Deconstructing stem cell tumorigenicity: a roadmap to safe regenerative medicine.
Knoepfler PS. · 2009
Read Deconstructing stem cell tumorigenicity: a roadmap to safe regenerative medicine. by Knoepfler PS. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2733374.txt.
Introduction
Knoepfler examined in 2009 why stem cells so readily form tumors. He focused on embryonic stem cells and their risk for regenerative medicine. The earliest stem cell work used embryonic carcinoma cells from tumors. Those cells share with embryonic stem cells the power to become many cell types. Both also form teratomas, tumors with mixed tissues, with ease.
Decades later, what drives that tumor formation is still largely open. Induced pluripotent stem cells may carry equal or greater risk. These are adult cells reset to an embryonic state. Knoepfler explores links between pluripotency and tumor growth. He proposes sharper tests of tumor risk for cell batches. He also highlights new ways to purge or control risky cells before therapy.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Knoepfler PS. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deconstructing Stem Cell Tumorigenicity: A Roadmap to Safe Regenerative Medicine By Paul S Knoepfler Published in: Stem Cells (Dayton, Ohio) DOI: 10.1002/stem.37 ABSTRACT Many of the earliest stem cell studies were conducted on cells isolated from tumors rather than from embryos. Of particular interest was research on embryonic carcinoma cells (EC), a type of stem cell derived from teratocarcinoma. The EC research laid the foundation for the later discovery of and subsequent work on embryonic stem cells (ESC). Both ESC isolated from the mouse (mESC) and then later from humans (hESC) shared not only pluripotency with their EC cousins, but also robust tumorigenicity as each readily form teratoma. Surprisingly, decades after the discovery of mESC, the question of what drives ESC to form tumors remains largely an open one. This gap in the field is particularly serious as stem cell tumorigenicity represents the key obstacle to the safe use of stem cell-based regenerative medicine therapies. Although some adult stem cell therapies appear to be safe, they have only a very narrow range of uses in human disease. Our understanding of the tumorigenicity of human induced pluripotent stem cells (IPSC), perhaps the most promising modality for future patient-specific regenerative medicine therapies, is rudimentary. However, IPSC are predicted to possess tumorigenic potential equal to or greater than that of ESC. Here, the links between pluripotency and tumorigenicity are explored. New methods for more accurately testing the tumorigenic potential of IPSC and of other stem cells applicable to regenerative medicine are proposed. Finally, the most promising emerging approaches for overcoming the challenges of stem cell tumorigenicity are highlighted. TUMORS, NOT EMBRYOS INITIATED THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE EMBRYONIC STEM CELLS FIELD The link between stem and tumor cells in science is a very old one. The earliest research on highly pluripotent stem cells was conducted not on normal stem cells, but instead on embryonic carcinoma cells (EC) derived from teratocarcinoma. EC had unusual stem-like properties that attracted a great deal of attention at the time, including a surprising degree of plasticity. Teratocarcinoma and its benign cousin teratoma are the best examples of tumors with substantial populations of pluripotent stem cells as well as differentiated tissues. It may not be widely appreciated that when embryonic stem cells (ESC) were first isolated [1,2] from the mouse by two independent groups more than a decade after the discovery of EC, the existing knowledge base and reagents related to EC played pivotal roles. In fact, in one case ESC were established and cultured in EC conditioned media [2]. It was also noted that ESC expressed the same markers as EC. Thus, EC were the touchstone to which ESC were initially compared and the fact that ESC shared so many properties with established EC lines was argued as validation that ESC were pluripotent stem cells. ESC and EC could be differentiated into a myriad of cell types [3] and formed teratoma with many diverse tissues, suggesting the exciting conclusion that both these cell types had robust pluripotency (reviewed in [4]). However, these studies also raised an important, still largely unanswered question. Why would ESC, supposedly normal counterparts to EC, also have the ability to cause tumors? The simplest but most troublesome answer is that ESC and EC are in fact, as was originally assumed, quite similar types of cells. Removing the inner cell mass (ICM) from the context of the early embryo and enforcing the culture of ICM cells in vitro produces a new cell type that does not normally exist in nature, that is, ESC. Although ESC mirror many of the normal, desired properties of the ICM cells such as near totipotency, they are not simply an in vitro manifestation of ICM cells but also almost certainly contain distinct properties, some of a more tumorigenic nature. The fact that the ESC field began with and in some ways depended on the much earlier discovery of EC highlights the intimate link between stem and tumor cells as well as between pluripotency and tumorigenicity. The shift to a potentially more tumorigenic state as ICM cells transition to ESC in vitro may be driven by the method of creating ESC via selecting for those unique ICM cells that can be forced to grow in vitro. This selective process is predicted to go hand-in-hand with epigenetic changes that enable such growth. Thus, driving ICM cells to become ESC may be at the same time creating a cell type that is inescapably also pushed toward a tumorigenic phenotype. Just how different ESC are from ICM cells remains an intriguing question. It is important to note that even transplants of whole early embryos can drive teratoma formation as well so some of the forces driving teratoma formation are intrinsic to ICM cells and not because of their in vitro growth to produce ESC. THE TERATOMA ASSAY: BOTH A PLURIPOTENCY AND A TUMOR ASSAY It is remarkable that, to date, one of the most common assays for demonstrating and studying the pluripotency of stem cells, including induced pluripotent stem cells (IPSC), is the teratoma assay. Often this is referred to as a pluripotency assay, but of course it is also a tumor assay. The fact that a key assay of “stemness” is also a tumor assay further illustrates the strong link between stem and tumor cells, a reality too rarely discussed in the field when interpreting results from teratoma assays. Even ignoring for the moment the ability of ESC and IPSC to produce malignant tumors in some cases [5,6], the production of benign teratoma as a side effect in humans given a hypothetical regenerative medicine therapy in the future, would be unacceptable. Such tumors could be numerous and would prove highly destructive to surrounding normal or regenerating tissue. Thus, a key concept is that stem cells, even those with potent self-renewal and pluripotency, will almost certainly never be directly used in regenerative medicine if they cannot be proven to lack the ability to cause teratoma in mice. WHAT IS THE MOLECULAR BASIS OF THE TUMORIGENICITY OF NORMAL STEM CELLS? Recent studies indicate that many of the same master programming elements are at work in both stem cells and tumor cells [7–10]. This shared molecular machinery suggests that untangling the determinants of pluripotency from the programming responsible for tumorigenicity is going to be a major challenge. The links between pluripotency and tumorigenicity are exemplified by the fact that many of the genes used to produce IPSC are either outright established oncogenes such as Myc and KLF4 [11–13] or are in various ways linked to tumorigenesis such as Sox2 [14], Nanog [9], and Oct3 [15]. But perhaps no molecule embodies the interwoven nature of the pluripotency and tumorigenicity programs more than Myc itself. Overexpression of the Myc family of proto-oncogenes is linked with an array of human tumors and elevated Myc expression may have some role in all human cancer [16]. Not only is Myc expression itself shared between stem and tumor cells, but distinct groups of Myc regulated target genes are coexpressed in both malignant tumors and ESC [10]. Myc was one of the first oncogenes discovered and there are literally thousands of papers studying the function of excess Myc in cancer. However, it has only