STUDIES ON TOXICITY.

Fulmer EI, Buchanan RE. · 1923

Read STUDIES ON TOXICITY. by Fulmer EI, Buchanan RE. (1923) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/europmc-pmc2140618.txt.

Introduction

Ellis Fulmer and Buchanan, at Iowa State College in Ames, published studies on toxicity in 1923. Yeast was exposed to phenol, alone and with alcohol, and the survivors over time were counted by a stain test: living cells resist methylene blue, dead ones take it. Such survivor curves were often claimed to follow a simple logarithmic law.

In general the curves did not prove logarithmic. Resemblances to monomolecular reaction curves look superficial and accidental to the authors. Any rating of disinfecting power built on that supposed law must mislead, they argue. What truly shapes the death rate is the spread of resistance among individual cells: some are tough, some weak, and that distribution is of fundamental importance.

Catalog record

CREATORFulmer EI, Buchanan RE.
YEAR1923
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
LICENSEPublic Domain
RIGHTSPUBLIC DOMAIN
SOURCEEurope PMC

Source: https://europepmc.org/articles/PMC2140618

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

STUDIES ON TOXICITY By Ellis I. Fulmer, R. E. Buchanan Published in: The Journal of General Physiology DOI: 10.1085/jgp.6.1.77 ABSTRACT With yeast subjected to the action of phenol or of phenol and alcohol the curves of survivors as measured by resistance to staining with methylene blue when plotted against time do not in general prove to be logarithmic. It is believed that such resemblances as have been found between such curves and monomolecular reaction or logarithmic curves are superficial and fortuitous. Any method therefore of evaluating disinfecting power based upon such a concept must prove misleading. Variations in resistance of individual cells and the distribution of such variations must be regarded as of fundamental importance in accounting for rates of death of microorganisms. STUDIES ON TOXICITY. BYELLISI. FULMERAm)R. E. BUCHANAN. (FromtheLaboratoriesof Chemistryand of Baaeriology, Iowa State College,Ames.) (Receivedfor publication,July 19, 1923.) I. Criteria of Toxlcily toward Microorganisms. Extensive studies of the effect of toxic agents have been made in recent years upon both unicellular organisms and multicellular tissues. There have been many criteria of injury and death suggested and used, but terms have not always been employed by various writers in the same sense. The present paper is an attempt to indicate those criteria which have been found helpful when dealing with microorgan- isms, and particularly to point out the usefulness of staining reactions of cells in securing quantitative results on studies of toxicities. In general any agency or material which produces an injurious effect upon the normal functions of a cell may be characterized as toxic. If two or more such substances produce equal harmful e.ffects in equal lengths of time under otherwise uniform conditions they may be termed isotoxic. Commonly in such studies the observations are continued until all of the cells have undergone the maximum injury detectable by the criterion used. Several methods of detecting cell injury on the one hand or toxicity of materials on the other have been proposed. Among those which are apparently most useful for studies of microorganismsin that results may be followed quantitatively are the following: changes in rapidity of multiplication or power of reproduction, changes in the electrical conductivity of the cells, changes in the permeability of the cell membranes, plasmolysis, variations in rate of metabolism, and changes in the ability of the cell to stain with various dyes. In work with microorganisms, particularly with bacteria, the crite- rion of injury most frequently used has been the death of the cell as indicated by the complete loss of reproductive power. Antiseptics, 77 The Journal of General Physiology 78 STUDIES ON TOXICITY germicides, and disinfectants are toxic substances which more or less promptly kill cells as evidenced by their loss of reproductive capacity when replaced in a favorable environment. For representing graphi- cally the relationships'between time and the death of cells three types of graphs are in common use. The number or percentage of cells still living after varying intervals of contact with the toxic agent may be plotted against time, the curve thus secured is commonly termed the survivor's curve. Or the number of dead cells may be plotted against time of exposure, the resultant curve being termed the death curve. Or the number of cells which succumb during each equal interval of time may be plotted against time to constitute a rate curve, or dis- tribution curve. The area under the rate curve is proportional to the total number of cells, the area to the left of any point on the x axis is proportional to the total number of cells dead, the area to the right is proportional to the total number of cells still living. It is possible, therefore, to derive each curve from either of the others. Much study has been devoted by microbiologists to the forms which these curves assume, and to the development of simple equations to represent them. It is apparent that curves of the same general types as those used for survival or death of microorganisms may be used for the illustration of effects of toxic agents when some criterion of injury other than fail- ure to reproduce is used. A curve of the type of a survivor's curve may be plotted to show the relationship between time and cells not exhibit- ing the particular effect of the toxic agent. Possibly the term survi- vor's curve may well be used for all curves of this type provided it is clearly understood in each case that the criterion of a "survivor" is not necessarily ability to reproduce. A rate or distribution curve may also be plotted. There is some danger of confusion, however, if the term death curve is applied to a plot of time against the number of cells showing the change to be observed regardless of the criterion used. Possibly such a curve may be termed a toxicity curve. Many quantitative studies have been made of the effect of toxic agents in which changes in the electrical conductivity of cells has been the criterion of injury. The studies of Osterhout (1922), of Shearer (1919), and of Brooks (1923), are particularly interesting in their quantitative approach. The graph of electrical conductivity and ELLIS I. FULMER AND R. E. BUCHANAIN" 79 time may properly be developed as a toxicity curve, and solutions producing equal changes in electrical conductivity (or more usually the maximum change in conductivity) under otherwise identical con- ditions in equal lengths of time may be termed isotoxic with reference to this particular criterion. A similar toxicity curve might be con- structed as a graph of permeability against time. Of particular interest for the securing of quantitative data on toxic- ity are the methods which have been set forth in a series of papers from the University of Toronto on the general subject of chemical potential and toxicity. The detailed technique may be found in the papers by Miller (1920), Burgess (1920), Fraser (1920, 1921) and Fulmer (1921). In this series is sought an explanation of such phenomena as the increase of toxicity of phenol in aqueous solution when sodium chlo- ride, alcohol or other substances are added. Itwasfound that the addi- tion of NaC1 or alcohol to a solution of phenol in contact with an im- miscible solvent such as toluene or kerosene causes the phenol to become less concentrated in the water and pass in part to the other solvent. This fact may be expressed in one of several ways: the chemical potential of the phenol is increased; the fugacity or tendency of the phenol to escape is increased; the solubility of phenol in the aqueous phase is decreased; or the phenol is driven into the non-aque- ous phase. For these studies yeast cells were used generally, the criterion of injury first employed was the loss of the power of the cell to reproduce; i.e., death rates were determined by plating. Later the acquisition of the ability of the cells to stain with an aqueous solu- tion of methylene blue was taken as a second criterion of toxic action. It would seem that this criterion of injury is worthy of more atten- tion in toxicity studies. It has been shown that all cells which take up the stain are dead,

Read the complete text