The toxicity data landscape for environmental chemicals.
Judson R, Richard A, Dix DJ, Houck K, Martin M, Kavlock R, Dellarco V, Henry T, Holderman T, Sayre P, Tan S, Carpenter T, Smith E. · 2009
Read The toxicity data landscape for environmental chemicals. by Judson R, Richard A, Dix DJ, Houck K, Martin M, Kavlock R, Dellarco V, Henry T, Holderman T, Sayre P, Tan S, Carpenter T, Smith E. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2685828.txt.
Introduction
Judson and colleagues mapped in 2009 how much toxicity knowledge actually exists for the thousands of chemicals in daily use. Only a fraction had ever been well tested, leaving regulators to guess which of the rest deserve scarce testing first. The United States Environmental Protection Agency built a giant catalogue, ACToR, pulling data from over 200 public sources worldwide.
From that catalogue the team charted the evidence for 9,912 chemicals on a screening shortlist: industrial chemicals made in bulk, pesticide ingredients, and drinking water contaminants. For each, the catalogue holds structure, physical traits, cell-test results, animal data, and official hazard verdicts. The picture was patchy: rich files for a few famous chemicals, near silence for most. Making the gaps visible, the authors argue, is the first step to a rational testing queue.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Judson R, Richard A, Dix DJ, Houck K, Martin M, Kavlock R, Dellarco V, Henry T, Holderman T, Sayre P, Tan S, Carpenter T, Smith E. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| LICENSE | CC0 1.0 Universal |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Toxicity Data Landscape for Environmental Chemicals By Richard Judson, Ann Richard, David J. Dix, Keith Houck, Matthew Martin, Robert Kavlock, Vicki Dellarco, Tala Henry, Todd Holderman, Philip Sayre, Shirlee Tan, Thomas Carpenter Published in: Environmental Health Perspectives DOI: 10.1289/ehp.0800168 ABSTRACT Objective Thousands of chemicals are in common use, but only a portion of them have undergone significant toxicologic evaluation, leading to the need to prioritize the remainder for targeted testing. To address this issue, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and other organizations are developing chemical screening and prioritization programs. As part of these efforts, it is important to catalog, from widely dispersed sources, the toxicology information that is available. The main objective of this analysis is to define a list of environmental chemicals that are candidates for the U.S. EPA screening and prioritization process, and to catalog the available toxicology information. Data sources We are developing ACToR (Aggregated Computational Toxicology Resource), which combines information for hundreds of thousands of chemicals from > 200 public sources, including the U.S. EPA, National Institutes of Health, Food and Drug Administration, corresponding agencies in Canada, Europe, and Japan, and academic sources. Data extraction ACToR contains chemical structure information; physical–chemical properties; in vitro assay data; tabular in vivo data; summary toxicology calls (e.g., a statement that a chemical is considered to be a human carcinogen); and links to online toxicology summaries. Here, we use data from ACToR to assess the toxicity data landscape for environmental chemicals. Data synthesis We show results for a set of 9,912 environmental chemicals being considered for analysis as part of the U.S. EPA ToxCast screening and prioritization program. These include high-and medium-production-volume chemicals, pesticide active and inert ingredients, and drinking water contaminants. Conclusions Approximately two-thirds of these chemicals have at least limited toxicity summaries available. About one-quarter have been assessed in at least one highly curated toxicology evaluation database such as the U.S. EPA Toxicology Reference Database, U.S. EPA Integrated Risk Information System, and the National Toxicology Program. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has a significant interest in developing more efficient and informative toxicity determination approaches in part because of the large number of chemicals under its jurisdiction. Ultimately, it would be beneficial to characterize the toxicologic profiles of all chemicals in use in the United States. However, the size of this chemical universe [in excess of 75,000 chemicals, which is the estimated number in the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA 1976) inventory (U.S. EPA 2004b) makes this goal too difficult using current approaches to toxicity characterization that rely on extensive animal testing, cost millions of dollars, and can take 2–3 years per chemical. The International Life Sciences Institute/Health and Environmental Sciences Institute (ILSI/HESI) recently released several reports describing a more focused, tier-based approach for toxicity testing of agricultural chemicals, which would ultimately lead to the use of fewer animals (Barton et al. 2006; Carmichael et al. 2006). The National Research Council (NRC) recently released a report titled Toxicity Testing in the 21st Century: A Vision and a Strategy that outlines a much more ambitious and long-term vision for developing novel in vitro approaches to chemical toxicity characterization and prediction (NRC 2007) that would largely eliminate animal testing. The NRC report addresses several concerns about the current testing methods, specifically, the desire a) to reduce the number of animals used in testing, b) to reduce the overall cost and time required to characterize each chemical, and c) to increase the level of mechanistic understanding of chemical toxicity. The U.S. EPA and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) are actively pursuing approaches to implement ideas outlined in the NRC report (Collins et al. 2008). Regardless of the level of quality of toxicology data on environmental chemicals, many chemicals lack significant amounts of data. In the United States and Canada, an estimated 30,000 chemicals are in wide commercial use, based on U.S. EPA and Environment Canada data (Muir and Howard 2006). The European Union’s Registration, Evaluation, and Authorization of Chemicals (REACH) program has recently released its first set of registered substances, which contains > 140,000 entries (REACH 2008). The exact number of chemicals in use is, in a sense, unknowable because it depends on where one sets the threshold of use and because use changes over time. The major point is that the number is relatively large and that only a relatively small subset of these chemicals have been sufficiently well characterized for their potential to cause human or ecologic toxicity to support regulatory action. This “data gap” is well documented (Allanou et al. 1999; Applegate and Baer 2006; Birnbaum et al. 2003; Guth et al. 2005; NRC 2007; U.S. EPA 1998). The high cost and lengthy times associated with the use of animal testing to determine a chemical’s potential for toxicity make this strategy impractical for evaluating tens of thousands of chemicals, hence the large inventories of existing chemicals for which few or no test data are available. An alternative approach is to attempt to assess much larger numbers of chemicals by employing more efficient in vitro methods. One strategy applies a broad spectrum of relatively inexpensive and rapid high-throughput screening (HTS) assays to a large set of chemicals, followed by the use of these results to prioritize a much smaller subset of chemicals for more detailed analysis. The “prioritization score” for a chemical would be based on signatures, or patterns extracted from the HTS data, that are predictive of particular effects or modes of chemical toxicity. A comprehensive prioritization approach will also require the use of exposure and pharmacokinetic estimates, in addition to the intrinsic hazard information provided by in vitro assays. Chemicals of known toxicity make up the training and validation sets that are used to develop and validate these predictive signatures. HTS assays that yield data for the predictive signatures would then be run on chemicals of unknown toxicity (the test chemicals), and a prioritization score for those chemicals would be produced. The U.S. EPA has made a significant investment in this approach through the ToxCast research program (Dix et al. 2007). ToxCast is currently screening hundreds, and eventually thousands, of environmental chemicals using hundreds of HTS assays with the goal to develop predictive toxicity signatures, and is using these signatures to prioritize chemicals for further testing. In this context, the term “environmental chemicals” refers primarily to pesticides and industrial chemicals that are used or produced in large enough quantities to pose potential for human or ecologic exposure [largely the high-production-volume (HPV) and medium-production-volume (MPV) chemicals described below]. However, a number of environmental chemicals that are captured in our analysis are food ingredients or naturally occurring human metabolites. We included many of the former because they are classified as inert ingredients in pesticide products. In this article we address two key aspects of this chemical screening and prioritization process. The first is the definition of a set of chemicals of interest to a screening program, based on their widespread use or other potential for significant human exposure, or the current availability of toxicity information that can be used in building screening models. Some widely used but as yet uncharacterized chemicals may not be good candidates for screening because their physical–chemical properties make them impractical to