Evaluating the successful implementation of evidence into practice using the PARiHS framework: theoretical and practical challenges.

Kitson AL, Rycroft-Malone J, Harvey G, McCormack B, Seers K, Titchen A. · 2008

Read Evaluating the successful implementation of evidence into practice using the PARiHS framework: theoretical and practical challenges. by Kitson AL, Rycroft-Malone J, Harvey G, McCormack B, Seers K, Titchen A. (2008) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2235887.txt.

Introduction

Kitson and co-authors examined the PARiHS framework in 2008, a model for getting research evidence into health practice. PARiHS, short for Promoting Action on Research Implementation (PARiHS) in Health Services, is widely used to frame implementation work. Yet as a concept it remains untested, and its contribution to theory is unquantified. The paper clarifies the difference between a conceptual framework, a theory and a model, borrowing a typology from social policy analysis.

The authors propose using PARiHS in two stages. First, diagnose the evidence and the local context using its elements and sub-elements. Then use those combined scores to choose the most fitting facilitation method. The intervention is thereby shaped by the specific people, place and time. They recommend an international collaborative to collect experiences and test the framework systematically.

Catalog record

CREATORKitson AL, Rycroft-Malone J, Harvey G, McCormack B, Seers K, Titchen A.
YEAR2008
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
LICENSECC BY 4.0
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2235887

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Evaluating the successful implementation of evidence into practice using the PARiHS framework: theoretical and practical challenges By Alison L Kitson, Jo Rycroft-Malone, Gill Harvey, Brendan McCormack, Kate Seers, Angie Titchen Published in: Implementation science : IS DOI: 10.1186/1748-5908-3-1 ABSTRACT Abstract Background The PARiHS framework (Promoting Action on Research Implementation in Health Services) has proved to be a useful practical and conceptual heuristic for many researchers and practitioners in framing their research or knowledge translation endeavours. However, as a conceptual framework it still remains untested and therefore its contribution to the overall development and testing of theory in the field of implementation science is largely unquantified. Discussion This being the case, the paper provides an integrated summary of our conceptual and theoretical thinking so far and introduces a typology (derived from social policy analysis) used to distinguish between the terms conceptual framework, theory and model – important definitional and conceptual issues in trying to refine theoretical and methodological approaches to knowledge translation. Secondly, the paper describes the next phase of our work, in particular concentrating on the conceptual thinking and mapping that has led to the generation of the hypothesis that the PARiHS framework is best utilised as a two-stage process: as a preliminary (diagnostic and evaluative) measure of the elements and sub-elements of evidence (E) and context (C), and then using the aggregated data from these measures to determine the most appropriate facilitation method. The exact nature of the intervention is thus determined by the specific actors in the specific context at a specific time and place. In the process of refining this next phase of our work, we have had to consider the wider issues around the use of theories to inform and shape our research activity; the ongoing challenges of developing robust and sensitive measures; facilitation as an intervention for getting research into practice; and finally to note how the current debates around evidence into practice are adopting wider notions that fit innovations more generally. Summary The paper concludes by suggesting that the future direction of the work on the PARiHS framework is to develop a two-stage diagnostic and evaluative approach, where the intervention is shaped and moulded by the information gathered about the specific situation and from participating stakeholders. In order to expedite the generation of new evidence and testing of emerging theories, we suggest the formation of an international research implementation science collaborative that can systematically collect and analyse experiences of using and testing the PARiHS framework and similar conceptual and theoretical approaches. We also recommend further refinement of the definitions around conceptual framework, theory, and model, suggesting a wider discussion that embraces multiple epistemological and ontological perspectives. BACKGROUND The spread of best practice and the use of best evidence remain sporadic. There continues to be a tension between policy imperatives and the ability to successfully support and enable local developments. Arguably the debate about how to implement evidence effectively reflects a lack of a true appreciation or understanding of the multiple factors involved. However, there has been a shift away from the traditional notion that getting evidence into practice is straightforward. Until relatively recently the spread of evidence was seen as a linear and technical process at the level of the individual, and was described as changes in clinicians' behaviour in line with evidence-based guidelines [1]. Now there is widespread recognition that guideline implementation, and evidence implementation more generally, requires whole system change implicating both the individual and organisation ([2,3]). Despite a growing awareness that getting evidence into practice is a complex, multi-faceted process, there remains a lack of knowledge about what methods and approaches are effective, with whom and in what contexts. The PARiHS framework represents the complexities of implementing evidence into practice. Previous papers have reported on the development of the framework over time [4-9]. Other authors have also reported on their use of PARiHS as a theoretical and practical heuristic to guide research and practice development work [10-14]. This paper integrates our work to date and presents the hypothesis that the PARiHS framework could be applied by practitioners as a diagnostic and evaluative tool to successfully implement evidence into practice, and by practitioners and researchers to evaluate such activity. In addition, the current and future challenges in relation to the PARiHS framework and to the field more generally are identified and discussed. The PARiHS framework – an overview Within the PARiHS framework, successful implementation (SI) is represented as a function (f) of the nature and type of evidence (E), the qualities of the context (C) in which the evidence is being introduced, and the way the process is facilitated (F); SI = f (E, C, F). Detailed descriptions exist in the literature on the development and empirical evaluation of the PARiHS framework [4-9]. The framework has been refined through two phases of research and development and is currently in its third or current phase (see Table 1 for a comprehensive summary). The unique characteristic of the PARiHS framework was that it proposed a three-dimensional framework within which to interpret successful implementation, arguing that elements could be located on a continuum of "high" to "low" evidence and context [Table: Summary of development and refinement steps of PARiHS framework] Summary of the development and refinement steps for PARiHS framework. (See Table 1) The main features and assumptions of the framework are: 1. Evidence encompasses codified and non-codified sources of knowledge, including research evidence, clinical experience including professional craft knowledge, patient preferences and experiences, and local information. 2. Melding and implementing such evidence in practice involves negotiation and developing a shared understanding about the benefits, disbenefits, risks, and advantages of the new over the old. This is a dialectical process that requires careful management and choreography, and one that is not done in isolation; in other words, it is a team effort. 3. Some contexts are more conducive to the successful implementation of evidence into practice than others – these include contexts that have transformational leaders, features of learning organisations, and appropriate monitoring, evaluative, and feedback mechanisms. 4. There is an emphasis on the need for appropriate facilitation to improve the likelihood of success. The type of facilitation, and the role and skill of the facilitator that is required is determined by the "state of preparedness" of an individual or team, in terms of their acceptance and understanding of evidence, the receptivity of their place of work or context in terms of the resources, culture and values, leadership style, and evaluation activity. Facilitators work with individuals and teams to enhance the process of implementation. The objective of the current phase of our work is to build on the concept analysis and clarification undertaken in phases one and two, and to evaluate the current framework through the development and testing of diagnostic and evaluative instruments to assist in the process of knowledge translation. Whilst conducting this phase, a number of challenges have arisen, which, whilst reflecting the particular complexities of the PARiHS framework's development, are also relevant to current debates in the field of knowledge translation. These include: 1. Understanding how the conceptual framework relates to, and informs the development of, integrated theoretical positions that are practically useful and theoretically robust. 2. Engaging in the challenges

Read the complete text