Prognostic indicators in hepatocellular carcinoma: a systematic review of 72 studies.

Tandon P, Garcia-Tsao G. · 2009

Read Prognostic indicators in hepatocellular carcinoma: a systematic review of 72 studies. by Tandon P, Garcia-Tsao G. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2711257.txt.

Introduction

Tandon and Garcia-Tsao reviewed in 2009 what predicts death in liver cancer with cirrhosis. Cirrhosis is severe scarring of the liver. The cancer form they studied is hepatocellular carcinoma. Most older studies mixed patients with and without cirrhosis, and mixed mild and advanced liver failure. That mix could blur which signs truly matter at each stage.

Across 72 studies with close to twenty-four thousand patients, the firmest predictors were tumor size and spread into the portal vein. A tumor marker in blood and Child-Pugh class, a score of liver function, also predicted death. Both tumor traits and liver traits mattered. Too few studies split mild from advanced cirrhosis to prove that predictors differ by stage.

Catalog record

CREATORTandon P, Garcia-Tsao G.
YEAR2009
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2711257

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Prognostic indicators in hepatocellular carcinoma: a systematic review of 72 studies By Puneeta Tandon, Guadalupe Garcia-Tsao Published in: Liver International DOI: 10.1111/j.1478-3231.2008.01957.x ABSTRACT Background Although there are many studies of the predictors of death in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), most combine patients with and without cirrhosis and many combine those with compensated and decompensated cirrhosis. Objective To perform a systematic review of the literature evaluating the predictors of death in patients with cirrhosis and HCC and to evaluate whether the predictors differ between patients with compensated and decompensated cirrhosis. Methods Inclusion criteria: (i) publication in English, (ii) adult patients, (c) >80% of the patients had cirrhosis, (iv) follow-up >6 months and (v) multivariable analysis. Quality was based on the accepted quality criteria for prognostic studies. Results Of the 1106 references obtained, 947 were excluded because they did not meet the inclusion criteria. A total of 23 968 patients were included in 72 studies (median, 177/study); 77% male, median age 64, 55% Child–Pugh class A. The most robust predictors of death were portal vein thrombosis, tumour size, α-foetoprotein and Child–Pugh class. Sensitivity analysis using only 15 ‘good’ studies and 22 studies in which all patients had cirrhosis yielded the same variables. In the studies including mostly compensated or decompensated patients, the predictors were both liver and tumour related. However, these studies were few and the results were not robust. Conclusions This systematic review of 72 studies shows that the most robust predictors of death in patients with cirrhosis and HCC are tumour related and liver related. Future prognostic studies should include these predictors and should be performed in specific patient populations to determine whether specific prognostic indicators are more relevant at different stages of cirrhosis. Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is responsible for significant morbidity and mortality in cirrhosis. It commonly leads to decompensation of cirrhosis and is one of the leading causes of death in cirrhotic patients (1, 2). Identifying the accurate prognostic indicators of death for HCC allows the provider to counsel individual patients and also forms the basis of any decision-making process. Most cases of HCC in the western world occur in the setting of cirrhosis and, therefore, prognosis is determined not only by factors related to the tumour but also by factors related to cirrhosis. In fact, current prognostic models for HCC include parameters of liver dysfunction and parameters related to HCC (3–5). However, studies on the prediction of death in HCC include patients both with and without underlying cirrhosis, and this heterogeneity may impact the clinical utility of current prognostic models. Additionally, one could hypothesize that, as in cirrhosis not associated with HCC (2), the prognostic factors for HCC would be different in patients with underlying compensated vs. decompensated cirrhosis, with factors related to the tumour having a greater prognostic significance in the former and factors related to both tumour and liver disease being more important in the latter. The purpose of this systematic review is to evaluate the predictors of death in patients with HCC and underlying cirrhosis to determine whether the predictors differ between patients with compensated and decompensated cirrhosis. METHODS A Medline search was performed using the terms (survival [ALL] OR mortality [ALL] OR predictor [ALL] OR prognosis [ALL] OR prognostic [ALL] AND (multivariate OR Cox OR Cox's OR adjusted OR adjustment OR logistic [ALL]) [MESH] AND hepatocellular carcinoma [MESH]. The search was carried out in March 2008 and no lower date limit was set on the search results. Additional studies were located by manual search using references from retrieved articles. Studies were selected using the following inclusion criteria: (i) English language, (ii) inclusion of only adult patients, (iii) established diagnosis of HCC, (iv) >80% of patients included had cirrhosis – if cirrhosis was not specifically mentioned, it was assumed that the population was comprised of cirrhotic patients if all patients in the study were classified into Child–Pugh classes, (v) survival analysis was reported, (vi) multivariate analysis of prognostic indicators of mortality was performed and (vii) patients in the study were either untreated or the study included more than one type of therapy following a local treatment protocol. Trials were excluded if they had (i) <80% cirrhosis, (ii) only prediction of short-term survival (<6 months), (iii) a single treatment option was being analysed, (iv) randomized trials comparing two different therapies, (v) the main predictive factor being studied was a tumour histological feature (i.e. tumour staining) and (vi) abstract only or full-text article not available. The rationale for excluding trials with only a single treatment option was that as candidates for particular treatment options may have varying prognoses, this may have resulted in a biased inclusion of patients. Required clinical data and data regarding study validity were predefined and collected for all studies meeting the inclusion criteria. Study validity was assessed using predefined quality criteria, as listed in Table 1 (2, 6–8). Because none of the trials met all the quality criteria (Table 1), ‘good quality’ studies were arbitrarily defined as those that fulfilled all four of the following major quality criteria: (i) enrollment of consecutive patients, (ii) listing relevant baseline data, (iii) reporting the number of deaths and (iv) the absence of overfitting (ratio of the number of deaths/the number of variables >10). All ‘good quality’ studies documented the number of patients with cirrhosis. [Table: Summary of the characteristics of 72 studies of the predictors of mortality in hepatocellular carcinoma] An ‘advanced’ tumour was arbitrarily defined as any of the following: ‘multinodular’ tumours or tumours exceeding the Milan criteria (one tumour >5 cm or three tumors, with any of them being >3 cm) (9). In the analysis aimed at determining whether the prognostic variables differed between patients with advanced vs. non-advanced tumours, studies including mostly advanced tumours were defined as those in which 66% of the patients had advanced tumours and studies including mostly non-advanced tumours were defined as those in which >66% of the patients had non-advanced tumours. Decompensated cirrhosis was defined as a patient with Child–Pugh B or C classification. In the analysis aimed at determining whether the prognostic variables differed between patients with compensated vs. decompensated cirrhosis, studies including mostly compensated patients were arbitrarily defined as those in which >66% of the patients were Child–Pugh A and studies including mostly decompensated patients were arbitrarily defined as those in which >66% of the patients were Child–Pugh B or C. The 1-, 2-, 3- and 5-year cumulative survivals and the final cumulative survival were recorded if present. The first five significant prognostic indicators in each multivariate analysis were recorded as were the number of studies evaluating each variable. A sensitivity analysis was performed using the ‘good quality’ studies and using the studies in which 100% of the patients had cirrhosis. RESULTS As shown in Figure 1, of the 1106 references identified through a Medline search, 947 were excluded on analysis of the abstract provided because they did not meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Of the remaining 159 full-text articles, 88 were excluded, 84 because they did not meet the inclusion criteria (at least 35 had combined cirrhotic and non-cirrhotic patients, with <80% being cirrhotic and 10 did not even mention whether there was underlying cirrhosis) and four because the full-text paper was not found,

Read the complete text