Comparative toxicity of 24 manufactured nanoparticles in human alveolar epithelial and macrophage cell lines.
Lanone S, Rogerieux F, Geys J, Dupont A, Maillot-Marechal E, Boczkowski J, Lacroix G, Hoet P. · 2009
Read Comparative toxicity of 24 manufactured nanoparticles in human alveolar epithelial and macrophage cell lines. by Lanone S, Rogerieux F, Geys J, Dupont A, Maillot-Marechal E, Boczkowski J, Lacroix G, Hoet P. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2685765.txt.
Introduction
Lanone and co-authors compared in 2009 the toxicity of 24 manufactured nanoparticles on two human lung cell lines. Nanoparticles, specks thousands of times thinner than a hair, go into sunscreens, coatings, and electronics. Workers and users breathe them, yet safety data lagged behind production. The team wanted both a ranking of danger and a fast standard test.
They exposed lung surface cells and immune cells to particles of matched size but different chemistry, and read survival with two assays at two time points. The most sensitive setup paired one assay with the immune cells at 24 hours. Copper and zinc particles killed the most cells. Titanium, aluminum, cerium, and zirconium oxides sat in the middle. Tungsten carbide showed no toxicity at all. Neither particle size nor surface area predicted the harm; chemistry did.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lanone S, Rogerieux F, Geys J, Dupont A, Maillot-Marechal E, Boczkowski J, Lacroix G, Hoet P. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparative toxicity of 24 manufactured nanoparticles in human alveolar epithelial and macrophage cell lines By Sophie Lanone, Françoise Rogerieux, Jorina Geys, Aurélie Dupont, Emmanuelle Maillot-Marechal, Jorge Boczkowski, Ghislaine Lacroix, Peter Hoet Published in: Particle and Fibre Toxicology DOI: 10.1186/1743-8977-6-14 ABSTRACT Background A critical issue with nanomaterials is the clear understanding of their potential toxicity. We evaluated the toxic effect of 24 nanoparticles of similar equivalent spherical diameter and various elemental compositions on 2 human pulmonary cell lines: A549 and THP-1. A secondary aim was to elaborate a generic experimental set-up that would allow the rapid screening of cytotoxic effect of nanoparticles. We therefore compared 2 cytotoxicity assays (MTT and Neutral Red) and analyzed 2 time points (3 and 24 hours) for each cell type and nanoparticle. When possible, TC50 (Toxic Concentration 50 i.e. nanoparticle concentration inducing 50% cell mortality) was calculated. Results The use of MTT assay on THP-1 cells exposed for 24 hours appears to be the most sensitive experimental design to assess the cytotoxic effect of one nanoparticle. With this experimental set-up, Copper- and Zinc-based nanoparticles appear to be the most toxic. Titania, Alumina, Ceria and Zirconia-based nanoparticles show moderate toxicity, and no toxicity was observed for Tungsten Carbide. No correlation between cytotoxicity and equivalent spherical diameter or specific surface area was found. Conclusion Our study clearly highlights the difference of sensitivity between cell types and cytotoxicity assays that has to be carefully taken into account when assessing nanoparticles toxicity. BACKGROUND Engineered nanomaterials possess astonishing physical and chemical properties, which lead to an exponential development and production worldwide . For example, titanium dioxide nanoparticles possess photocatalyst activity and are used as antibacterial coatings and in sunscreens [1]. Due to their antibacterial properties, silver nanoparticles are used as medical tools, but they are also of interest in photography, jewelry, electricity and as batteries [1]. The list of actual applications and uses for nanomaterials is already substantial, and will certainly become exponential in the future. A critical issue in this wide development and subsequent use is the essential need of knowledge on nanomaterials toxicity. Several physico-chemical parameters have been proposed to be critical determinants in nanomaterial toxicity: size, crystalline structure, chemical composition, surface area, oxidation status, ... (see [2] for review). However, no single parameter has yet been identified as being the one responsible for nanomaterial toxicity. Moreover, another important factor to take into account is the nature of the cell type studied. Indeed, each cell type has its own function and therefore may not respond the same way as another cell type after exposure to one single nanomaterial. For example, Sayes and collaborators recently demonstrate that rat lung epithelial (L2 cell line) and primary alveolar macrophages exposed to different nanosized particles (carbonyl iron, silica, zinc oxide, 90–500 nm) show different sensitivity in terms of viability and inflammatory profile [3]. Nano- and fine-sized zinc oxide particles induced the highest toxicity in lung epithelial cells only, not in macrophages that were essentially resistant to all particles. Moreover, only carbonyl iron and silica nanoparticles did induce inflammatory cytokine (MIP-2) production, by macrophages only, thus showing dissociation between toxicity and inflammatory effects of these nanomaterials. In the same line, Soto and collaborators demonstrate that macrophages (from murin or human origin) do not have the same sensitivity than human alveolar epithelial cells in response to commercially manufactured inorganic nanoparticulate materials [4]. Among all engineered nanomaterials, carbon black and titanium dioxide nanoparticles have been extensively studied in terms of cytotoxic effects on various cell types, including macrophages, lung epithelial cells, fibroblasts of human or murin origin [5-8]. Beside those two types of nanoparticles, other engineered nanomaterial cytotoxic effect has been studied, such as cobalt-, copper-, iron-, zinc-, manganese-based nanomaterials [4-6,9]. However, such studies have usually been set-up to focus on one single element (i.e. cobalt, copper, iron, ...), which could be an issue when comparing biological or toxic effects of different materials. Indeed, evaluations should be performed in the context of the same experimental set-up, which allows an efficient comparison of the experimental results and, hence, the establishment of relative toxicity indexes for the different material tested [4]. We therefore performed a study aimed to evaluate the toxic effect of 24 nanoparticles of similar equivalent spherical diameter and various elemental compositions on 2 human cell lines: A549 cell line, representative of alveolar type II cells [10] and Phorbol Myristate Acetate (PMA)-differentiated monocytes to macrophages (THP-1 cell line). These 2 cell types were chosen because they are potential targets of nanomaterials in vivo after inhalation [11]. A secondary aim of the study was to elaborate a generic experimental set-up that would allow the rapid screening of cytotoxic effect of nanomaterials, we compared 2 cytotoxicity assays, based on metabolic activity and membrane permeability (MTT and Neutral Red respectively), and analyzed 2 time points (3 and 24 hours) for each cell type and nanomaterial. Finally, each nanomaterial was analyzed by 2 independent laboratories, out of the 3 different laboratories participating in this study. This work was performed in the framework of Nanosafe2 European project. RESULTS Sensitivity of the different tests Examples of toxicity curves obtained in the different experimental set-up are presented in Figure 1 and Figure 2. As described in the method section, TC50 were only calculated when at least 2 viability values were below 50% of control condition. Otherwise, the nanomaterial was considered as non-toxic in the given experimental set-up. As shown in Table 1, for each experimental set-up, the number of TC50 values that could be calculated, is higher after 24 hours than after 3 hours of incubation. Moreover, at the same time point and with the same cell type, TC50 occurrences were in higher number for MTT than for Neutral Red assay. Finally, when comparing cytotoxicity data obtained for A549 and THP-1 cells, TC50 values were obtained more often when using THP-1 cells than with A549 cells (Table 1). [Figure: Comparative cytotoxicities of Ceria (Panel A and C) and copperoxide (cuprous, Panel B and D) to A549 (Panel A and B) and THP-1 (Panel C and D) cells. In each panel, values were obtained with Neutral Red assay (solid lines) after 3 hours (diamonds) and 24 hours (squares), and with MTT assay (dashed lines) after 3 hours (triangles) and 24 hours (circles).] [Figure: Comparative cytotoxicities of copperoxide (Panel A), nickel oxide (Panel B) and Stainless steel (Panel C) obtained with MTT assay, after exposure of THP-1 cells for 24 hours. In each panel, each individual lab performing the experiment is identified (Lab. A: circles, solid line, Lab. B: triangles, dashed line, Lab. C: squares, light dashed line).] [Table: Number of calculated TC50 values] A similar trend is found in each lab, as shown in Figure 2. To illustrate inter-laboratory reproducibility, typical cytotoxicity curves obtained with MTT assay after 24 hours of THP-1 cells exposure to 3 different nanomaterials are shown in Figure 2. From this figure and data reported in Table 1 and additional file 1, additional file 2, additional file 3, additional file 4, additional file 5, additional file 6 and additional file 7, it is clear that for highly toxic or not toxic materials, inter-laboratory reproducibility is good, with TC50 values very similar for toxic nanomaterials. However, these data also highlight that