CONTRASTS IN THE CELL SAP OF VALONIAS AND THE PROBLEM OF FLOTATION.

Osterhout WJ, Dorcas MJ. · 1925

Read CONTRASTS IN THE CELL SAP OF VALONIAS AND THE PROBLEM OF FLOTATION. by Osterhout WJ, Dorcas MJ. (1925) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2140740.txt.

Introduction

Osterhout and Dorcas, at Harvard and The Rockefeller Institute, compared the cell sap of two seaweed Valonia forms in a 1925 paper. The two forms are close kin and grow in similar waters, yet one floats in sea water and the other sinks. Chemical analysis of their sap was set beside that behavior.

The sinking form holds potassium and sodium in one proportion; the floating form holds them in a far different, inverted proportion. The sinker also lacks magnesium, which the floater carries, and other sap differences appear. Those internal differences, the authors show, bring about the contrast in flotation. Two near-identical plants thus run opposite mineral economies side by side.

Catalog record

CREATOROsterhout WJ, Dorcas MJ.
YEAR1925
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2140740

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

CONTRASTS IN THE CELL SAP OF VALONIAS AND THE PROBLEM OF FLOTATION By W. J. V. Osterhout, M. J. Dorcas Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.7.5.633 ABSTRACT The marine alga Valonia macrophysa contains in its cell sap K and Na in the proportion of 5.72 to 1. In a form regarded as closely related, Valonia ventricosa, growing in similar environment, the ratio of K to Na is as 0.0278 to 1. The former contains no Mg but in the latter it is present. There are other differences in the composition of the sap. These differences bring about a remarkable contrast in behavior in that Valonia ventricosa floats in sea water while Valonia macrophysa sinks. CONTRASTS IN THE CELL SAP OF VALONIAS AND THE PROBLEM OF FLOTATION.* BY W. J. V. OSTERttOUT ANDM. J. DORCAS. (From the Laboratory of Plant Physiology, Harvard University, Cambridge, and The Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research.) (Accepted for publication, April 2, 1925.) It has been shown~that the marine alga Valonia macrophysa, Ktitz. collected at Bermuda), has the power to absorb K and to store it up so that its concentration becomes much greater in the cell sap than in the sea water. This is also the case with Valonia utricularis (collected at Naples) according to Meyer and Hansen3 A similar behavior might be expected in other Valonias but the authors find that this is apparently not the case with the large species found at Bermuda which is commonly referred to Valonia ventricosa, J. G. Agardh. 3 Table I gives a comparison of the analyses of Bermuda sea water, and of the saps of V. macrophysa and. V. ventricosa. It will be noted that the proportion of K to Na in V. macro- physa is about 5.72:1 while in V. ventricosa it is about 0.0278:1. * Contributions from The Bermuda Biological Station for Research, No. 149. Osterhout, W. J. V., J. Gen. Physiol., 1922-23, v, 225. There is some doubt regarding the identity of this species. 2Meyer, A., Ber. bot. Ges., 1891, ix, 77. Hansen, A., Mitt. zool. Station Neapel, 1893, xi, 254. Czapek (Czapek, F., Biochemie der Pflanzen, Jena, 2. Auflage, 1920, ii, 353) mentions (without quoting the source) an analysis of V. utricularis in which Na predominates over K but the analysis was presumably made on whole plants and there may have been a good deal of contamination by sea water, as is suggested by the high values for SO,. 3Cf. Collins, F. S., and Hervey, A. B., The algm of Bermuda, Proc. Am. Acad. Arts and So., 1917, liii, 51. Britton, N. L., Flora of Bermuda, New York, 1918. Algm by M. A. Howe. V. ventricosa is cast up on beaches as clear green, balloon- shaped cells sometimes as large as pigeon eggs and is known locally as" sea bottles." In the sun the cells soon bleach and become colorless. 633 The Journal of General Physiology 634 CELL SAP OF VALONIAS AND FLOTATION In the latter the concentrations of Na and K are nearly the same as in sea water. The table shows that Mg, which is absent from V. macrophysa, occurs in V. ventricosa, though in lower concentration than in sea water; Ca is present in both cases but in much lower concentration than in sea water. In both cases NO8 is present although the sea water gives no indica- tion of it by the ring test. In both species the halide content, and osmotic pressure are higher than in sea water.4 The pH of th~ sap is about the same in both, approximately 5.9, while that of the sea water is about 8.2. There is practically no Br, PO,, or SO, in the sap~of intact cells of either species, but SO, begins to diffuse in as soon as injury occurs and this serves as a useful indicator of normal condition. In order to gain an approximate idea of the amount of organic matter the loss on ignition was determined. The procedure employed in the case of V. rnacrophysa1 was followed in the main except that the filtration was omitted on the ground that some Ca and Mg might be retained on the filter as carbonate. The sap was dried to constant weight in an oven at 105C. and ignited just below red heat. Water was added (to replace any water held between the crystals which may have been driven off by ignition) and the residue was again dried to constant weight at 105C. The difference in weight before and after ignition amounted to 2.09 parts per thousand: the corresponding figure obtained by Van der Pyl for V. macrophysa is 1.433 parts per thousand. These striking differences between two species of Valonia raise the question whether it is justifiable to assume, as is often done, that close relationship involves similarity in chemical composition and 4Determinations of conductivity were made by Mr. L. R. Blinks who found that the conductivityof the sap of V. ventricosato be about the sameas that ofsea water. In V. macrophysa,however,the conductivity is about 20 per cent higher than that ofseawater, as is to be expectedin viewof the largerproportion ofKC1, whichhas a higher specificconductivity than NaCI. 5Freshly collectednormal cells show only a trace of turbidity whenBaC12is added to the acidifiedsap: this very slight turbidity may be due to the precipita- tion of organic matter. W. J. V. OSTERHOUT AND M. .]'. DORCAS 635 metabolic processes. The implications of this question are far reaching. If it is possible for nearly allied forms to differ so profoundly it is evident that we have as yet no satisfactory conception of the nature of the variables involved in differentiation or in the develop- ment of specific characters. These differences suggest another question of considerable im- TABLE 1.* Molecular Composition Expressed as Per Cent of Halide (Cl + Br). C1+ Br? ............................... . Na ..................................... K ....................................... i Ca ...................................... i SO4 ..................................... Bermuda Sap of Valonla Sap of Valonia sea water, macrophysa, ventricosa. 100.00 85.87 2.15 205 974 6.26 100.00 15.08 86.24 0.2~13 Trace ? Trace ? 100.00 92.80 2.58 1.36 2.49 Trace ? * The figures for sea water and for the sap of V. macrophysa are based upon the results of L. M. Van der Pyl (cf. Osterhout, W. J. V., J. Gen.Physiol., 1922-23, v, 225). The methods described in that paper were followed in the work on V. ventricosa except that the halide was determined volumetrically and the Ca, after separation as oxalate, was determined by titrating against KMnO4, instead of gravimetrically. In the table the sea water appears to have an excess of anions over cations of 0.825 per cent (each bivalent ion being counted as two univalent ions): this is due in part to the fact that the halide was determined gravimetrically and called CI, no account being taken of the Br present, Which in molar terms is approxi- mately 0.14 per cent of the C1. This procedure would make the C1appear too great (owing to the greater atomic weight of Br). On the other hand no account was taken of carbonates. In the sap of V. macrophysa the table shows an excess of cations amounting to 1.9 per cent; in the case of V. ventricosa

Read the complete text