GEOTROPIC ORIENTATION IN ARTHROPODS : I. MALACOSOMA LARVAE.
Crozier WJ, Stier TJ. · 1928
Read GEOTROPIC ORIENTATION IN ARTHROPODS : I. MALACOSOMA LARVAE. by Crozier WJ, Stier TJ. (1928) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2141013.txt.
Introduction
Tent caterpillars climbing a tilted surface do not head straight up, and W. J. Crozier and T. J. B. Stier measure the angle they actually take. Their 1928 study from Harvard follows Malacosoma americana larvae as they crawl on planes set at different inclines, opening a series on gravity orientation in arthropods.
The path angle upward grows in proportion to the logarithm of the sine of the incline, and the product of the two sines stays constant. The authors trace this to the swinging of the head from side to side during crawling, which varies the pull on muscles along the upper side of the body. Readers get a precise, measured account of how a simple animal steers against gravity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Crozier WJ, Stier TJ. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1928 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
GEOTROPIC ORIENTATION IN ARTHROPODS By W. J. Crozier, T. J. B. Stier Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.11.6.803 ABSTRACT The geotropic orientation of caterpillars of Malacosoma americana during progression upon a surface inclined at angle α to the horizontal is such that the path makes an average angle θ upward on the plane, of a magnitude proportional to log sin α. More precisely, the product (sin α) (sin θ) is constant. This is traced to the fluctuation of the pull of the head region upon the lateral musculature of the upper side during the side to side swinging implicated in progression. GEOTROPIC ORIENTATION IN ARTHROPODS. I. MALACOSOMAL A R V A E . BYW. J. CROZIERAXDT. J. B. STIER. (From the Laboratory of General Physiology, Harvard University, Cambridge.) (Acceptedfor publication,March30, 1928.) I Quantitative description of geotropic orientation as controlled by the magnitude of the effective component of gravity has been obtained for several animals, including young rats (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27, a; 1926-27, c; Pincus, 1926-27), mice (Crozier and Oxnard, 1927-28; Keeler, 1927-28), slugs (Wolf, 1926-27; Wolf and Crozier, 1927-28, a), and certain others. The interpretation of these descriptions in terms of the processes of excitation which limit the extent of the orientation must be checkedthrough experiments with other organisms, in which particular features of the orientation effect may be separately studied. This is especially the case when it is desired to utilize the descriptions for the investigation of behavior in compound fields oi excitation (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27, b; Wolf and Crozier, 1927-28; Crozier and Stier, 1927-28). Ideally, adequate mathematical de- scription must be based upon understanding of the mechanisms governing the orientation. In the nature of the case, these two aspects of the interpretation cannot be approached in ways entirely independent. But by careful examination of structurally diverse animals, creeping in quite different ways, means may be found for the critical testing of the several orientation formul~e. In this connection the distinction must be kept in mind between formulae which may be empirically adequate and of a type convenient to handle, and rational equations based upon a theory of the controlling mechanism. Thus a linear relationship has been found, with several forms, between log sin o~and 0, where a = the inclination of the creep- ing plane above the horizontal and 8 = the angle of upward orienta- 803 The Journal of General Physiology 804 GEOTI~.OPISM OF INSECTS tion on the plane (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27, a; 1926-27, b; Crozier and Oxnard, 1927-28; Wolf, 1926-27). The fit is very good except at quite low values of a. No one would consider the agreement more than an empirically useful one, and as such it has been employed (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27, b). Yet, in a paper containing a variety of other and more curious misapprehensions, Hunter (1927) states that we have found the relationship between a and ~ "to follow Weber's Law," although in the paper referred to (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27, a, p. 264) explicit caution against such an idea was quite definite. While certain formulations, of the logarithmic type for example, must not be taken to have more than a useful share of significance, it is important for the uses to which they may be put to demonstrate that they do not result merely from accidents of averaging data as obtained from a number of tested individuals. For this reason we have in crucial cases depended upon data from tests with a few really comparable individuals, although stating (Crozier and Pincus, 1926-27a, b) that these were cited as illustrative. But proof is given by the fact that with other organisms, where the mechanics of creeping and the possible manner of the limitation of its direction are obviously different, these logarithmic expressions do not apply. II. In the experiments already referred to it was found that on a plane inclined at angle a to the horizontal the upward orientation of the actively creeping geosensitive organism is limited to a zone defined on either side by an average angle Oon the plane (cf. Fig. 1). The path describing the angle 0 is the limiting position for stable progres- sion. The magnitude of this angle is, for first approximation, linearly related to the logarithm of the active gravitational component on the plane, so that 40 corot. (1) log sin The precise form of the relationship, and its meaning, will be examined in another place. It is possible to show, also, that in particular cases the striking of the angle 0 is determined by the achievement of a w. j. CROZn~R AND T. 2[. B. stria 805 threshold difference between the downward pull of the body upon the musculature of the two sides. Thus in the slug Agriolimax (Wolf, 1926-27) it is sufficient to assume that the downward pull of elements of the body mass upon corresponding longitudinal elements of the parietal musculature at the anterior end of the animal becomes so adjusted, at orientation, that the difference in the tensions produced on the two sides is reduced to a constant value. This requires that the longitudinal elements affected be mutually inclined, and at a constant angle (2 h). The trigonometric expression to which these assumptions lead is adequately verified (Wolf, 1926-27); it states that when the limiting angle (0) is reached and maintained, (4 sin a )(4 sin 0) = corot., (2) and it assumes that the "head angle," 2 h, is constant; this assumption might be tested by experiments with larger slugs (e.g.,Limax) when forced to carry added loads. Another method of investigation is to employ an animal in which the "head angle" is not structurally determined, but is conditioned by the side to side swinging of the anterior end during progression, and in which the amplitude of such swings may be seen to vary. The tent caterpillar Malacosoma americana, and certain other larva~, provide suitable material. The negative geotropism of such beetles as Taraopes letra@thalmus affords a quite different situation for comparison, and the successfully descriptive formulae, whether arrived at as empirical approximations or analytically, are totally dissimilar. We will consider first the evidence from Malacosomalarva~. III. The experiments are very simple, and for that reason require considerable care. Each caterpillar, from a nest maintained on a branch of wild-cherry in the laboratory, is repeatedly caused to creep upon an inclined plane. In successive groups of "runs" of observations the inclination of the plane is altered. The surface is covered with ~oarse textured paper, affording a good foothold. The larva is started head downward, or with the axis horizontal, and its path is traced by gentle application of a soft pencil to the paper just behind the moving animal. The tests are made in a ventilated 806 GEOTROPISM OF INSECTS dark room, under very weak non-directive red light. This is neces- sary, as during the periods, of the day involved in the tests directive white light of low intensity suffices to overcome the geotropic effect; to this aspect of the matter we expect later to return. Suitable tests showed that the location of the observer did not influence the trails made; a possible influence of his breathing currents was excluded by an appropriate screen. Tests