Research in action: using positive deviance to improve quality of health care.
Bradley EH, Curry LA, Ramanadhan S, Rowe L, Nembhard IM, Krumholz HM. · 2009
Read Research in action: using positive deviance to improve quality of health care. by Bradley EH, Curry LA, Ramanadhan S, Rowe L, Nembhard IM, Krumholz HM. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2690576.txt.
Introduction
Bradley and colleagues argued in 2009 that health care improves fastest by studying its own stars, an approach called positive deviance. Decades of quality campaigns had left poor care stubbornly common, and under one percent of medical research money targeted delivery itself. The approach starts from a bet: somewhere, an organization already performs exceptionally with the same resources as everyone else.
The method runs in four steps. Find the consistently top performers. Study them closely, with interviews and observation, to form guesses about the practices behind their success. Test those guesses statistically across a broad sample. Then spread what survives, working with the very people expected to adopt it. The authors illustrate with hospital care for heart attacks, where speed of treatment varies hugely. The approach suits problems where the knowledge exists but sits trapped in a few bright spots.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bradley EH, Curry LA, Ramanadhan S, Rowe L, Nembhard IM, Krumholz HM. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Research in action: using positive deviance to improve quality of health care By Elizabeth H Bradley, Leslie A Curry, Shoba Ramanadhan, Laura Rowe, Ingrid M Nembhard, Harlan M Krumholz Published in: Implementation Science : IS DOI: 10.1186/1748-5908-4-25 ABSTRACT Background Despite decades of efforts to improve quality of health care, poor performance persists in many aspects of care. Less than 1% of the enormous national investment in medical research is focused on improving health care delivery. Furthermore, when effective innovations in clinical care are discovered, uptake of these innovations is often delayed and incomplete. In this paper, we build on the established principle of 'positive deviance' to propose an approach to identifying practices that improve health care quality. Methods We synthesize existing literature on positive deviance, describe major alternative approaches, propose benefits and limitations of a positive deviance approach for research directed toward improving quality of health care, and describe an application of this approach in improving hospital care for patients with acute myocardial infarction. Results The positive deviance approach, as adapted for use in health care, presumes that the knowledge about 'what works' is available in existing organizations that demonstrate consistently exceptional performance. Steps in this approach: identify 'positive deviants,' i.e., organizations that consistently demonstrate exceptionally high performance in the area of interest (e.g., proper medication use, timeliness of care); study the organizations in-depth using qualitative methods to generate hypotheses about practices that allow organizations to achieve top performance; test hypotheses statistically in larger, representative samples of organizations; and work in partnership with key stakeholders, including potential adopters, to disseminate the evidence about newly characterized best practices. The approach is particularly appropriate in situations where organizations can be ranked reliably based on valid performance measures, where there is substantial natural variation in performance within an industry, when openness about practices to achieve exceptional performance exists, and where there is an engaged constituency to promote uptake of discovered practices. Conclusion The identification and examination of health care organizations that demonstrate positive deviance provides an opportunity to characterize and disseminate strategies for improving quality. INTRODUCTION Despite decades of efforts to improve quality of health care, poor performance persists in many aspects of care. Patients often do not receive guideline-recommended processes of care [1-3], and risk-adjusted outcomes vary substantially across hospitals [4] and regions [5,6], suggesting potential for improvements. Furthermore, despite enormous national investment in biomedical research, less than 1% of this is directed at research on improving health care delivery [7], and when innovations in clinical care are discovered, the uptake of these improvements into practice is often delayed and incomplete [8-11]. We describe an approach to quality of care research that identifies innovative strategies from 'positive deviants' in health care, those organizations that consistently demonstrate exceptionally high performance in an area of interest (e.g., survival rates, medication use, and timely emergency treatment). The central premise of a positive deviance approach [12,13] is that solutions to problems that face a community often exist within that community, and that certain members possess wisdom that can be generalized to improve the performance of other members. Many of these strategies rely on resources that already exist in the community, which can increase their adoption and sustained use [14]. The power of a positive deviance approach to improve health outcomes has been shown in complex problems globally, including pregnancy outcomes [15], condom use [16], and childhood nutrition [12,17,18]. In a dramatic application of positive deviance in Vietnam, childhood malnutrition was reduced by 75% [12]. Researchers identified a set of women as 'positive deviants' because their children were thriving despite high rates of childhood wasting and stunting in their rural villages. The women were including in their cooking pots tiny shrimps and crabs, found in large numbers in rice paddies but not normally used because fish were generally thought to be inappropriate for young children [18]. The subsequent randomized controlled trial showed significant improvements in health outcomes of children fed in this way [12,17,19]. This method of food preparation was then disseminated and sustained years after the original studies [20]. The 'best practice' was based on proven, successful practices within the community, rather than theoretical concepts of good nutrition. How might this potentially powerful approach be used to improve quality of health care delivery in the United States? How does it differ from other strategies of identifying and disseminating best practices, and in what circumstances might this approach be most effective? We address these questions in the following five sections. In the first section, we provide an overview of the positive deviance approach as applied to the organizational setting and discuss when its application is most useful. In the second section, we outline core methodological considerations in this approach. In the third section, we compare the positive deviance approach to alternative methods of identifying best practices, including standard biomedical and epidemiologic research and quality improvement and action research. In the fourth section, we draw on theoretical literature to describe how the positive deviance approach can promote effective dissemination of best practices. We conclude with an illustrative example of the positive deviance approach applied to improving hospital care nationally for patients with myocardial infarction. Overview of positive deviance approach The positive deviance approach accomplishes two goals: the identification of practices that are associated with top performance, and promoting the uptake of these practices within an industry, using the following steps (Figure 1): identify 'positive deviants,' i.e., organizations that consistently demonstrate exceptionally high performance in the area of interest (e.g., proper medication use, timeliness of care); study the organizations in-depth using qualitative methods to generate hypotheses about practices that enable organizations to achieve top performance; test hypotheses statistically in larger, representative samples of organizations; and work in partnership with key stakeholders, including potential adopters, to disseminate the evidence about newly characterized best practices. [Figure: Steps in the positive deviance approach.] When should one consider using a positive deviance approach to identify and disseminate best practices in health care organizations? First, the approach requires concrete, widely endorsed, and accessible performance measures for organizations. For instance, in the case of hospital care, there are several specific, validated, and publicly-reported performance measures; therefore, hospitals can be ranked according to performance, and positive deviants within the industry can be identified. In contrast, there are no publicly accessible data on performance measures for many health care conditions such as treatment of children with fevers or hospital falls among elderly, among others. Positive deviance studies in these areas would therefore be difficult to accomplish. Second, the positive deviance approach works when there is variation in organizational performance and outcomes across the industry, with some organizations achieving marked and consistent top performance and other organizations not doing so, i.e., there are positive deviants. Additionally, the approach is effective when organizations are adequately open to sharing their strategies for exceptional performance. In cases where organizations are highly proprietary and resistant to sharing what might be viewed as competitive advantages or 'trade secrets,' the positive deviance approach is unlikely to produce meaningful results. Third, the approach is effective when hypotheses generated from the experience of top performing organizations can be tested in larger, representative samples. Evidence from statistical testing is particularly useful when disseminating findings to health care