Decision-making in structure solution using Bayesian estimates of map quality: the PHENIX AutoSol wizard.
Terwilliger TC, Adams PD, Read RJ, McCoy AJ, Moriarty NW, Grosse-Kunstleve RW, Afonine PV, Zwart PH, Hung LW. · 2009
Read Decision-making in structure solution using Bayesian estimates of map quality: the PHENIX AutoSol wizard. by Terwilliger TC, Adams PD, Read RJ, McCoy AJ, Moriarty NW, Grosse-Kunstleve RW, Afonine PV, Zwart PH, Hung LW. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2685735.txt.
Introduction
Terwilliger and colleagues improved in 2009 the way crystallography software judges its own work while solving protein structures. To read a protein's shape from X-ray data, scientists build an electron-density map, a cloud picture of the molecule. Automated solving makes choice after choice, and each choice needs a reliable score for how good the current map is.
The team tested ten candidate scores against known answers. The winner was skewness, a measure of how lopsided the density values are; good maps skew in a characteristic way. They wrapped that score in a Bayesian method, which weighs new evidence against prior expectation, inside the PHENIX AutoSol wizard. The wizard now picks paths and stops bad branches with better judgment. Sharper self-scoring matters because structure solving is increasingly done by software alone, overnight, on hundreds of targets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Terwilliger TC, Adams PD, Read RJ, McCoy AJ, Moriarty NW, Grosse-Kunstleve RW, Afonine PV, Zwart PH, Hung LW. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2009 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Decision-making in structure solution using Bayesian estimates of map quality: the PHENIX AutoSol wizard By Thomas C Terwilliger, Paul D Adams, Randy J Read, Airlie J McCoy, Nigel W Moriarty, Ralf W Grosse-Kunstleve, Pavel V Afonine, Peter H Zwart, Li-Wei Hung Published in: Acta Crystallographica Section D: Biological Crystallography DOI: 10.1107/S0907444909012098 ABSTRACT Ten measures of experimental electron-density-map quality are examined and the skewness of electron density is found to be the best indicator of actual map quality. A Bayesian approach to estimating map quality is developed and used in the PHENIX AutoSol wizard to make decisions during automated structure solution. Keywords: structure solution, scoring, Protein Data Bank, phasing, decision-making, PHENIX, experimental electron-density maps INTRODUCTION Structure solution in macromolecular crystallography is a multi-step procedure in which more than one plausible possibility often exists at the conclusion of each step. At the start of the process, one or more MAD, SAD, SIR or MIR data sets are collected and reduced to a list of indices and structure-factor amplitudes (Leslie, 1992 ▶; Kabsch, 1993 ▶; Otwinowski & Minor, 1997 ▶; Pflugrath, 1999 ▶). Even at this stage there are often several possibilities for the space group that must be considered. For each possible space group, the process continues with finding a substructure containing heavy atoms or anomalously scattering atoms (Grosse-Kunstleve & Adams, 2003 ▶; Schneider & Sheldrick, 2002 ▶; Terwilliger & Berendzen, 1999a ▶,b ▶; Weeks et al., 2003 ▶). There is often more than one plausible substructure at this stage. For example, in space groups that are not chiral the two possible hands of the substructure cannot normally be distinguished. Furthermore, for MAD data sets there may be alternative solutions found by searching for the substructure using different data sets (from various wavelengths or combining data from different wavelengths using F A values; Terwilliger, 1994 ▶). Similarly, for MIR data sets there may also be substructures found for several different derivatives. In addition to these intrinsic possibilities, it is possible that more than one set of parameters or even more than one set of software might be used to generate possible solutions. The potential heavy-atom substructures found are then used to calculate the phases of structure factors, which are in turn used as the starting point for density modification (Wang, 1985 ▶) and subsequent model building (e.g. Perrakis et al., 1999 ▶; Terwilliger et al., 2008 ▶). Normally, one of the best indications of map quality is that the map can be interpreted in terms of an atomic model. If every possibility at every stage were investigated fully by calculating maps, carrying out density modification and model building, the process might take many hours or days to complete. To speed up the process, the possibilities at each stage are generally ranked, with only the highest ranked possibilities being considered for the next step. This approach can be efficient, but if it is to yield the best solution at the end it requires a reliable method for deciding which members of a set of solutions are of the highest quality. The definition of ‘quality’ when applied to electron-density maps normally refers to the correlation between the values of electron density in the map and the values of electron density in a hypothetical ‘true’ map for the same structure. In this work, when tests are carried out to assess various measures of map quality, the ‘true’ quality or map correlation is calculated between the map in question and a map obtained using measured amplitudes but with phases calculated from a refined model of the corresponding structure. Maps that have a high map correlation as defined in this way are generally more useful for model building and interpretation than those with a low map correlation. However, it should be noted that map correlation is not a perfect way to assess the utility of a map, as low-resolution terms are generally stronger and therefore have a higher relative contribution to the correlation than high-resolution terms, while the high-resolution terms are generally essential for the interpretation of a map. Consequently, a map could have a moderately high correlation to a model map, based largely on low-resolution terms, yet not be interpretable. A number of methods for evaluating the quality of experimental macromolecular electron-density maps have been developed. The methods can generally be grouped into real-space calculations and reciprocal-space calculations. Real-space methods are based on an examination of the electron-density map and generally answer the question ‘Does this map look like an electron-density map of a macromolecule?’ There are many distinctive features of macromolecular electron-density maps that can be used to answer this question. A good map may be expected to have continuous chains of density (Baker et al., 1993 ▶). It may have local patterns of density that reflect shapes and interatomic spacings common to macromolecules (Colovos et al., 2000 ▶; Terwilliger, 2003 ▶). It may have a distribution of electron densities with a positive skewness, reflecting the large number of points with moderate or low electron density, the lack of points with negative density and the points with very positive electron density located near atoms in the structure (Podjarny, 1976 ▶; Lunin, 1993 ▶). There may be a large variation (contrast) in the local r.m.s.d. of electron density, reflecting regions of the structure containing the macromolecule (with high local variation) and solvent (with low local variation; Terwilliger & Berendzen, 1999a ▶; Sheldrick, 2002 ▶). The contiguous nature of the regions of relatively flat solvent may be detected from the correlation of local r.m.s.d. at one point in a map with that at neighboring points (Terwilliger & Berendzen, 1999b ▶). If noncrystallographic symmetry is present in the structure, then the correlation of NCS-related density can be detected (Cowtan & Main, 1998 ▶; Vellieux et al., 1995 ▶; Terwilliger, 2002a ▶). Reciprocal-space methods for evaluation of map quality generally address questions involving structure factors and expectations about the structure such as the model for the solvent region or for the heavy-atom substructure. One such question is simply ‘Given the anomalously scattering atom model and the observed data, what is the expected correlation between the experimental map and the true map?’ The value of the figure of merit of phasing (Blow & Crick, 1959 ▶; Terwilliger & Berendzen, 1999a ▶,b ▶), when estimated correctly, is similar in magnitude to the correlation between the experimental and true maps and can be used as an estimate of this correlation. Another question addresses the data and the expectations about the electron-density map: ‘Is the amplitude of each structure factor consistent with the value expected based on the amplitudes and phases of all other reflections and the model of the solvent region?’ This question can be answered based on the R factor in the first cycle of density modification (which reflects the agreement between each measured amplitude and an estimate of that amplitude based on all other amplitudes and phases along with expectations about features in the map; Cowtan & Main, 1996 ▶; Terwilliger, 2001 ▶). A related question can be asked about the phases: ‘If a phase is estimated from the model of the solvent region, measured amplitudes of structure factors and the experimental values of all other phases, is this phase