Cyclic and sleep-like spontaneous alternations of brain state under urethane anaesthesia.
Clement EA, Richard A, Thwaites M, Ailon J, Peters S, Dickson CT. · 2008
Read Cyclic and sleep-like spontaneous alternations of brain state under urethane anaesthesia. by Clement EA, Richard A, Thwaites M, Ailon J, Peters S, Dickson CT. (2008) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2289875.txt.
Introduction
Clement and co-workers recorded brain activity in 2008 in rats under urethane anaesthesia and found sleep-like state cycles. Sleep alternates between activated REM and quiet slow-wave stages. Most anaesthetics instead impose one uniform slow-wave state, suggesting anaesthesia differs fundamentally. The team made long, multi-site forebrain recordings in urethane-anaesthetised rats and tracked muscle tone, breathing and heart rate alongside the electrical patterns.
The rats' brains spontaneously alternated between activated and deactivated patterns in a cycle of about eleven minutes. Individual states and transitions closely resembled the natural REM and non-REM cycle in their electrical components and timing. Muscle tone, respiration and heart rate covaried exactly as in sleep. The alternations also shared sleep's sensitivity to cholinergic drugs and its dependence on basal forebrain activity. Urethane thus mimics the full spectrum of natural sleep.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Clement EA, Richard A, Thwaites M, Ailon J, Peters S, Dickson CT. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2008 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 80 KB |
| LICENSE | CC BY 4.0 |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cyclic and Sleep-Like Spontaneous Alternations of Brain State Under Urethane Anaesthesia By Elizabeth A. Clement, Alby Richard, Megan Thwaites, Jonathan Ailon, Steven Peters, Clayton T. Dickson, Ernest Greene Published in: PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0002004 ABSTRACT Background Although the induction of behavioural unconsciousness during sleep and general anaesthesia has been shown to involve overlapping brain mechanisms, sleep involves cyclic fluctuations between different brain states known as active (paradoxical or rapid eye movement: REM) and quiet (slow-wave or non-REM: nREM) stages whereas commonly used general anaesthetics induce a unitary slow-wave brain state. Methodology/Principal Findings Long-duration, multi-site forebrain field recordings were performed in urethane-anaesthetized rats. A spontaneous and rhythmic alternation of brain state between activated and deactivated electroencephalographic (EEG) patterns was observed. Individual states and their transitions resembled the REM/nREM cycle of natural sleep in their EEG components, evolution, and time frame (∼11 minute period). Other physiological variables such as muscular tone, respiration rate, and cardiac frequency also covaried with forebrain state in a manner identical to sleep. The brain mechanisms of state alternations under urethane also closely overlapped those of natural sleep in their sensitivity to cholinergic pharmacological agents and dependence upon activity in the basal forebrain nuclei that are the major source of forebrain acetylcholine. Lastly, stimulation of brainstem regions thought to pace state alternations in sleep transiently disrupted state alternations under urethane. Conclusions/Significance Our results suggest that urethane promotes a condition of behavioural unconsciousness that closely mimics the full spectrum of natural sleep. The use of urethane anaesthesia as a model system will facilitate mechanistic studies into sleep-like brain states and their alternations. In addition, it could also be exploited as a tool for the discovery of new molecular targets that are designed to promote sleep without compromising state alternations. INTRODUCTION Sleep is a condition of altered consciousness in which there is a reduction of sensory awareness, behavioural output and metabolic activity. Sleep is expressed as a circadian rhythm under neural control and appears to be essential for survival [1]. Although sleep takes up a significant portion of our biological existence, its functional purpose (both ecological and physiological) remains unclear. One of the fundamental mysteries of sleep is the production of brain state alternations, i.e., the REM/nREM cycle. Sleep in mammals and birds involves two main stages as measured by field potential (EEG) recordings: 1) quiet, slow-wave, or nREM sleep, which is characterized by large-amplitude and slow cortical rhythms; and 2) active or REM sleep, which is characterized by low-amplitude and faster cortical rhythms. The latter stage is also known as paradoxical sleep since the EEG patterns are similar to those present during the alert awake state. Alternations between nREM and REM sleep occur at regular intervals throughout a continuous sleep episode. The functional relevance of these stages and their alternations is unknown, although depriving subjects of either stage can induce detrimental effects independent of sleep loss itself, and a rebound amount of time spent in the deprived state in subsequent sleep episodes [1]–[5]. Although progress towards an understanding of 1) the mechanisms, and 2) the functional relevance of state dependent patterns of brain activity and their alternations in sleep has certainly been made since their discovery in 1953 [6], research in the field has been made difficult by the lack of a model of sleep state alternations other than sleep itself. For certain experimental paradigms the naturally sleeping animal presents both technical and ethical obstacles. This has undoubtedly limited our scientific progress in this field. The most common model for sleep has been anaesthesia, which produces a behavioural condition not unlike natural sleep [7]. In fact, “sleep” is the most common metaphor or analogy used for anaesthesia by physicians and laypersons alike [8]. The similarities between sleep and anaesthesia include: a subjective loss of consciousness, reduced sensory awareness, and a reduction in behavioural responsiveness. Moreover, recent research has provided evidence that there is a considerable overlap in the physiological mechanisms of anaesthesia and the induction of the sleeping state (reviewed in [9]). Of course, differences between the two conditions are obvious, including the dependence of anaesthesia on circulating levels of pharmacological agents, the inability to rouse anaesthetized subjects and, perhaps most importantly, the lack of cyclical variability of brain states while under the influence of most anaesthetics Here we report that rats anaesthetized with urethane demonstrate spontaneous and cyclical alternations of brain state that resemble sleep state alternations. We systematically evaluated their similarity by comparing their EEG components, evolution, time frame, physiological correlates, pharmacology and dependence upon ascending neuromodulatory brain systems. Our results suggest that the pharmacological action of urethane in the brain closely mimics the physiological mechanism(s) for the maintenance of the natural sleeping state in rats and thus implicates this preparation as a valid model for the investigation of brain mechanisms giving rise to cyclical state alternations. RESULTS Spontaneous and rhythmic brain state alternations under urethane anaesthesia In long term (>45 minute) field (EEG) recordings made from neocortical and hippocampal sites in urethane-anaesthetized rats, a spontaneous and highly regular alternation of electrographic state between activated and deactivated patterns was noted. Activated EEG patterns consisted of low amplitude fast activity at neocortical sites concomitant with theta (rhythmic 3–5 Hz) activity at hippocampal sites while deactivated EEG patterns were characterized by large-amplitude slow oscillatory (∼1 Hz) activity at both neocortical and hippocampal sites (Figure 1A). As previously reported [10], the spontaneous evolution between these states was stereotyped and involved a gradual transition from the activated to the deactivated state (5.23±0.60 minutes, range: 2.75 to 8.58, n = 10) and then a rapid (52±4 s, range: 34 to 78, n = 10) shift back into the activated state (Figure 1B). This cycle repeated itself in a stable and consistent rhythmic fashion as demonstrated by observation of the amplitude fluctuations of long-duration plots of raw EEG traces (Figure 1C) and spectrographic plots computed on the same EEG traces (Figure 1D). Within spectrograms, the highest power fluctuations were centered at a frequency of 1 Hz (especially in the neocortex) so the period and rhythmicity of the alternations were systematically characterized by extracting this frequency band across time (Figure 1E). The precise time points of alternations between states were denoted by calculating a threshold value (corresponding to the saddle of the bimodal distribution of the power at 1 Hz across time) that separated activated from deactivated patterns (values below the threshold were considered to be activated while those above were considered to be deactivated). Autocorrelations of the de-trended power at 1 Hz were highly rhythmic (Figure 1F) and successive periods maintained a consistent duration across time (Figure 1G). This consistency was observed in the vast majority of experiments (38 of 41 see Fig 1H) by showing that least-squares linear fitting of the period durations across time did not result in significant slope values (p>0.05). All of these results were consistent with a systematic and stable cyclic process. [Figure: Urethane anaesthetized animals displayed spontaneous and cyclic alternations of brain state.A) Spectra and raw EEG traces of different spontaneous states under urethane. During the activated state, the nCTX showed low voltage fast activity and the HPC showed prominent theta at ∼4 Hz. During the transition state, there was an increase in overall power with a