4 down-regulates lin-14 expression in the absence of noticeable changes in lin-14 mRNA abundance in Caenorhabditis elegans [7],[30]–[33]. Subsequent studies in mammalian cell culture provided further support for this model [34]–[37]. Several studies have found that repressed mRNAs as well as protein components of the miRNA regulatory system accumulate in P-bodies, suggesting that repressed mRNAs may be sequestered away from the translation pool [38]–[44]. Other evidence points to deadenylation of miRNA-targeted mRNAs, an effect that can inhibit translation [14],[45]–[53]. Some studies have argued that initiation of translation is blocked at either an early, cap-dependent stage or later during AUG recognition or 60S joining [10],[44],[52],[54]–[58]. Others have argued that a postinitiation step is targeted, resulting in either slowed elongation, ribosome drop-off, or nascent polypeptide degradation [7],[59]–[62]. One factor contributing to the lack of a consensus model for miRNA function is the evidence that miRNA targeting of an mRNA significantly reduces message levels (despite previous reports to the contrary) [9],[11],[12],[14],[52],[63],[64]. Indeed, very recent studies from Baek et al. and Selbach et al. found that the changes in mRNA abundance are not only correlated with the repression of many targets, but also can account for most of the observed reduction in protein expression [16],[17]. mRNA targets of the same miRNA can either be translationally repressed with little change in mRNA abundance, translationally repressed and have concordant changes in mRNA abundance, or have little translation repression with large changes in mRNA abundance [52],[65],[66]. That miRNAs can affect both protein production and abundance of their mRNA targets raises the question of to what extent these outcomes of miRNA regulation are mediated by a common mechanism or by competing or complementary processes. The regulatory consequence of a particular miRNA–mRNA interaction might be influenced by miRNA-independent factors such as cellular context or by additional information encoded by the target mRNA, e.g., presence of binding sites for other RNA-binding proteins and miRNAs, secondary structure around miRNA binding sites, or the intrinsic decay rate of the mRNA [25],[51],[67],[68]. Experiment-specific effects of in vitro translation assays, reporter constructs, or procedural differences that alter properties of gene expression could account for some of the wide variation in the apparent mechanisms by which miRNAs alter expression [25],[27]. To date, most studies on translational regulation by miRNAs have used reporter assays. Although assays that rely on engineered reporter transcripts are powerful, assay-specific anomalies are a concern; artificial mRNAs may lack key pieces of regulatory information, overexpression of reporter mRNAs could mask subtle regulatory functions, and DNA transfection can lead to indirect effects on cell physiology [26]. Indeed, recent reports have found that differences in experimental setup, such as the method of transfection, type of 5′-cap, or the promoter sequence of the DNA reporter construct can drastically alter the degree or even the apparent mode of regulation by miRNAs [59],[69]. In addition, some models have been based on studies in which only one or a few targets were studied, which introduces the possibility of generalizing the behavior of a single miRNA–mRNA interaction that may not represent the dominant biological mechanism. Two recent studies avoided many of these caveats by overexpressing, inhibiting, or deleting specific miRNAs and systematically measuring changes in endogenous mRNA and protein levels using DNA microarrays and stable isotope labeling with amino acids in cell culture (SILAC), respectively [16],[17]. Both studies found mostly concordant changes in mRNA levels and protein levels, with changes in mRNA levels accounting for much, but not all, of the changes in protein abundance. With data for hundreds of endogenous targets, these studies were the first to provide genome-wide evidence that mRNA degradation accounts for much of the reduction in protein levels. And whereas these results suggest that translation inhibition accounts for some of the observed changes in protein abundance of miRNA targets, they do not provide direct evidence of this, nor do they provide insight into which steps in translation are regulated, the extent this regulation contributes to reduced gene expression of specific mRNAs, or its possible links to mRNA decay. To investigate how miRNAs regulate gene expression, we systematically identified direct targets of the miRNA miR-124 by measuring the recruitment of target mRNAs to Argonaute (Ago) proteins, the core components of the miRNA effector complex, as previously described [70]–[72]. We then measured, in parallel, mRNA abundance and two indicators of translation rate, ribosome occupancy and ribosome density, for more than 8,000 genes, using DNA microarrays and a novel polysome encoding scheme. This strategy allowed us to directly investigate the behavior of miRNA–mRNA target pairs with respect to both mRNA fate and translation, on a genomic scale. RESULTS Systematic Identification of mRNAs Recruited to Argonautes by miR-124 To study the effects of miR-124 on expression of mRNA targets, we first had to identify those targets. Recruitment to Ago complexes in response to the expression of a particular miRNA appears to be the most reliable criterion for target identification [70]. To this end, we lysed human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293T cells transfected with miR-124 and isolated Ago-associated RNA by immunopurification (IP) using a monoclonal antibody that recognizes all four human Ago paralogs [73]. We measured mRNA enrichment in Ago IPs by comparative DNA microarray hybridization of samples prepared from immunupurified RNA and total RNA from cell extracts. Three replicates of Ago and control IPs were performed from both miR-124 and mock-transfected cells (Datasets S1 and S5). To examine the enrichment profiles of the IPs, we first clustered the microarray results by their similarity and visualized the results as a heatmap, with the degree of enrichment of each RNA shown on a green (least enriched) to red (most enriched) scale (Figure S1). The Ago IP enrichment profiles were reproducible as evidenced by an average Pearson correlation coefficient between mRNA enrichment profiles of Ago IPs in mock-transfected cells and miR-124–transfected cells of 0.90 and