EXPERIMENTS ON TOLERATION OF TEMPERATURE BY DROSOPHILA.
Plough HH, Strauss MB. · 1923
Read EXPERIMENTS ON TOLERATION OF TEMPERATURE BY DROSOPHILA. by Plough HH, Strauss MB. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2140625.txt.
Introduction
Harold Plough and Maurice Strauss tested temperature tolerance in fruit flies in a 1923 paper. Stocks of Drosophila melanogaster from many places were bred on banana agar at a steady high temperature, and mutant stocks and other species were tried the same way. The question was which flies can live and breed at heat that others cannot.
Most wild stocks bred indefinitely at the high temperature, with no link between their home climate and their tolerance. One wild stock managed only one generation above a lower ceiling, a difference that looks genetic. Mutant stocks also failed after one generation at the heat, an effect the authors tie to any mutant gene present in double dose. Among other species, two northern forms failed while tropical kinds bred on.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Plough HH, Strauss MB. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 1923 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| LICENSE | Public Domain |
| RIGHTS | PUBLIC DOMAIN |
| SOURCE | Europe PMC |
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EXPERIMENTS ON TOLERATION OF TEMPERATURE BY DROSOPHILA By Harold H. Plough, Maurice B. Strauss Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.6.2.167 ABSTRACT 1. Most wild stocks of Drosophila melanogaster can be bred indefinitely on banana agar at a temperature of 31°C. There is no relation between the geographical origin of these stocks and their ability to tolerate this temperature. 2. A single wild stock has been found which will breed for only one generation at temperatures above 29°C. The offspring hatched at 31°C. will breed normally at 24°C. This difference from other wild stocks is apparently genetic, but its genetic basis has not yet been worked out. 3. The mutant stocks of D. melanogaster tested by us will breed for only one generation at 31°C. and their offspring at this temperature are also fertile at 24°C. This condition is apparently a physiological effect of the presence of any of the mutant genes in a homozygous condition. 4. Similar tests indicate that wild stocks of D. virilis and Chymomyza procnemis will breed at 31°C., while D. simulans, D. immigrans, and D. funebris will not. The last two species are northern forms not commonly found in the tropics. 5. Both male and female flies from mutant stocks hatched at 31°C. produce offspring at this temperature if mated to flies hatched at 24°C. Their germ cells are therefore capable of development, and the cause of their failure to develop at 31°C. when inbred must lie either in the failure of the germ cells to reach each other or in the fertilization process itself. EXPERIMENTS ON TOLERATION OF TEMPERATURE BY DROSOPHILA. BY HAROLD H. PLOUGH AI~-D MAURICE B. STRAUSS. (From the Biological laboratory of Amherst College,Amherst.) (Received for publication, August 1, 1923.) In connection with experiments by one of us on the effect of high temperature on the amount of crossing over in Drosophilait became obvious that differences exist among various cultures of this fly in the ability to withstand temperatures above the normal range and in the ability to breed at these temperatures. A series of compara- tive tests was therefore undertaken in order to gain more accurate information along these lines. Experiments on a single culture of Drosophilamelanogaster,grown on sterile yeast medium, were reported by Northrop I in 1920. He wished to find out whether the offspring of cultures kept at high temperatures acquired the ability to tolerate temperatures still higher. He found that no such adaptation occurred, and that fries could be carried at temperatures above 29C. for one generation only. These flies would however breed normally according to his findings if returned to normal temperatures for a period of 24 hours. Since Northrop's work was upon a single stock of Drosophilaonly, it seemed of interest to us to determine whether there was not a difference in the upper temperature limit among different cultures of Drosophila, which might be genetically determined. Our work indicates that with optimum food conditions it is only the exceptional stock of Drosophilamdanogasterwhich will not breed at 31C. Furthermore our work suggests the basis for the failure to breed at high temperatures as observed by Northrop and by our- selves. t Northrop, J. H., d. Gen. PhysioL, 1919-20, if, 313. 167 The Journal of General Physiology 168 TOLERATION OF TEMPERATURE BY DI~OSOPI-IILA Our tests were carried on in electrically controlled bacteriological incubators. While by no means as constant as the apparatus used by Northrop, these were sufficiently so for all practical purposes. Checks were run on certain of the experiments in a water bath used in the Department of Chemistry which varied less than 0.1C., with identical results in each case. The control incubator was carried at approximately 24C. Most of the high temperature tests were made at 31C. Approximate records of the limits of variation of these incubators were kept with Taylor maximum and minimum thermometers, and these showed variations of less than lon either side. In the case of the high temperature tests, Northrop ~ and Plough2have indicated that 29C. was the critical temperature, which our experiment confirms, and our present material was constantly above this point in the high temperature work. The medium used for the cultures was the usual banana agar, made up in fairly large quantifies, placed in bottles, and kept in a refrigera- tor until used. A pinch of powdered magic yeast was dropped in each bottle before the paper and the flies were introduced. This medium, if carefully made and used within 2 or 3 days, gives far larger numbers of flies than the sterile solution of Northrop. The cultures are practically uniform and the conditions closer to those in the wild state. EXPERIMENTAL. Our first tests were made with a number of different cultures of Drosophila rnelanogaster collected from various widely separated regions. Following this series we tested a number of mutant stocks and wild stocks of several other species of Drosophila. Table I gives the results of these tests and also the source of the stocks tested. In general these tests were made with two bottles of each stock con- taining about three pairs of flies apiece. Whenever a test culture failed to develop, however, it was repeated at least once, so that each negative result represents at least four bottles tried. Geographically Different Races of Drosophila melanogaster. The data given in the table show in general that wild stocks of Drosophila 2Plough, H. H., J. Exp. Zool.,1917-18,xxiv, 147. H. H. PLOUGH AND M. B. STRAUSS 169 melanogaster can be bred for indefinite periods at a temperature of 31C. on banana agar. The stocks from Amherst, Georgia, and Sweden were carried for eight, ten, and eleven generations before they were lost and it is very probable that more careful methods, with a larger number of separate cultures would make it possible to carry them indefinitely. At 31C. the flies begin to hatch within 8 days. They are smaller than under optimum conditions and some- what less viable. All of these conditions appear to be due to the hastening of development with the result that the larva~ take in less food. Up to 31C. there is no evidence that the stocks cited show any effects which make breeding beyond the second generation im- possible as Northrop states. In the case of the Devil's Lake stock no difficulty was experienced in carrying the flies for fourteen genera- tions and the stock was only discontinued at that point because we moved to Woods Hole where incubators were not available. An interesting point in connection with these stocks has to do with the geographical origins. It was thought possible that stocks from southern or tropical climates might show greater resistance to heat than those from farther north. That this idea has no basis in fact is obvious. Stocks from Sweden and North Dakota go as well at 31C. as those from Georgia and Florida. In the case of the stock collected at Attleboro, the results follow those found by Northrop with his stock. Three distinct trials failed to give any offspring beyond the first generation. In addition the stock has been tested at least as m~ny times more in another series of tests with identical results. This stock is as