Widespread genomic signatures of natural selection in hominid evolution.

McVicker G, Gordon D, Davis C, Green P. · 2009

Read Widespread genomic signatures of natural selection in hominid evolution. by McVicker G, Gordon D, Davis C, Green P. (2009) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2669884.txt.

Introduction

McVicker and colleagues measured in 2009 how strongly natural selection has shaped the genomes of humans and their primate kin. Selection leaves a shadow: when it removes harmful variants near a useful gene, neutral variation nearby drops too. The team compared human variation and differences among five primate species against maps of conserved DNA stretches.

Near those conserved stretches, neutral diversity fell sharply. Across the whole genome, selection had cut average diversity by roughly a fifth to a quarter on the regular chromosomes. The effect ran stronger still on the X chromosome, and strongest of all near gene parts that code for proteins. The pattern fits background selection, the steady weeding of harmful changes in ancestral populations. Long-term selection, they conclude, explains the patchy divergence between humans and chimpanzees better than tangled histories of splitting populations.

Catalog record

CREATORMcVicker G, Gordon D, Davis C, Green P.
YEAR2009
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2669884

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Widespread Genomic Signatures of Natural Selection in Hominid Evolution By Graham McVicker, David Gordon, Colleen Davis, Phil Green, Michael W. Nachman Published in: PLoS Genetics DOI: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1000471 ABSTRACT Selection acting on genomic functional elements can be detected by its indirect effects on population diversity at linked neutral sites. To illuminate the selective forces that shaped hominid evolution, we analyzed the genomic distributions of human polymorphisms and sequence differences among five primate species relative to the locations of conserved sequence features. Neutral sequence diversity in human and ancestral hominid populations is substantially reduced near such features, resulting in a surprisingly large genome average diversity reduction due to selection of 19–26% on the autosomes and 12–40% on the X chromosome. The overall trends are broadly consistent with “background selection” or hitchhiking in ancestral populations acting to remove deleterious variants. Average selection is much stronger on exonic (both protein-coding and untranslated) conserved features than non-exonic features. Long term selection, rather than complex speciation scenarios, explains the large intragenomic variation in human/chimpanzee divergence. Our analyses reveal a dominant role for selection in shaping genomic diversity and divergence patterns, clarify hominid evolution, and provide a baseline for investigating specific selective events. INTRODUCTION The action of natural selection on genome sequences is most directly revealed by a deficit or excess of substitutions relative to the neutral rate, but detecting this requires sequences that have been diverging long enough to experience a high density of mutations [1]. An alternative approach, applicable over shorter evolutionary time periods, is to look for indirect effects of selection on neutral sequence variation [2],[3]. Directional selection reduces population diversity at linked neutral sites by eliminating chromosomes bearing a less fit variant from the population, an effect known as ‘hitchhiking’ in the case of positive selection [3] and ‘background selection’ in the case of negative or purifying selection [2],[4],[5]. The magnitude of the diversity reduction depends upon the density of selected sites, the amount of time during which selected variants segregate in the population prior to fixation or loss, and the rate at which recombination decouples neutral sites from selected variants [2],[4],[5]. In Drosophila a positive correlation between recombination rate and nucleotide diversity is well established and there is strong evidence for background selection or hitchhiking [2], [4], [6]–[10]. In hominid evolution, the roles of background selection and hitchhiking are less certain. Human diversity is positively correlated with recombination on a large scale [11]–[13] and negatively correlated with coding sequence density [14], consistent with a role for selection in recent human evolution. However, whole genome scans have identified relatively few regions with convincing evidence of positive selection [15],[16], an important role for background selection has generally been discounted [5],[17],[18], and it has been suggested that the association with recombination may reflect a mutagenic effect rather than selection [11],[17]. Consequently a clear picture of the importance and nature of selection in human evolution is still lacking. Here we conduct a broader and more systematic search for signatures of selection. We look more widely in hominid evolution, augmenting human polymorphism data [19],[20] with orthologous sequences for five primate species ([21] and our laboratory) (Figure 1). The latter sequences carry information about ancient population diversity, because some sequence differences between any two species represents polymorphic variation that existed in their common ancestral population [22]. [Figure: Species and populations analyzed.Ancestral effective population sizes, N, and interspeciation times in generations, T, were estimated by fitting a model of selection to five-primate sequence data (Table 1 contains all parameter estimates). Parameter values were calibrated by assuming human/chimpanzee speciation occurred 240,000 generations ago; a different calibration would multiply all values by a constant factor. The times between speciation in millions of years (MY) are shown in parentheses, assuming a constant generation time of 25 years. The old world monkey/great ape divergence time is older than suggested by the fossil record [82], but can potentially be explained by generation times that have increased during hominid evolution or a more recent human/chimpanzee speciation time than was used for calibration.] RESULTS/DISCUSSION We used mammalian sequence conservation to identify two classes of genomic segments: “conserved” segments, which appear to be under long-term purifying selection, and “neutral” segments which are putatively free of selective constraint. Specifically, we employed a phylogenetic Hidden Markov Model (HMM) [23], which we extended to improve sensitivity by incorporating information from alignment gaps. We ran the HMM on a multiple alignment of placental mammals [24], but intentionally excluded data from the great apes (including human) and rhesus macaque to avoid biasing our subsequent analysis of sequence divergence in these species. Less than one-fourth of conserved bases identified by this approach are protein-coding, with the remainder largely of unknown function [23]; moreover, conserved segments are much more uniformly distributed in the genome than coding sequences, with most genomic bases surprisingly close to a conserved site (Figure 2). Thus it is desirable to take into account the detailed genomic distribution of all conserved sequences, and not just coding sequences, in investigating the effects of selection on diversity. Using sequence conservation rather than existing gene annotations has the advantage that it is unbiased by assumptions about which annotated features are functional. [Figure: Most genomic bases are near a conserved segment.Plots show the percentage of the genome that is within a given distance of a conserved segment (solid curve) or protein coding sequence (broken curve). (A) Physical distances. (B) Genetic distances according to a fine-scale recombination map [25].] We next compared levels of variation at putative neutral sites in the 10% of the genome nearest to conserved segments, to that in the 50% of the genome farthest from such segments, hypothesizing that selection should have a reduced effect on more distant regions. Human diversity and human/chimpanzee (H/C) divergence are indeed both substantially reduced near conserved segments, and using genetic instead of physical distance magnifies this effect (Figure 3). An even stronger reduction in neutral divergence and diversity is observed if distances are calculated with respect to annotated exons rather than conserved segments, suggesting that selection acting on exonic sequences has a greater effect on nearby diversity than selection on non-exonic conserved sequences. The effect is not limited to sites which are closest to exons; across the genome, H/C divergence exhibits a strong dependency on distance from conserved exonic segments (Figure 4, Table S1). Somewhat surprisingly, a fine-scale recombination map that incorporates ‘hotspot’ patterns [25] provides significantly better discrimination than a coarse pedigree-based map [26], even though many hotspots have moved in recent evolution [27],[28]. This suggests the finescale map may be more accurate than the pedigree map at smaller scales despite the hotspot movement. [Figure: Human diversity, interspecies divergence and HG and CG sites are reduced near evolutionarily conserved segments.(A) Ratios calculated using the 10% of neutral sites which are nearest to and the 50% of neutral sites farthest away from conserved segments or exons. (B) The same ratios as (A) but normalized by human/macaque (H/M) divergence to account for mutation rate variation or undetected sites under purifying selection. The distance to the nearest conserved segment or exon was determined using four different measures: physical distance, pedigree-based recombination distance [26], polymorphism-based finescale recombination distance [25] and the background selection parameter, B. B (described in the

Read the complete text