THE ACTIVATION OF STARFISH EGGS BY ACIDS.
Lillie RS. · 1926
Read THE ACTIVATION OF STARFISH EGGS BY ACIDS. by Lillie RS. (1926) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2140768.txt.
Introduction
Ralph Lillie studied the activation of unfertilized starfish eggs by acids in a 1926 paper. Activation means starting the egg developing without sperm. Weak acids in a balanced salt solution, the fatty acids, benzoic acid, and carbonic acid among them, can do it fully, if the exposure lasts just long enough. Lillie measured that best duration across strengths and temperatures.
For each acid, the activation rate varies with concentration and temperature, and over a wide strength range it runs roughly proportional to concentration. Each acid thus has a molecular rate of action. That rate rises in general with the acid's dissociation constant and surface activity. In the fatty series formic acid acts about four times as fast as acetic. Hydrochloric and lactic acids are relatively ineffective.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lillie RS. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1926 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
THE ACTIVATION OF STARFISH EGGS BY ACIDS By Ralph S. Lillie Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.8.4.339 ABSTRACT 1. Exposure of unfertilized starfish eggs to dilute solutions of weak acids (fatty acids, benzoic and carbonic acids) in isotonic balanced salt solution causes complete activation with the proper durations of exposure. For each acid the rate of activation (reciprocal of optimum duration) varies with concentration and temperature; at a given temperature and within a considerable range of concentrations (e.g. 0.00075 to 0.004 M for butyric acid), this rate is approximately proportional to concentration. We may thus speak of a molecular rate of action characteristic of each acid. 2. In general the molecular rate of action increases with the dissociation constant and surface activity of the acids. In the fatty acid series (up to caproic), formic acid has the most rapid effect, acting about four times as rapidly as acetic; for the other acids the order is: acetic = propionic ≦ butyric < valeric < caproic. Carbonic acid acts qualitatively like the fatty acids, but its molecular rate of action is only about one-fourteenth that of acetic acid. 3. Hydrochloric and lactic acids are relatively ineffective as activating agents, apparently because of difficulty of penetration. Lactic acid is decidedly the more effective. The action of both acids is only slightly modified by dissolving in pure (isotonic NaCl and CaCl2) instead of in balanced salt solution. 4. The rate of action of acetic acid, in concentrations of 0.002 M to 0.004 M is increased (by 10 to 20 per cent) by adding Na-acetate (0.002 to 0.016) to the solution. The degree of acceleration is closely proportional to the estimated increase in undissociated acetic acid molecules. Activation thus appears to be an effect of the undissociated acid molecules in the external solution and not of the ions. Acetate anions and H ions acting by themselves, in concentrations much higher than those of the solutions used, have no activating effect. The indications are that the undissociated molecules penetrate rapidly, the ions slowly. Having penetrated, the molecules dissociate inside the egg, yielding the ions of the acid. 5. When the rate of activation is slow, as in 0.001 M acetic acid, the addition of Na-acetate (0,008 M to 0.016 M) has a retarding effect, referable apparently to the gradual penetration of acetate ions to the site of the activation reaction with consequent depression of dissociation. 6. An estimate of the CH of those solutions (of the different activating acids) which activate the egg at the same rate indicates that their H ion concentrations are approximately equal. On the assumptions that only the undissociated molecules penetrate readily, and that the conditions of dissociation are similar inside and outside the egg, this result indicates (especially when the differences in adsorption of the acids are considered) that the rate of activation is determined by the CH at the site of the activation reaction within the egg. THE ACTIVATION OF STARFISH EGGS BY ACIDS. BY RALPHS. LILLIE. (From the Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole, and the Laboratory of GeneralPhysiology, University of Chicago, Chicago.) (Received for publication, February 15, 1926.) INTRODUCTION. In the activation of starfish eggs (Asterias forbesii) by temporary exposure to solutions of fatty acid the essential factors are concentra- tion of acid, duration of exposure, and temperature. In order to effect complete activation at any temperature (within the physiological range) the eggs must be exposed to a given concentration of acid for a time which is definite within somewhat narrow limits. 1 For example, exposure to 0.002 ~ butyric acid (dissolved in balanced non-buffered salt solution) for 12 to 14 minutes at 20C. typically causes all eggs to develop into active free-swimming blastula. If the eggs are ex- posed for a few minutes longer or shorter than this critical time, activation is partial or defective (membrane formation, cleavage slower or less regular than after the optimum exposure), and the eggs cease development and die at an early stage. In general, the rate of activation s by fatty acid, within a range of 0.001 M to 0.005 ~a, is closely proportional to the concentration of acid. The relation be- tween duration of exposure to a given solution and degree of activa- tion may be represented graphically by plotting against the durations the percentages of eggs reaching a free-swimming stage. Any such curve has a time range which varies with temperature in the manner shown (Fig. 1). The position of the optimum is more sharply defined at the high temperatures, and the rate of activation shows a high temperature coefficient which increases rapidly as the temperature approaches 28C.8 At this temperature heat-activation begins to 1Lillie, R. S., Biol: Bull., 1915, xxviii, 260; .1..Biol. Chem., 1916, xxiv, 233. This rate is defined as the reciprocal of the optimum time of exposure. *Lillie, R. S., Biol. Bull., 1917, xxxii, 131. 339 The Journal of General Physiology 340 ACTIVATION OF STARFISH EGGS BY ACIDS appear; it is noteworthy that the rate of heat-activation, within the effective range of temperatures, 28-38C., is almost doubled by each rise of 1,~ a result indicating its dependence on some physical or structural change in the protoplasmic colloids. Complete heat- activation at a given temperature also requires a definite time of ex- posure, and the relations between duration of exposure and degree of activation are closely similar to those found in activation by fatty acid. Heat-activation and acid-activation can in fact be substituted c~nt Z4 22 18 lZ 100 O0 ? 4o 6 80 x ~ / / to / o X 0' l'~i~.0 5 10 15 20 25 80 85 40 45 50 55 FIO. 1. Relation between durations of exposure to butyric acid solution (0.006 dissolved in sea water) and percentages of eggs forming blastulae at different temperatures (Table I, Biol. Bull., 1917, xxxii, 138). Ordinates: percentages of blastulm; abscissae; exposures. for one another, a brief exposure to either heat or butyric acid being used, for example, to complete a previous partial activation by either treatment.4 It seems probable, from the resemblance between the curves correlating degree of activation and duration of exposure in the two cases, that high temperature acts indirectly by freeing acid in certain regions of the egg; i.e., that heat-activation is in reality acid- activation. The latter would thus appear to be the fundamental phenomenon in activation and its conditions demand special study. 4 Cf. Biol. Bull., 1915, xxviii, 284. RALPH S. LILLIE 341 In the Asterias egg acids have a special relation to activation. Bases (ammonia) are entirely ineffective,e It is significant that only the more rapidly penetrating and surface-active acids show the above described definite relation between time of exposure and degree of activation; also, it is only with such acids that complete activation is obtained in a large proportion of eggs. These acids include the fatty acids and other penetrating acids such as benzoic and carbonic acids. The difference between the activating effectiveness of these acids and that of the mineral acids and hydroxy-acids is striking. Hydro- chloric acid is only slightly effective; in numerous experiments with this acid, using concentrations between 0.00075 N and 0.01 N (dis- solved in balanced isotonic salt solution), I found